logo
episode-header-image
Oct 21
22 m

S4E36: No, College Admissions Aren't Get...

Thomas Caleel
About this episode

In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel breaks down why college admissions at Ivy League and other top universities are more competitive than ever—and what students and parents can still control in the process.

Despite social media myths about an "easier" year ahead, Thomas explains why application numbers remain high, selectivity rates are dropping, and grade inflation is blurring academic distinctions. Drawing on decades of admissions experience, he reveals how to focus on what actually moves the needle: differentiation, strategy, and authentic engagement.

Key Takeaways:

  • Admit Rates Stay Low: Even with visa changes and testing shifts, top schools like Columbia, Penn, and Stanford continue to see rising applications and falling admit rates. The qualified applicant pool is bigger, not smaller.

  • Qualified Isn't Enough: Perfect grades and test scores don't guarantee admission anymore. What separates top candidates is coherence—the ability to connect activities, essays, and recommendations into a clear, intentional story.

  • Differentiate or Disappear: Students who follow formulas or copy peers' paths blend into the crowd. The strongest applicants take risks, pursue genuine interests deeply, and craft an application that reflects individuality, not perfection.

  • Parents, Step Back Strategically: Thomas offers a direct message to parents—how to support without pressuring, and why old admissions playbooks no longer apply. Honest evaluation, early preparation, and outside perspective are key.

  • Control What You Can: Grades and scores matter, but the true edge lies in strategy—building academic rigor, refining narratives, and making decisions with long-term intention.

Admissions to top universities aren't getting easier. But with clarity, focus, and the right approach, students can still stand out.

Follow @admittedlyco on Instagram and TikTok for more college admissions strategy, and visit www.admittedly.co for webinars, guides, and expert support.

 

Up next
Nov 18
S4E39: How to Plan a Strategic Summer (Before It's Too Late)
<p dir="ltr">In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel explains why freshmen, sophomores, and juniors should begin planning their summer programs and activities long before spring. Drawing on decades of experience in college admissions, he breaks down what act ... Show More
20m 12s
Nov 4
S4E38: The Hidden Half of College Admissions: What Students Overlook (and What Actually Matters)
In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel reveals the hidden half of the college admissions process, the part most families never think about. Students spend years stacking achievements and building resumes, but the truth is that admissions officers care less ... Show More
18m 4s
Oct 28
S4E37: The 3 Biggest Mistakes Students Make in High School (And How to Fix Them Before Senior Year)
In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel breaks down the three most common mistakes he sees students make year after year in the college admissions process — and how to correct them before it's too late. Drawing on more than two decades of admissions experien ... Show More
16m 9s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 12
What Is Demonstrated Interest And How Does It Impact College Admisssions?
Demonstrated interest refers to the ways a student indicates interest in a specific school. This includes visiting campuses, reaching out to admissions officers, participating in prospective student events, and even interacting with the school’s online resources.Let’s face it: th ... Show More
10m 29s
Jan 2024
501: What Colleges Want (Part 1): A Deep Dive into the Factors Colleges Deem Important & State of College Admissions Report
<p><strong><span style="font-size: 18pt;">Show Notes</span></strong></p> <p>On today's episode, Ethan sits down with David Hawkins, Chief Education and Policy Officer at National Association of College Admission Counselors (aka NACAC), and they get discuss, among other things: </ ... Show More
51m 41s
Jul 2024
Forget "Comprehensive" School Counseling
<p>Welcome back to the School for School Counselors Podcast! In this episode, Steph Johnson dives deep into the often unrealistic expectations placed on school counselors. After wrapping up the wildly successful &quot;Best Year Ever!&quot; event, Steph shares her heart and wisdom ... Show More
32m 17s
Oct 2024
Grades, Rakes, and Reflection: Helping Kids Do Less To Do Better - With Teacher & Writer Tim Donahue
In this episode, I sit down with Tim Donahue, a seasoned high school English teacher and a writer, to dive into the pressures of grade inflation, the impact on student resilience, and why kids today feel overwhelmed by academic and extracurricular demands. Tim’s unique perspectiv ... Show More
49m 52s
Sep 2024
A Surprising Secret Weapon Against Chronic School Counselor Stress
<p>Are you tired of feeling overwhelmed and burnt out as a school counselor? Discover game-changing strategies to not only manage- but also thrive- amidst the unique stressors you face daily. Join me, Steph Johnson, on the School for School Counselors Podcast as we navigate the c ... Show More
31 m
Feb 2025
The Fat-Free Fix That’s Failing School Counselors
<p>As busy school counselors, we often find ourselves reaching for quick-fix solutions to help our students. But are these convenient resources truly serving our students&apos; needs? In this episode, I challenge the effectiveness of &quot;print and pray&quot; materials that have ... Show More
22m 25s
Aug 2021
Season 3: Episode 2: How Do I Write a Great Personal Statement and Supplemental Essays?
<p>In this episode, IvyWise college admissions expert Katie (formerly at MIT) talks with Zach (former Senior Assistant Director of Admissions at Boston College) about how to write a meaningful personal statement and impactful supplemental essays.</p> 
46m 9s
Nov 2024
Are You Chasing the Right School Counseling Goals?
<p>In this episode of the &apos;School for School Counselors&apos; podcast, host Steph Johnson discusses a major misstep she nearly made by trying to follow someone else&apos;s advice rather than staying true to her authentic style. <br/><br/>She explores the unrealistic expectat ... Show More
22m 33s
Sep 2021
Semester 3: Episode 5: Why Are Recommendation Letters Important?
<p>In this episode, IvyWise college admissions experts Christine (formerly at Yale and Georgetown) and Robin (formerly at Georgetown) share advice on how students can cultivate strong relationships with their teachers, how they can choose which teachers to ask for recommendation ... Show More
41m 55s
Nov 2024
When Less is More in Your School Counseling Program
<p>⭐️ <a href='https://www.schoolforschoolcounselors.com/mastermind'><b>Join the School for School Counselors Mastermind to build a &quot;stress-less&quot; career</b></a><br/><br/>In this episode of the School for School Counselors podcast, host Steph Johnson addresses an issue m ... Show More
32m 27s