logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2025
1h 1m

Hannah Brencher: Friendship Rejections &...

Alice Draper
About this episode

Hannah Brencher has built a career around sharing her life openly, but at what cost? In this episode, she gets brutally honest about the dark side of public vulnerability, the pressure to turn your life into content, and the raw reality of rejection.

She shares the moment she realized she was burning out from oversharing, the painful lesson of being turned into content herself, and why one friend muted her on Instagram because her life seemed too perfect.

Ever had a moment where you thought, maybe I should stop putting my life online? This episode is for you.

In This Episode, We Cover:

  • The moment Hannah realized her personal storytelling was harming her mental health
  • Why social media makes friendships more complicated than ever
  • The fear of rejection—and why it hurts so much when you're trying to be kind
  • What happens when you stop seeking external validation online
  • How to be vulnerable without losing your sense of self


Links & Resources:

Read Hannah’s book The Unplugged Hours: https://www.amazon.com/Unplugged-Hours-Cultivating-Digitally-Connected/dp/0310367700
Visit Hannah’s website: https://hannahbrencher.com
Join Hannah’s newsletter: https://hannahbrencher.com/newsletter/
Follow Hannah on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hannahbrencher/

Chapters:


00:00 Why Hannah Stopped Turning Her Life Into Content
06:23 The Boyfriend Who Didn’t Want to Be “Content”
12:45 The Blog Post That Ended a Friendship
18:10 Rejected at the Doorstep—The Christmas Cookie Story
24:35 A Therapist Was Discussing Hannah’s Depression in Someone Else’s Therapy Session
30:52 The Friend Who Muted Her on Instagram
38:17 Why Being the “Main Character” in Your Own Story Can Be Dangerous
45:50 How to Protect Your Personal Life While Still Sharing Your Story

Don't forget to subscribe, leave a review, and tag us on Instagram with your thoughts on this episode.

Up next
Oct 8
Tara Jaye Frank: Leaving A Marriage, Learning Through Publisher’s Rejection, & The Helper’s Dilemma
In this episode, bestselling author and former Hallmark executive Tara Jaye Frank joins Alice to talk about the messy, courageous process of letting go—of careers, of marriages, and of identities that no longer fit. From leaving a long-term marriage to walking away from a lucrati ... Show More
57m 18s
Sep 24
Jamie Varon on Delayed Gratification versus Instant Gratification & How To Detach From Results
What if success takes longer than expected?In this reflective and empowering episode, writer and creative entrepreneur Jamie Varon joins My Rejection Story to talk about the uncomfortable space between effort and outcome. We dig deep into the psychology of delayed gratification v ... Show More
21m 56s
Sep 17
Arielle Estoria on The Human Need for Belonging & Unfolding
What if the fear of rejection is actually a fear of being fully seen?In this poetic and soul-searching episode, author and spoken word artist Arielle Estoria opens up about what it means to grow beyond who the world expects you to be—and how devastating, liberating, and cyclical ... Show More
46m 43s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2024
Turning Community Support Into Global Poetry Success | Rupi Kaur EP 828
Have you listened to the FULL EPISODE yet?"I had no access point to this 'industry' of publishing and literature. But what I had was a community on Tumblr and Instagram of young women who felt so seen by these words." - Rupi KaurAt just 21 years old, Rupi Kaur defied traditional ... Show More
7m 51s
Mar 2025
how to turn REJECTION into GROWTH: the best revenge to overcome hurt, regain confidence, & move forward | REDEMPTION ARC
Rejection is your SUPER POWER… The greatest form of revenge, is using rejection to FUEL your passion instead of putting it out. If you’ve felt rejected, you know how hard it can be to let go/forgive, or move on from the past. The truth about rejection, is it’s actually a GIFT onc ... Show More
21m 39s
Sep 2023
Trevor Noah & Jay Shetty: When You Feel Lost In Life
Today's motivation covers feeling lost, gratitude, and identity. Audio Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5BHutz6P-g Quote of the Day: “We spend so much time being afraid of failure, afraid of rejection. But regret is the thing we should fear most. Failure is an answer. ... Show More
22m 22s
Jan 2025
Mel Robbins: The Life-Changing 'Let Them Theory' to Overcome Fear, Self-Doubt, and Build Stronger Relationships in Work, Love, and Friendships
How would your life change if you stopped worrying about what others think and started living for yourself? In this empowering episode, Marianna sits down with Mel Robbins, renowned motivational speaker and author, to discuss how to break free from fear and judgment, and take bol ... Show More
49m 33s
Sep 29
Overcoming the Odds: She grew up on a cotton farm as one of 17 children and overcame domestic violence, and poverty.
Two-time Emmy and Three-time NAACP Image Award-winning, television Executive Producer Rushion McDonald interviewed Mildred J. Mills. Topic: Life journey, resilience, and her memoir Daddy’s House: A Daughter’s Memoir of Setbacks, Triumphs, and Rising Above Her Roots Mildred J. Mil ... Show More
31m 41s
Apr 2025
Stop Waiting. Start Living. Why You Feel Stuck - And How to Break Free and Reinvent Your Life | Natalie MacNeil (Fan Fav)
Lisa Bilyeu sits down with Emmy Award–winning entrepreneur, author, and creator of She Takes on the World, Natalie MacNeil. From launching her first company at just 21 to becoming a guiding force for women ready to embrace their full selves in business, Natalie shares her candid ... Show More
51m 9s
Sep 3
Fear of Rejection
Fear of rejection is one of the biggest hurdles in dating, often holding people back from putting themselves out there or forming deeper connections. In this episode, we unpack where this fear comes from, how it ties into past experiences and self-worth, and why rejection is not ... Show More
46m 42s
Jul 2023
4 Ways to Stop Fearing Rejection and Start Feeling Confident
When you see an attractive woman you’d love to meet, fear of rejection likely holds you back. “What if she doesn’t like me?,” you think. Or if you want to go for a first-date kiss, the R-word paralyzes you, and you worry, “What if she turns away?” Hello, Friend Zone. In dating, f ... Show More
36m 31s
Jul 2023
Brianna Holt, "In Our Shoes: On Being a Young Black Woman in Not-So 'Post-Racial' America" (Plume Books, 2023)
Part memoir, part cultural critique, In Our Shoes: On Being a Young Black Woman in Not-So 'Post-Racial' America (Plume Books, 2023) uses pop culture and author Brianna Holt’s own lived experience to dissect the stereotypes and preconceived notions that young Black women must over ... Show More
43m 17s