logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2025
16m 26s

43: Why Synthroid Isn’t Working – The Sh...

McCall McPherson, PA-C
About this episode

🎧 Episode Overview:

In this episode of Modern Thyroid Wellness, McCall McPherson unpacks one of the most common frustrations in thyroid care: why levothyroxine-based medications (like Synthroid) often leave patients feeling unwell, even when their labs look “normal.” Drawing from her own experience as a thyroid patient and her extensive clinical work, McCall explains the flawed assumption that every body seamlessly converts T4 into active T3—and why that’s simply not the case for many people.

She breaks down the three stages of levothyroxine treatment, reveals the gaps in standard thyroid testing, and explains how adding T3 therapy can change everything. This episode is a must-listen for anyone who feels unheard, dismissed, or stuck in their thyroid journey—and wants practical, actionable advice for regaining energy, balance, and hope.

Show Highlights:

✅ Why levothyroxine often isn’t enough—especially for patients who can’t convert T4 to T3 efficiently

✅ The hidden flaws in “normal” thyroid lab results

✅ The three stages of levothyroxine treatment every patient should understand

✅ The role of T3 therapy in restoring true thyroid balance

✅ How persistent symptoms like fatigue, brain fog, and weight gain are often overlooked

✅ Practical steps to discuss better testing and treatment options with your provider

✅ Empowering patients to advocate for themselves in their thyroid care

🔗 Links and Resources Mentioned:

🌐 Website:

https://www.modernthyroidclinic.com

📱 Social Media:


📚 Learn More:

  • Schedule a Consultation with McCall
  • Thyroid Resource Library

Up next
Oct 30
55: Can the “Love Hormone” Heal Your Skin? – The Science of Oxytocin & Emotional Beauty with Dr. Sabrina Fabi
Can your thyroid and hormones really influence how your skin ages—or could your emotional health be part of the glow you’re missing?In this insightful episode of Modern Thyroid and Wellness, host McCall sits down with internationally renowned dermatologist Dr. Sabrina Fabi to exp ... Show More
38m 17s
Oct 23
54: It’s Not Just Your Thyroid – The Hidden Causes of Female Hair Loss with Dr. Breanne Kallonen
Could your thinning hair be more than a cosmetic concern—perhaps a signal of hidden hormone, thyroid, or nutrient imbalances?In this must-listen episode of the Modern Thyroid and Wellness Podcast, host McCall McPherson sits down with functional medicine expert Dr. Breanne Kallone ... Show More
29m 46s
Oct 16
53: Can Thyroid Health Help Prevent Cancer? – The Root-Cause Approach to Healing with Dr. Leigh Erin Connealy
Can thyroid issues increase your cancer risk—or could they hold the key to preventing it altogether?In this episode of the Modern Thyroid and Wellness Podcast, host McCall McPherson welcomes renowned integrative physician Dr. Leigh Erin Connealy, author of The Cancer Revolution. ... Show More
53m 29s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2024
Addressing Thyroid and Autoimmune Issues with Dr. Lorraine Maita
“Thyroid disorders are very prevalent, especially in women.” - Dr. Lorraine Maita What you eat and drink, how much you sleep, how much you exercise, the stress you're under, and the toxins you're exposed to all affect your thyroid and hormones. We often underestimate th ... Show More
59m 26s
Aug 2024
The Rise of Thyroid Disorders: Causes, Symptoms & Solutions with Dr. Amie Hornaman
Dr. Amie Hornaman does a deep dive into thyroid health to explore why so many women experience thyroid problems during perimenopause, understand the role of toxins, genetics, and stress, and discover effective lifestyle changes and medical strategies for managing thyroid health. ... Show More
1h 8m
Jul 2025
Why Thyroid Meds Don’t Work for Most Women | Thyroid & Weight Loss Expert
1 out of 8 women will develop a thyroid condition, and up to 60% don’t even know they have it, often because symptoms are dismissed or misdiagnosed. You might be one of the millions with undiagnosed thyroid issues. In this episode, Dr. Axe sits down with McCall McPherson: license ... Show More
1h 3m
Nov 2024
Is Your Thyroid the Hidden Root Cause of Your Health Issues?
Is your thyroid the hidden culprit behind your fatigue, weight gain, or mood swings? In this episode, I uncover the vital role your thyroid health plays in energy, metabolism, and mood—and why its symptoms are often overlooked. Learn about comprehensive thyroid testing, the impac ... Show More
54m 21s
Sep 9
Why Hair Loss Happens and What Helps with VJ Hamilton
What if hair loss was really a signal from your body, not just a cosmetic issue?In this episode, I talk with VJ Hamilton, The Autoimmune Nutritionist, about overcoming alopecia areata and other forms of hair loss by addressing root causes. We dive into nutrient deficiencies, gut ... Show More
47m 31s
Mar 2025
957 - The Most Effective Hypothyroid Medication (It’s Not Levothyroxine)
I’m very excited to have thyroid expert, Dr. Antonio Bianco back on the podcast! In this episode, we have a fascinating discussion about different approaches to hypothyroidism therapy. He shares his research on the use of levothyroxine in comparison to combination therapy and pro ... Show More
1h 26m
Oct 2024
Overcoming Extreme Cases of Thyroid Hair Loss
Many people with hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism experience hair loss, and in some cases, this hair loss can be extreme. That said, in my practice, hair loss occurs more commonly with my hyperthyroid patients - whether Graves’ disease, toxic multinational goiter, or subacute t ... Show More
10m 7s
Dec 2024
The Thyroid Reset Diet with Dr. Alan Christianson
Iodine is a critical nutrient for thyroid function, yet there is a lot of controversy around iodine and thyroid health. Unlike other nutrients, iodine is selectively taken up by the parts of the body that use it. This generally means that when it’s in low supply, more is pulled i ... Show More
1 h
Jan 2025
Quick Hits: The Thyroid Solution: Uncovering the Root Causes of Your Symptoms
Welcome to Quick Hits: Blasts from The Past. Join Karen as she explores her podcast archives, offering you short, impactful excerpts from standout episodes. In just 15 minutes, you'll experience the essence of past conversations, packed with valuable insights and memorable moment ... Show More
23m 45s
Sep 2024
Thyropause: The Silent Thyroid Crisis in midlife Women!
Let’s get into the intricate relationship between thyroid health and menopause, which I refer to as thyropause. In this episode, I’m explaining how the significant drop in estrogen and progesterone can mimic and exacerbate thyroid issues. We’ll explore the common symptoms that ov ... Show More
1h 9m