logo
episode-header-image
Sep 18
38m 33s

The Best (& Worst) Creative Demand Score...

Common Thread Collective
About this episode

As Q4 approaches, creative demand becomes one of the biggest challenges for brands looking to scale efficiently. In this episode, Richard Gaffin (Director of Digital Product Strategy at CTC) sits down with Luke Austin (VP of E-Commerce Strategy) to unpack CTC’s new Creative Demand Model—a framework that quantifies exactly how much creative output brands need in order to hit their revenue and spend goals.

They walk through real examples from CTC’s dataset, breaking down what separates the highest creative scores from the lowest, and why top brands are still producing hundreds of ads each month to sustain growth.

You’ll learn:

  • The five key metrics behind the Creative Demand Score (zero spend rate, ad concentration, ROAS degradation, spend degradation, and evergreen share).

  • How creative volume directly ties into forecasting models like spend and MER.

  • Why troubleshooting CTR or hook rate in isolation often misses the bigger picture.

  • Practical recommendations for balancing evergreen content, rapid testing, and scaling winning ads.

  • How creator-driven content and AI-enabled creative are making high-volume production more cost-effective.

If you’ve ever wondered whether your brand needs 20 ads—or 200—to compete in Q4, this episode provides the clarity and direction to plan with confidence.


Show Notes:

Ready to stop gambling on unreliable contractors? 

Check out AllStars and Book Your Strategy Call:

 https://www.hireallstars.com/contact


Explore the Prophit System:

https://www.prophitsystem.com


Explore our Creator Content Packages: https://www.commonthreadco.com/pages/creative-production


The Ecommerce Playbook mailbag is open — email us at podcast@commonthreadco.com to ask us any questions you might have about the world of eCom.

Up next
Nov 20
CFO Summit: Board, Budget, Bonus - The Forecasting Framework for 2026
<p>In our first CFO Summit Taylor breaks down the Board, Budget, Bonus forecasting framework—CTC’s core system for building a clear, defensible, and aligned financial plan for 2026.This replay walks you through how high-performing ecommerce brands create scenario models that serv ... Show More
1h 2m
Nov 18
Meta’s Black Box Is Ruining Your Creative Strategy
<p>Meta’s new creative ranking systems are changing everything, and most brands have no idea how much it’s affecting their performance. In this episode, we break down exactly how Meta’s Black Box evaluates your ads, why your creatives are being grouped together, and why small var ... Show More
1h 1m
Nov 13
How to Set Meta ROAS Targets Before Black Friday
How do you set the right ROAS target on Meta heading into Black Friday and Cyber Monday?Most brands either guess… or use last month’s numbers and hope they hold.But BFCM behaves nothing like a normal period and the attribution windows prove it.In this episode, Tony and Steve walk ... Show More
25m 40s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 5
How We 10X'd Ad Spend in 4 Days (and Why It Worked)
INTELLIGEMSIntelligems brings A/B testing to business decisions beyond copy and design. Test your pricing, shipping charges, free shipping thresholds, offers, SaaS tools, and more by clicking here: https://bit.ly/42DcmFl. Get 20% off the first 3 months with code FARIS20.WORKSPACE ... Show More
40m 31s
Oct 2024
Agencies vs. In-House Teams - Which is Better?
<p>📈 Ecommerce Equation - Business Coaching, Consulting &amp; Community 🔗 https://www.ecommerceequation.com.au/ In this episode of Chew on This, Ash is joined by Jay Wright, CEO and Founder of Ecommerce Equation, an Australian-based growth and education business for brands. Th ... Show More
48m 4s
Sep 2024
Learn how to win on the internet in 28 min [tiktok shop, trends, building cult brands]
Join me as I sit down with Oren John, the internet's creative director who's worked with major brands like Red Bull, Ciroc, Grey Goose, and YRB. Together, we explore the game-changing potential of TikTok Shop and how creators are using the platform to build thriving businesses. O ... Show More
28m 52s
Dec 2024
Scaling Content Creation with AI
<p><strong>Episode #061 - </strong>Destaney sits down with Carolyn, CMO of Pattern, to talk about how brands can use AI to scale their content and stay ahead in the fast-paced industry. From creating optimized listings to tailoring content for specific marketplaces like Amazon an ... Show More
23m 44s
Apr 2025
No More Excuses: The Playbook for the Next 5 Years | GaryVee Aspire Q&A
<p>On today’s episode of the GaryVee Audio Experience, we’re sharing Gary’s full keynote and Q&amp;A from the <strong>Aspire event in Florida</strong> — a gathering of driven entrepreneurs, real estate professionals, and business leaders focused on building stronger brands and na ... Show More
53m 40s
Nov 2024
The Great Luxury E-Commerce Reckoning
<p>In 2024, luxury e-commerce faced a harsh reckoning. A pandemic-era boom gave way to a bruising downturn that exposed deep-seated weaknesses, as rising marketing costs, excessive discounting, outdated technology management and intensifying competition hit profitability.&nbsp;</ ... Show More
26m 27s
Aug 25
Creative Diversification: The Ad Types You Need to Win on Meta
Meta’s Andromeda update has flipped the script: your creative is now your targeting. That means the old “find one winner and scale it” playbook no longer cuts it. In this episode, I break down the nine essential creative categories every business should have in their account in 2 ... Show More
27m 10s
Aug 2024
How to Hire a Bouncer For Your CRM & Make More Money (Not Get More Leads)
Ralph Burns and Lauren Petrullo are discussing a game-changing approach to lead generation. They talk about the pitfalls of chasing high volumes of leads and the importance of filtering out unqualified prospects right from the start. They are going to guide you on how to focus on ... Show More
37m 20s
Sep 29
Julie Wainwright: Getting Real Real About Building a Billion-Dollar Business
Julie Wainwright is the visionary founder and past CEO of The RealReal, the luxury resale giant that disrupted the fashion industry and redefined what it means to build a billion-dollar brand. In her new book, Time to Get Real: How I Built a Billion Dollar Business that Rocked th ... Show More
1h 16m
Sep 16
The Brand NEW AI Marketing Strategy for 2025
Want our free Loop Marketing Prompt Library (with 100 prompts)? Get it here: https://clickhubspot.com/kcl Ep. 362 Did you know that 58.5% of Google searches now end without a click? Kipp and Aja Frost, Sr. Director of Global Growth at HubSpot, dive into how AI has fundamentally c ... Show More
32m 58s