logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2024
1 h

Overthinking About Crushes

Amanda Montell & Studio71
About this episode

Before the internet, getting lost in a spiral of romantic, obsessive feelings for someone was already an all-consuming experience… but now? With algorithmic dating apps and the ability to overanalyze everyone watching your Instagram Stories, crushes in the digital age are ripe for delulu. In some cases, they might even pose a threat to IRL human connection. This week on the pod, OCD specialist Alegra Kastens (@alegrakastens) joins host Amanda Montell (@amanda_montell) for an open-hearted, all-too-relatable discussion of limerence, neurodivergence, and how crushes have combined with the social media era to produce a perfectly chaotic cocktail of magical overthinking.

- Join the "Magical Overthinkers Club" by following the pod on Instagram @magicaloverthinkers.

- To access early, ad-free episodes and more, subscribe to the Magical Overthinkers Substack.

- Pick up a hard copy of Amanda's book The Age of Magical Overthinking: Notes on Modern Irrationality, or listen to the audiobook.

- Sources:

What causes a crush to develop?

Is it a crush or have you fallen into limerence?

Why your internet crush can be stronger than your in-person feelings

Office crushes can be fun and excrutiating

Why crushes are so common, and healthy, at all ages


To watch the podcast on YouTube: https://bit.ly/MagicalOverthinkersYouTube ; Don’t forget to subscribe to the podcast for free wherever you're listening

If you like the show, telling a friend about it would be amazing! You can text, DM, email, or send this link to a friend: https://bit.ly/MagicalOverthinkers 

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Up next
Jun 25
Overthinking About Opinion Overload
In an age where everyone has to have a hot take, how does this shape our inner voice? This week, host Amanda Montell (@amanda_montell) is joined by journalist Fortesa Latifi (@hifortesa) to unpack the emotional weight of opinion overload: the pressure to react, post, and declare ... Show More
53m 7s
Jun 11
Overthinking About Personality
How much of who you are is really you—and how much is habit, circumstance, or a story you started telling yourself a long time ago? This week, host Amanda Montell (@amanda_montell) is joined by journalist and author Olga Khazan (@olganator) to explore the strange, sticky concept ... Show More
55m 33s
May 28
Overthinking About Billionaire Worship
Why do we, against all logic, evidence, and bank account balances, still kind of believe that billionaires earned it? This week on Magical Overthinkers, host Amanda Montell (@amanda_montell) sits down with writer and cultural critic Dasia Sade (@dasiadoesit) to unravel the glitte ... Show More
1h 5m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2022
#brunchtalk: How to handle your SO's flirty friend
You're trying your best not to be the jealous type...but even the best of us can be triggered. On this week’s brunch talk we’re talking about how to not loose your shit when your partner's ex or just flirty friend comes around, how to maintain your confidence in your rela ... Show More
25m 1s
Apr 3
116. Not for Rage Bait + The Real Reason Your Friends Never Take Your Advice
Get up to 10 FREE meals at https://hellofresh.com/NOTFOREVERYONE10FM__Hello babies! Have you ever flirted to get something you want? Jess starts the episode off talking about her trip to NYC and a flirting method she used to get her boyfriend on the flight back. This leads to a d ... Show More
1h 13m
Nov 2024
(Matt Monday): How to Stop Obsessing in Early Dating
How do you stop obsessing over someone you’ve recently started dating? When someone seems to tick all our boxes, it can be hard to NOT become flooded with thoughts of a possible future together. We anxiously wait for their text. We put them on a pedestal . . . and as a result, po ... Show More
21m 1s
Aug 2024
257: Don't Let Your Anxiety Sabotage Your Relationships (What To Do Instead!)
There are many ways anxiety can show up in our relationships. When we like someone and worry about them losing interest. When we're waiting for a text back. When we overthink in a relationship.  In this episode, Matt and Audrey talk about the fears that activate anxious behavior ... Show More
42m 27s
Jan 2023
Double Timing College Boy
Today's episode is all about boundaries and expectations. In one story, we have a girl who has a crush, and although things seem fun and flirty, reality strikes when she remembers he has a girlfriend and his actions are disrespectful. Drawing out those boundaries and setting expe ... Show More
59m 12s
May 2
816: FRIDAY FAVE | How To Stop Being Indecisive & Make BIG DECISIONS
Welcome to Friday Favorites! Over the last eight years, we’ve had some incredible conversations with world-class experts, inspiring guests, and, of course, YOU. This series is all about revisiting the episodes that have stood the test of time as listener favorites. This also give ... Show More
48m 57s
Apr 9
291: How to Flirt When You’re Not Confident
In this episode of the Love Life Podcast, Matthew, Audrey, Stephen, and producer David dive deep into one of the most common struggles in dating: flirting. So many people feel stuck when it comes to creating chemistry, worrying they'll come off as desperate, awkward, or get rejec ... Show More
1 h
Sep 2023
How to Survive an Apocalypse, Teeth with Secrets, Birds Who BBQ
Annalee Newitz discusses how to survive an apocalypse while eating good, Rachel talks about birds using spikes as barbecue skewers (and more), and Chelsey gets into sexing skeletons. The Weirdest Thing I Learned This Week is a podcast by Popular Science. Share your weirdest facts ... Show More
51m 4s
Jun 2023
S16E20: Finding Love At Any Age w/ May Lee
Gone are the days when you need to lock it down before you're 30 – we're firm believers that you can find love at any age! We're chatting with another fan favorite, former CNN journalist May Lee, about how she's now engaged for the first time at age 57 – and could ... Show More
1h 23m
Mar 2025
113. Love Letter: How to Forgive and Forget in Friendship + Keeping Dating FUN in Your 30s | ft. My BFF Ekaette Obot
Check out the Fits Everybody Collection at https://www.skims.com/notforeveryone #skimspartnerStart with 50% off your first box with code notforeveryone50 at https://get.everyplate.com/podcast. EveryPlate offer valid with auto-renewing subscription. __Jess has told us the greatest ... Show More
1h 33m