logo
episode-header-image
Nov 15
36m 55s

The 'Should' You Never Questioned Is Fru...

COACHING CULTURE PODCAST

About this episode

Every "should" hides an expectation you never questioned — and that hidden expectation is quietly driving your frustration as a coach.


JP Nerbun, Betsy Butterick, and Nate Sanderson unpack the one word that complicates coaching and leadership: should. You'll learn how Byron Katie's four questions help you test the expectations behind your anger, how to enforce a standard without the story that a player doesn't care, and what to do when a player's shoulds collide with yours.


In this episode you'll discover:

• Why should is a trapdoor — and how to open it

• The 4 questions to ask when you catch yourself in a should

• How to hold the standard without living in the should

• How to listen and validate when shoulds collide, instead of defending

• Why acceptance is where change actually starts

• A simple breath + intention practice to regulate emotion in the moment so a should doesn't derail you or your players


TOC 3-2-1: 3 Quotes | 2 Questions | 1 Resource

"The word should is kind of like the trapdoor that reveals a whole lot underneath of it if you're willing to explore it." - Nate Sanderson

"Oftentimes we carry our own expectations of others that we're not living up to ourselves." - JP Nerbun

"The goal is not to avoid feeling something. The goal is to make sure it's a round trip, not a one-way ticket." - Betsy Butterick


KEY TAKEAWAYS

1. Should is a trapdoor. Open it.

2. Ask whether it is true, then ask who you would be without it.

3. Hold the standard without living in the should.

4. When shoulds collide, listen and validate before you defend.

5. Accept where you are so change can start.6. Feel it, then come back.


RESOURCE: Loving What Is by Byron Katie - https://thework.com/


Get the notes and tools: tocculture.com

Join TOC Coach:

Better Coaches. Better Leaders. Better Culture.


#CoachingCulture #TOCCoach #TeamCulture #LeadershipDevelopment #CoachingPodcast

Up next

Today
How to Run a More Effective Practice | Ep 482 | SAVI Basketball (Part 1)
A practice can be full of sweat and activity and still achieve very little. Your players need to know you can actually help them get better, and that starts with how you plan and run practice.In part one of a two-part conversation, JP Nerbun sits down with Tyler Coston and Mark C ... 
33m 15s
Nov 8
How to Create a High Performing Coaching Team | Patrick Lencioni | Episode 480
Your number one job as a head coach is not calling plays or runnYour number one job as a head coach is not calling plays or running practice. It is turning the coaches around you into a real team.In part two of JP Nerbun's conversation with Patrick Lencioni, author of The Five Dy ... 
38m 49s

Recommended Episodes

Jan 2025
EP94: Developing a Youth Program with Jon Yu & Neil Houghton (Part 1)
In this episode, Adam Omiecinski is joined by Jon Yu & Neil Houghton, their conversation encompasses the implementation of ecological dynamics frameworks and the challenges of player retention within a culturally different basketball coaching environment in Vietnam. Emphasis is p ... 
26m 8s
Sep 2021
How To Coach The Mental Game
In this episode, Jeff and Gene Zannetti talk about what you can do to help coach the mental game for your wrestler and in life. Learn some useful tips and implement it for this upcoming wrestling season! 1:40 Training paradox 3:16 What NOT to do 12:00 Ideal Mental Training 20:17 ... 
43m 48s
Aug 2020
Put Me in Coach!
How do you motivate your kids to take sports seriously without getting too competitive?? That’s what Mike aims to learn from a conversation with legendary soccer player Christie Pearce Rampone and neuropsychologist Dr. Kristine Keane. Mike opens up about his own anxieties about J ... 
44m 33s
Sep 2021
How to Manage the Toughest Moments of Elite Competitions
<p>In this sports psychology podcast, Dr. Patrick Cohn interviews a former swimmer and now a mental advocate Kimberly Karducci.</p> <p>They discuss mental health issues and how to best manage the toughest moments of elite competitions. They also talked about her reasons for becom ... 
17m 34s
May 2025
Mental Performance Tips for Sports Parents
Mental Performance Tips for Sports Parents | Sports Psychology Podcast In this episode, we help sports parents separate the athlete from the person. We discuss how to help athletes not be defined by just their sports performance. Dr. Patrick Cohn is a master mental performance co ... 
8m 6s
Aug 2025
Mindset Tips for Navigating Social Media
Mindset Tips for Navigating Social Media | Sports Psychology Podcast In this episode, you will learn strategies to manage social media as an athlete in today's society. We discuss how to keep your focus solely on competing. Dr. Patrick Cohn is a master mental performance coach wh ... 
8m 2s
Aug 2021
Helping Athletes Manage High Expectations
<p>In this sports psychology video, Dr. Cohn helps athletes improve their mental game for sports. Learn how to get your mindset right when you compete so you can perform your best. In this podcast, you learn about how athletes place expectations on themselves and also feel them f ... 
6m 19s
Jan 2024
Episode 302: J.P. Nerbun, Sport Parent Solutions and Culture
Guest: JP Nerbun, Leadership Coach and ConsultantIn this week's coaching conversation, leadership coach and consultant J.P. Nerbun joins the Basketball Podcast to share insights on sport parent solutions and culture. J.P. Nerbun is a bestselling author, leadership coach, and foun ... 
52m 49s
Dec 2022
How to Take Meaningful Action
Send us Fan MailCoach Jack asks himself a series of questions when he's deciding what action to take. These questions help him stay true to himself and maximize his time. Learn about this method in this week's episode of Off The Court.Download our FREE 25 page EBook: How to Unloc ... 
8m 56s