logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
24m 59s

272 - Breaking Free from "Protein Prison...

Maggie Sterling
About this episode

Are you stuck in "protein prison" - forcing yourself to eat foods you don't even like in the name of weight loss? In this episode, Maggie and Ryan explore the complicated relationship between nutrition choices and diet mentality, diving into why our reasons for eating certain foods matter more than the foods themselves. They discuss how many women get trapped in patterns of restriction and binging when they prioritize "healthy eating" without considering mental satisfaction. If you've ever choked down Greek yogurt mixed with protein powder while secretly craving something else, this conversation about finding balance without sacrificing results is for you.

Click here to join vibe club

03:20: Diet mentality is about energy, beliefs, and thoughts - not specific foods.

07:00: "Protein prison" happens when forcing yourself to eat protein you dislike, causing mental dissatisfaction.

10:20: Choosing foods that make you feel good isn't diet mentality if your reasons are balanced.

14:50: Finding balance often requires swinging to extremes first before settling in the middle.

18:30: Ryan's experience losing muscle when not prioritizing protein he enjoys.

21:30: When to move beyond food neutrality toward intentional choices that support goals.

Up next
Nov 13
New Course- The Overeating Solution Available NOW
Get the course here! https://www.vibewithmaggie.com/course/the-overeating-solution 
1m 51s
Sep 12
296 - Your Weight Problem Isn't About Food
<p>You've tried every diet, counted every calorie, and switched up your workout routine more times than you can remember - but you still feel completely out of control around food. What if the reason you can't stop overeating has nothing to do with willpower, meal plans, or even ... Show More
13m 54s
Sep 5
295 - The End of Why We Overeat (And What's Next)
<p>After nearly six years of podcasting, Maggie and Ryan make a major announcement about the future of Why We Overeat. They share the honest truth about why they've decided to end this podcast and what they've learned about the limitations of staying focused on certain topics. Th ... Show More
19m 8s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
When Calorie Counting Doesn’t ‘Work’ For You
We&apos;re tackling a topic that always gets people talking—counting calories! If counting calories works for you, great! But if tracking every bite or obsessing over your food app has ever made you anxious, this episode is for you! In this episode, we&apos;ll talk about why calo ... Show More
10m 15s
Apr 2023
Three Versions Of Healthy Eating
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
20m 27s
Feb 2025
Why Small Changes Make a Big Difference When Losing Weight
<p>For years, this bitch living in my brain kept telling me, "If you just tried harder... if you just had more discipline... then you'd lose the weight."</p> <p>Maybe you know her too?</p> <p>She's the one who makes you feel like you're broken every time life gets in the way of y ... Show More
18m 36s
Jun 2024
169. You Can't Force Weight Loss
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
14m 2s
Jun 2025
198. How To Stop Thinking About Food All Day
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
25m 51s
May 2025
196. Healthy Eating with Human Error
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
25m 54s
Aug 2024
How to Not Overeat Your Favorite Foods
Today you're getting a behind-the-scenes look at how I coach on the #1 thing women struggle with in weightloss. It's a type of overeating that: Stalls weightloss and/or causes you to quit Gives you alllll the guilt and shame Destroys your relationship with your favorite foods Wan ... Show More
48m 34s
Jun 2024
170. How To Enjoy Food More Without Overeating
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
14m 8s
Jun 2025
FOMO Eating: What to do if you think "I might not get this again"
<p>Ever feel like you <em>have</em> to eat something because you might not get it again?</p> <p>You're not hungry, but the second you see it—your brain screams, "Don't miss out!"</p> <p>That's food FOMO. And it's sneaky.</p> <p>One minute, you're trying to eat better. The next? Y ... Show More
15m 7s
May 2023
Performance Healthy Eating
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
20m 3s