logo
episode-header-image
Jul 7
1 h

248: The Anxious Generation Review (Part...

JEN LUMANLAN
About this episode
In Part 1 of this mini-series looking at Jonathan Haidt's book The Anxious Generation, we discovered that the teen mental health crisis might not be as dramatic as The Anxious Generation claims - and that changes in diagnosis and coding could be inflating the numbers. But even if we accept that teens' struggles have increased somewhat, the next crucial question is: what's actually causing the change?   Jonathan Haidt is adamant that social media causes depression and anxiety in teenagers. He claims that "dozens of experiments" prove social media use is a CAUSE, not just a correlate, of mental health problems. But when you dig into the studies, as we do in this episode, we'll see that the 'causal' data is nowhere near as strong as Haidt claims.   We'll examine the experimental evidence behind social media and teen mental health claims, reveal why leading researchers compare social media effects on teens to eating potatoes, and uncover what factors actually explain 99% of youth mental health outcomes. Because if we're going to spend time and energy helping our kids, we want to make sure we're spending it doing things that will actually help.  

Questions This Episode Will Answer

Does social media really cause teen depression and anxiety? Research shows correlation, not proven causation, with social media effects on teens explaining less than 1% of wellbeing, similar to the effect of eating potatoes. (Some researchers argue that this is still important enough to pay attention to - the episode explores why.)   Why do I keep hearing that social media is harmful if the research is weak? Many (but not all) social media studies find some evidence of harm, but when you look at the methodology this isn't surprising - researchers do things like sending participants daily reminders that "limiting social media is good for you," and then asking them how much social media they've consumed and how they feel. It's hard to draw strong conclusions from this data!   How can different studies on social media show opposite results? Researchers studying teen social media use can get completely different results from the same data depending on how they choose to analyze it. The episode looks at those choices and what they mean for understanding whether social media causes kids' depression and anxiety.   Is limiting my teen's social media use actually going to help them? Current evidence suggests that some kids who use social media a lot are vulnerable to experiencing depression and anxiety, and limiting their use specifically may be protective. There is little evidence to support the idea that blanket bans on kids' social media/smart phone usage will result in dramatic improvements in youth mental health, and focusing on issues that are more clearly connected to mental health would likely have a greater positive impact.  

What You'll Learn in This Episode

  • How most social media research creates results that don't tell us what we want to know (but then reports the results as if they do)
  • How the same teen mental health data can be analyzed to support opposite conclusions about social media effects on teens
  • What family relationships, academic pressure, and economic stress reveal about the real drivers of youth mental health issues
  • How social media and teen mental health correlations explain the same amount of variance as seemingly irrelevant factors like potato consumption
  • How researcher bias and study design flaws make social media studies less reliable than parents think
  • What happens when kids who benefit from social media lose access to it
  • Why the focus on teen social media...
Up next
Jun 30
247: The Anxious Generation Review (Part 1): Is There Really a Mental Health Crisis in the U.S.?
Are we really facing an unprecedented mental health crisis in America, or have we been misreading the data? As parents everywhere grapple with The Anxious Generation's claims that smartphones are rewiring our children's brains, this episode takes a closer look at what the researc ... Show More
1 h
May 26
246: My Parenting Feels Off Track: Reparenting Helps You Find Your Way Back
Do you ever feel like your parenting is completely off track from where you want it to be? You promise yourself you won't yell, then find yourself yelling at your kids before breakfast. You intend to be patient and present, but end up getting distracted by your phone, or snapping ... Show More
47m 2s
May 19
RE-RELEASE: Finding Your Parenting Village: How Community Support Changes Everything at Home
Are you tired of facing family challenges alone? In this powerful episode, we witness the transformative journey of two parents who discovered that joining a parenting support group can change everything at home. Parenting wasn't meant to be a solo journey. When sleep deprivation ... Show More
51m 18s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
#1 Menopause Doctor: 5 Daily Habits to Sleep Better, Feel Healthier, and Beat Menopausal Belly Fat
Have you saved your seats at Summit of Greatness 2024 yet?! Get them before they sell out at lewishowes.com/ticketsToday, we welcome Dr. Mary Claire Haver, who delves into the critical and often overlooked topic of menopause. Dr. Haver discusses the alarming lack of education and ... Show More
1h 17m
Jul 2024
588: The Metabolic Trifecta in Perimenopause and Menopause + HRT Basics and Best Practices to Thrive in Midlife with Jackie Piasta
Frustrated with not feeling heard by your primary care doc?  You’re not the only one who feels like your menopause symptoms and concerns are getting dismissed.  As women, we go through a whirlwind of changes– physically, emotionally, and hormonally– during perimenopause and menop ... Show More
1h 8m
Dec 2024
What Is Menopause?
Hot flashes, brain fog, sleepless nights—menopause is often shrouded in mystery and stigma. But what if it didn’t have to be? In this episode, we’re joined by, Dr. Louise Newson, a trailblazing GP and menopause specialist who’s work is transforming how the world understands this ... Show More
54m 20s
Mar 2025
433 - The Truth About Menopause EVERY Woman Needs to Hear with Tamsen Fadal
Is menopause really the end of feeling like yourself? In this powerful conversation, Tamsen Fadal breaks down the myths about menopause and shares science-backed solutions for managing symptoms, reclaiming your energy, and thriving through midlife. @TamsenFadal, Emmy Award-winnin ... Show More
43m 44s
Nov 2023
314: Insulin Resistance, Weight Gain and Exercise in Perimenopause & Menopause with Adele Johnston
Adele Johnston is on a mission to make menopause mainstream, and she’s back today for part two of our discussion about the journey into perimenopause and menopause. A world-leading and highly sought-after menopause expert, Adele is committed to breaking down female health taboos, ... Show More
50m 31s
Oct 2024
Honoring Every Phase of Womanhood EP28
There’s no doubt that women experience so much, both physically and emotionally. From our monthly cycles to the unpredictability of menopause, it's astounding how much we endure and yet thrive through.    Have you ever wondered why it feels so hard to live under the expectations ... Show More
22m 34s
Oct 2024
601: The Food You Eat Will Impact Your Menopause Journey + Foods to Ease Menopause and Promote Longevity with Dr. Federica Amati
It’s no secret that our bodies have to endure dramatic metabolic shifts throughout perimenopause, menopause, and beyond.  Things that used to feel effortless—like keeping your energy, mood, and weight in check—now take everything you’ve got. But what if there was an easier way?A ... Show More
59m 57s
Jan 2025
Dr. Mary Claire Haver: The Critical Truth About Women's Health After 30 & The Menopause Revolution | EP 857
Have you listened to the FULL EPISODE yet?"Osteoporosis is real and 50 percent of women will have an osteoporotic fracture before they die. If you fall and break your hip, your chance of death in one year is 30 percent with surgery." - Dr. Mary Claire HaverIn this eye-opening con ... Show More
7m 4s
Jun 2024
402 - Surprising (GOOD) News About Menopause | Lisa Mosconi
"Meopause Brain" is real. But it doesn't have to give you hot flashes and brain fog or destroy your libido. There's no shortage of bad news when it comes to menopause. But new science reveals menopause is NOT the beginning of the end. In today's #MarieTV, Dr. Lisa Mosconi — one o ... Show More
1h 23m
Sep 2022
Menopause
The menopause marks the permanent end to the reproductive phase of life and happens at an average age of 51. Symptoms can be significant and affect many body systems. In this podcast, Dr Anne Connolly discussed contraception in the perimenopausal years, the management of a woman ... Show More
18m 21s