logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
26m 56s

Pitching On LinkedIn Don't Work, Do This...

Donald C. Kelly
About this episode

LinkedIn is a goldmine for opportunities, but the challenge many sales reps are finding is that no one is responding to their messages after connecting. In this episode and the next one coming up, I’m sharing LinkedIn tips that provide the right touch to get prospects to start engaging with you. My research will help you network better and close deals, without resorting to those silly automated messages.

Why Sending Pitch Messages Is A Mistake?

  • Recently I did a LinkedIn poll that said, “When you accept a connection request, what percentage of them turn into pitches right after?” Out of the 316 people who responded to the survey, 60% of them received pitches in the next line of communication and did not like it.
  • My poll result shows that prospects really hate those automated LinkedIn messages, especially right after you just connected with them. Just because they match your ICP, doesn’t mean it gives you the authority to pitch your services. Your prospects aren’t machines who are just going to do business with you because you have a great product.
  • Sales reps who think that prospects are supposed to say yes to their first pitches often believe that sending out hundreds of automated LinkedIn messages works. It doesn’t, and you’re making it harder on yourself to close deals by doing it this way.

What Do Prospects Want?

  • I share more stats to help show you how to stop automating messages. For example, regarding content consumption, 40% of users between 30-49 consider LinkedIn as their primary news source. 
  • The stats I share show why people are even on LinkedIn, which is to grow their network, find industry insights, solve business problems, and engage with thought leaders.
  • From this research, you can see why your prospects are on LinkedIn: they’re trying to find answers, solve problems, and get news.

What Can You Do To Get Their Attention?

  • Instead of sending automated LinkedIn messages after a connection, consider sending, “Hey, thank you so much for connecting with me,” and then figure out a way you can connect back with them in the message. 
  • Prospects are networking to build a community; how can you become a part of their community without pitching to them right away? I share how you can keep the engagement going to help close a deal by simply being a friendly person.

“We’re polluting everything just for a short-term win, hoping to get by. But in reality, we’re damaging ourselves, our company, our careers, and our industry. The way we pitch on LinkedIn is why 30% of people are deleting messages after they see them.” - Donald Kelly. 

Resources

Connect and follow me on LinkedIn.

Do you need help with creating a podcast? Check out Bluë Mango Studios.

Join my LinkedIn Prospecting Course for more guidance. 

Sponsorship Offers

  1. This episode is brought to you in part by Hubspot.

With HubSpot sales hubs, your data tools and teams join a single platform to close deals and turn prospects into pipelines. Try it for yourself at hubspot.com/sales.

  1. This episode is brought to you in part by LinkedIn.

Are you tired of prospective clients not responding to your emails? Sign up for a free 60-day trial of LinkedIn Sales Navigator at

Up next
Aug 22
Why Your AI Sales Strategy Is Failing And How To Fix It | Doug Foley - 1926
Are you trying to use AI to speed up your sales cycle, only to find it's making your prospects' experience worse? The key is using technology to your advantage, not against you.In this episode, I'm joined by Doug Foley, an expert in sales enablement and AI integration. He shares ... Show More
32m 28s
Aug 18
The Easy 8-Step Framework to Win Enterprise Deals in the AI Era | Daren Fields - 1925
Today's buyers are more informed than ever, thanks to AI. Yet, they remain wary of sellers who rely on it too heavily, creating a unique challenge: How can you leverage technology to enhance your sales process without losing the authentic, personal connection that closes deals?To ... Show More
35m 47s
Aug 15
Stop Saying "Just Following"... Do This Instead! | Donald Kelly - 1924
After three to four follow-up emails, you start feeling like you're just an annoying fly to your prospects. Honestly, you're probably just buzzing their inboxes, especially if you're only sending simple "just checking in" messages. In this episode, I'll show you how to send follo ... Show More
15m 14s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2025
630: Marcus Sheridan - How To Build Trust, Drive Sales, and Earn Endless Customers
Go to www.LearningLeader.com for full show notes This is brought to you by Insight Global. If you need to hire 1 person, hire a team of people, or transform your business through Talent or Technical Services, Insight Global's team of 30,000 people around the world have the hustle ... Show More
1h 1m
Aug 2024
Pivoting to Success: The Tenbound Story
What if the key to your company’s success lay hidden in a challenge you’re currently facing? David Dulany's journey from sales frustration to creating a thriving business is a testament to this idea.In this episode of Sales Talk for CEOs, Alice Heiman speaks with David Dulan ... Show More
37m 6s
Dec 2024
Cigars, Salespeople, & Sales Training: Walter Crosby on The Sales Podcast
Walter Crosby and I discuss the unique challenges and processes involved in hiring and managing salespeople. Salespeople are coin-operated...and a little bit...strange. There. I said it. We get into what I always teach is a sales manager's #1 job. (And it's not to review your CRM ... Show More
57m 58s
Jun 27
5 Game-Changing Sales Insights from Q2 2025
The second quarter of 2025 delivered some incredible conversations on the Sales Gravy podcast. From discipline strategies that separate winners from wannabes to the psychology of selling that most reps completely miss, here are the five most powerful insights that can transform y ... Show More
18m 28s
Nov 2023
Ep 231 | Creating a Sales Strategy for 2024 with Harry Spaight
When you think about sales how does it make you feel? For most people they feel icky and greasy. Sales doesn't have to be that way. You can implement a sales strategy into your fundraising approach so that you have a constant stream of people coming into your network for you to b ... Show More
33m 20s
Oct 2024
Jerry Acuff Shares How To Create The Relationship Edge In Sales
In this episode of The Sales Podcast, I sit down with renowned sales expert Jerry Acuff to uncover his top strategies for building stronger relationships and driving sales success. https://bonus.thesalespodcast.com/ Jerry, the CEO and founder of Delta Point and the author of seve ... Show More
41m 18s
Jun 2024
The 7 Steps To Get People To Buy, With Cole Gordon
Professional Sales Tips you'll learn today on The Sales Podcast... Is sales dead? Is closing dead? For higher ticket sales, you need great salespeople MDR, SDR, Account Executives SDRs are reaching out cold (Sales Development Reps) MDRs reach out after you opt-in for something (M ... Show More
31m 9s
Jun 20
Mastering the 3 Deadliest Sales Objections | Andy Elliott
Andy’s Elite 1 on 1 ROLE PLAY SALES COACH where you can master any objection any closing scenario for any industry: https://elliott247.com/free-30-smIn this throwback video, Andy & Guest speaker Eric Cline go over the TOP TOUGHEST objections that most sales people face on a day t ... Show More
28m 8s
Jul 2024
From Problem to Product: Sujan Patel's Path to Mailshake
In 2015, Sujan Patel faced a common frustration: sales teams failing to follow up with prospects. His solution? Build a tool so effective that it turned into a successful company, Mailshake.In this episode, Alice Heiman talks with Sujan Patel, co-founder of Mailshake, about his j ... Show More
39m 19s
Jun 5
Sales Training // Jab Your Prospects, Flip The Script, Control the Sale // Learn How on The Sales Podcast with Wes Schaeffer, The Sales Whisperer®
#12WeeksToPeak #salestraining #SelfImprovement I'm going solo today to start year 13 of The Sales Podcast, episode 718.I updated an old blog post about "jabbing hard-charging" prospects to 'flip the script' in sales.Our job in sales is to disqualify prospects, engage them effecti ... Show More
28m 13s