logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2023
6m 5s

Price Fixing in Real Estate

Victor Menasce
About this episode

On today’s show we are looking at the result of a lawsuit that has been decades in the making. I’ve wondered for a long time why real estate commissions in the US have remained solidly anchored at 6% when in other markets real estate commissions seem to fluctuate much more widely. For example, where I live in Canada, it’s much more common in high priced markets like Toronto to see commission structures where the selling agent is charging 1%-1.5%, and the buyer agent who has a lot more work to do in many cases charging 2.5% for a total of 4% or 4.5%. 

In most professions there are two separate industry bodies. The first is a professional association that acts on behalf of the members. The second is a quasi government body that serves to regulate the industry and to enforce the licensing requirements. They also serve to protect the public. You see this dual structure in most professions whether we are talking about doctors, lawyers, psychologists, and also real estate agents. 

The body that represents real estate agents is an industry body in the US called the National Association of Realtors. 

A Kansas City jury last month delivered a $1.8 billion verdict to home sellers in Missouri against the National Association of Realtors and several major brokerages, finding they had conspired to keep commission rates high.

Up next
Yesterday
A River With No Destination
Today I want to talk about learning AI, and why it’s fundamentally different from learning most other professional skills.If you decide you want to become a doctor, you commit to a long, structured journey. Years of study, exams, residency, and then a licensing body tells the wor ... Show More
5m 40s
Mar 2
Hundreds of Days On Dealer Lots
Today I want to talk about something that looks like it belongs in an auto industry newsletter, but it’s actually a leading indicator for the broader economy, and it matters for real estate investors.Walk onto an auto dealer lot today and you’ll see a lot more sheet metal sitting ... Show More
5m 52s
Mar 1
BOM - Abundance by Ezra Klein
Today we’re looking at the book Abundance, by Ezra Klein, co-authored with Derek Thompson, published in 2025. Ezra Klein is a writer and editor. He has a columnist and editor at The Washington Post, a policy analyst at MSNBC, and a contributor to Bloomberg. He’s written for The N ... Show More
5m 32s
Recommended Episodes
Sep 2023
1075 - How Do Realtors Get Paid? by Jacqueline DeMarco
Realtors are essentially intermediaries between buyers and sellers, so realtors get paid on commission when you close on a property. But who is responsible for that fee, and how much commission do realtors normally take? This article explains how realtor commission works and when ... Show More
10m 26s
Apr 2023
920 - How Much Do Real Estate Agents Make? by Anthony Greer
Real estate agent earnings vary widely based on numerous factors, including experience, location, and niche. Some agents struggle to get by while others earn a comfortable living.  However, some constants exist in how real estate agents work and get paid. For example, most real e ... Show More
12m 18s
Nov 2023
Busting Real Estate Collusion And Price Fixing With Attorney Mike Ketchmark
tail spinning
58m 59s
Sep 2022
279: Where Are All The Houses?
Alec Weichel, Founder and CEO of ListQuick, and Scott Hicken, AOC Executive Producer, join us for episode 279 of Art of Construction.  ListQuick's mission is to provide a highly accountable service to real estate professionals, as well as home buyer and sellers. They have an onli ... Show More
1h 1m
Dec 2022
Money jobs: The reality for realtors
This is episode four of our Business Daily series all about high value, high transaction jobs you might read about, see on the TV or glamorised in films. And in this episode Leanna Byrne looks at the reality for those people who's job is to sell or rent some of the most expensive ... Show More
18m 15s
Mar 2024
The Bombshell Case That Will Transform the Housing Market
<p>For decades, an invisible hand has been guiding and controlling the American real estate industry, dictating how much buyers and sellers pay to their agents and how homes are sold. A few days ago, after a stunning legal settlement, that control — wielded by the National Associ ... Show More
25m 44s
Feb 2019
How to Do Real Estate Marketing in 2019 | First in Line Q&A
<p>There’s a reason why real estate gets hit the hardest during a recession: Everyone is focused on short term sales over brand. That’s why I genuinely believe I’d dominate if I decided to start a brokerage. I would take lower commissions, build brand, and win in the long term. I ... Show More
49m 54s