logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2025
48m 7s

#548: Disordered Eating and Body Image i...

Danny Lennon
About this episode

Fitness pursuits can bring various benefits. However, within the modern fitness industry there is a complex interplay of body image ideals, societal pressures, and disordered eating behaviors.

Research continues to illuminate how certain practices and messaging within the industry—such as the overvaluation of leanness or the impact of social media personas—can fuel body dissatisfaction and disordered eating.

For fitness coaches and enthusiasts alike, this raises important questions:

  • What defines success in fitness?
  • How can individuals engage in training and nutrition without falling into harmful traps?
  • And how can professionals align their practices with values that support long-term well-being for themselves and their clients?

In this episode, Michelle Carroll, a PhD researcher in clinical psychology, explores these questions in depth. Drawing on her academic work and personal experiences, she discusses the implications of fitness industry norms, the challenges of online coaching, and practical steps for fostering healthier relationships with food and body image.

Timestamps
  • [01:15] Defining disordered eating and body image
  • [03:47] Motivations behind this research
  • [05:37] Impact of the fitness industry on body image
  • [08:29] Challenges and misconceptions about body image
  • [14:26] Physical capital and pressures on fitness professionals
  • [18:20] Consequences of harmful fitness industry messaging
  • [35:04] Positive changes and gaps for future research
  • [40:16] Practical advice for professionals and individuals
Related Resources
Up next
Yesterday
#569: The History of Fat, Cholesterol & Heart Disease
The idea that saturated fat might be harmful to our health has sparked controversy for decades. In recent years, counter-narratives have surged: suggesting that concerns over saturated fat were overblown, that LDL cholesterol doesn’t matter, or that the original diet-heart hypoth ... Show More
1h 16m
Jul 1
#568: Does the Maternal Diet Impact Risk of ADHD & Autism? – David Horner, PhD
To what extent can maternal nutrition during pregnancy influence a child’s later cognitive or behavioural development? While genetic and environmental factors are known to contribute to neurodevelopmental outcomes such as ADHD and autism, growing attention is being paid to the po ... Show More
45m 1s
Jun 24
#567: Did Big Sugar Hijack the Food Pyramid? Were Low-fat Diets a Scam that Damaged Our Health?
For decades, dietary guidelines—and the Food Pyramid in particular—have been at the center of heated debates and considerable controversy. These guidelines have often been accused of being influenced by industry interests, oversimplifying nutritional nuance, or even directly cont ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
Eating Disorders and Body Image: Research, Teaching Students and Inspiring Change, with Dr. Kamila Irvine
Today I’m talking to Dr. Kamila Irvine who is senior lecturer in Psychology at Lincoln University. Kamila specialises in body image and eating disorders and is particularly interested in perceptual body image and size/shape estimation. Kamila completed her PhD at Northumbria Univ ... Show More
40m 5s
Aug 2024
#326: Body Image: What the Evidence Really Says, with Charlotte Markey
Psychologist and body-image researcher Charlotte Markey joins us to discuss myths and misinformation about body image, how chronic illness and pain affect perceptions of our bodies, the body positivity vs. body neutrality debate, the potential body-image harms of social media (an ... Show More
43m 2s
Nov 2024
NLP621 - Finding Freedom: Chelsey's Transformation from Disordered Eating to Empowerment
This week's guest, and Next Level Nutrition coach Chelsey, opens up about overcoming disordered eating without formal treatment and the challenges of societal pressures, especially before her wedding. We explore her journey through functional health, gut issues, and a break from ... Show More
46m 42s
Jan 2025
Midlife Body Positivity & Realistic Fitness Goals with Nathalia Melo
Nathalia Melo, a bikini Olympian champion, mother of two, wife, and globally recognized fitness coach shares her incredible journey from humble beginnings in Brazil to winning the first bikini Olympia in 2012. This episode dives deep into the realities of the fitness industry, tr ... Show More
1h 35m
Feb 2025
Eating Disorder Recovery and Navigating Health and Fitness with Hope, Habits, Happiness and Health, with Michelle Rosko
Today I’m talking to Michelle Rosko, who is a holistic health & fitness coach, certified personal trainer, & nutrition coach. Michelle has been on her own eating disorder recovery journey and now comes to the health and fitness space with a compassionate, sustainable, & holistic ... Show More
31m 39s
Oct 2024
2746: Break Free From the Ugly Side of Health and Fitness by Nia Shanks on Negative Body Image
Discover all of the podcasts in our network, search for specific episodes, get the Optimal Living Daily workbook, and learn more at: OLDPodcast.com.Episode 2746:Nia Shanks critiques the health and fitness industry for promoting superficial goals like losing fat and fixing "flaws, ... Show More
10m 35s
Oct 2022
#228 ‒ Improving body composition, female-specific training principles, and overcoming an eating disorder | Holly Baxter, APD
View the Show Notes Page for This Episode Become a Member to Receive Exclusive Content Sign Up to Receive Peter’s Weekly Newsletter Holly Baxter is an accredited practicing dietician (APD), competitive bodybuilder, fitness and nutrition educator, and coach. In this episode, Holly ... Show More
2h 15m
Jul 2024
Episode 71 - Body Image and Eating Disorders - with Harriet Frew
The episode featured an interview with Harriet Frew, a BACP accredited counsellor and eating disorder practitioner. Harriet shared her expertise on the topic of body image and how it relates to eating disorders.  Some of the key points discussed: - The definition of body image an ... Show More
38m 12s
Aug 2024
A Deep Dive into Body Image with Dr. Charlotte Markey
Today I’m talking to Charlotte Markey, Ph.D., who  is a world-leading expert in body image research, having studied body image and eating behaviors for nearly three decades.  She is passionate about understanding how to help people have a healthy relationship with their body and ... Show More
41m 20s
Jan 2025
World-Renowned Personal Trainer: How To Lose Fat, Build Muscle and Improve Your Mental Health | Senada Greca
Get ready for an incredibly raw and inspiring conversation with fitness phenomenon Seneda Greca. From immigrating to America as a teenager and battling eating disorders to becoming one of the most influential figures in women's strength training, Seneda opens up about her remarka ... Show More
1h 18m