logo
episode-header-image
Nov 20
12m 5s

Q&A 12 Your Questions About Becoming Som...

Weight Loss Mindset
About this episode

Addressing the real fears and challenges of identity transformation.

This Q&A episode tackles common concerns about changing your food-related identity, from feeling "fake" when trying new behaviors to handling setbacks and unsupportive people during your transformation journey.

Important Points Covered

1. Identity Isn't Permanent - It's Learned

The belief "I'm someone who struggles with food" isn't who you ARE, it's who you've LEARNED to be. You weren't born struggling with food - you learned these patterns and can unlearn them. Try shifting from "I struggle with food" to "I'm learning to have a healthy relationship with food."

2. Feeling "Fake" Is Normal and Necessary

Acting like your new identity feels uncomfortable at first because you're trying on new behaviors. This isn't evidence you can't change - it's evidence you're growing. Authenticity comes AFTER behavior change, not before. Keep acting like your new identity even when it feels weird.

3. Setbacks Don't Erase Progress

One binge doesn't cancel three days of evidence collection. Old patterns will surge back as your brain tries to maintain familiar territory. Handle setbacks like someone who naturally takes care of their body: see them as information, not failure. Don't let one setback erase multiple days of growth.

4. Realistic Timeline for Identity Shifts

Small shifts happen within 1-2 weeks, deeper integration takes 2-3 months, and full identity transformation typically requires 6-12 months. Unlike diets that get harder over time, identity work gets easier as you collect more evidence and strengthen new neural pathways.

5. Handling Unsupportive People

Family and friends may resist your changes because your growth threatens their comfort zone. Set gentle boundaries and don't let their discomfort stop your transformation. Your job isn't to make everyone comfortable with your growth - it's to become who you're meant to be.

Continue collecting evidence for your new identity one small choice at a time.

Don't aim for perfection - aim for consistency. Trust that you can become someone who naturally takes care of their body, even when it feels unfamiliar. Keep sending questions about identity work as this is where real transformation happens.

Key Takeaway

"Identity change isn't about perfection - it's about consistency. You're not just changing what you do, you're changing who you are. And that changes everything. Feeling uncomfortable during the process is evidence you're growing, not evidence you can't change."

Up next
Feb 2024
Silencing the Inner Critic: Embracing Self-Compassion on Your Weight Loss Journey
Show NotesSummary:This episode dives deep into the transformative power of self-compassion on your weight loss journey. Host Rick Taylar guides you through the process of silencing your inner critic and cultivating a supportive inner champion. Learn how self-compassion can boost ... Show More
13m 57s
Feb 2024
Sleep and Weight Loss: Exploring the Link Between Sleep Deprivation and Weight Gain
Show Notes:Summary:In this insightful episode, host Rick Taylar explores the intriguing connection between sleep deprivation and weight gain.  We delve deep into how lack of quality sleep could be sabotaging our weight loss efforts and mental and physical health. The discussion f ... Show More
15m 13s
Jan 2024
Embracing Discomfort for Successful Weight Loss
Show NotesSummary:Thank you for tuning into today's episode! Below you'll find the key points we covered, along with strategies to help you navigate the discomforts of weight loss. We've also included some valuable resources for further reading and learning. And re ... Show More
21m 33s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2025
198. How To Stop Thinking About Food All Day
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
25m 51s
Aug 4
Mastering Mindful Eating When Your Day Won’t Slow Down
Welcome to my Summer Throwback Playlist—a handpicked collection of the most downloaded episodes of the podcast. These are listener favorites, packed with insights, laughs, and empowered eating encouragement to keep you fueled all summer long. A quick heads up: since these are thr ... Show More
14m 48s
Jul 2025
Ep 300 Why you're overwhelmed with food (and how to finally feel free)
<p><span style="font-weight: 400;">Have you ever wondered why you keep struggling with food, even when you know what to do? Why can you be successful in so many areas of life, yet feel stuck in an exhausting cycle of overeating, dieting, and self-criticism? If you've tried everyt ... Show More
19m 18s
Aug 15
292 - Top 4 Mindful Eating Habits
<p>Ever feel like you're doing everything "right" but still can't figure out why you're overeating? You know you should listen to your hunger signals, stop when you're satisfied, and eat without distractions - but something keeps getting in the way. In this episode, we dive into ... Show More
27m 32s
Jan 2023
Emotional Eating: How to Stop Using Food to Numb Out
When you experience negative emotions, is your first reaction to reach for food? What about positive emotions? In this week's episode, we cover emotional eating, why it's working against you to demonize it, discuss some techniques and different coping skills that you can begin to ... Show More
27m 30s
Feb 2022
104: Skills you can use to stop binging and overeating NOW
The first goal of therapy if you have binge eating, compulsive overeating, food addiction or emotional eating should be interrupting any current unwanted behaviors, such as bingeing, overeating, obsessing about food or your body.  But these behaviors are so automatic and so linke ... Show More
25m 33s
May 2025
Welcome to Emotional Eating Unwrapped
Welcome to Emotional Eating Unwrapped — the only podcast that shows you how to connect mindfulness and science so you can fall in love with eating, create healthy attachments with food, and lose weight sustainably. If you're ready to stop using food as a comfort mechanism, you're ... Show More
1m 30s
Mar 2021
It's not what you're eating, it's what's eating AT you
In her book, The Binge Cure, 7 Steps to Outsmart Emotional Eating, Dr. Nina Savelle-Rocklin talks about how she helps others to understand the real causes of compulsive eating by looking past the surface of WHAT we eat to WHY we eat. We also discuss how to feel in control of the ... Show More
54 m
May 2025
Ep 293 Why high achievers still feel stuck with food + weight
<p><strong>🔑 Episode Summary:</strong><strong><br /></strong> <span style="font-weight: 400;">This empowering episode is for high-achieving women who feel overwhelmed behind the scenes. Whether you're a doctor, mom, leader, or professional, if you struggle with emotional eating, ... Show More
15m 17s
May 2025
194. Solidifying Healthy Eating Habits
<p>💡 <strong>FREE COURSE: Solve Your Food Struggles In 5 Days</strong></p> <p>Take the next step and start making healthy eating easier today.</p> <p>Access my free video series now: <a href= "https://katrentas.com/course"><strong>https://katrentas.com/course</strong></a></p> <p ... Show More
19m 49s