logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2023
8m 14s

Bryan Kohberger's Courtroom Optics Look ...

True Crime Today
About this episode
Can a crime scene visit sway the jury's verdict? This crucial question has emerged in the latest discussions around the Bryan Kohberger case on the podcast "Hidden Killers," featuring psychotherapist and author Shavaun Scott. With the FBI recently unboarding the house on King Road where the alleged crimes took place, the difference between observing a crime scene firsthand versus through pictures or video is becoming a critical talking point in the judicial process.
 
 Shavaun Scott explained, "Anything where you can make the jury... experience what it must have been like to be in that house at that time will have an emotional impact on them and will make it more real." Scott's assertion resonates with the experience of the Alex Murdaugh trial jurors, who reported that visiting the crime scene offered them a stark realization of the accusations.
 
 The practice of allowing jurors to visit crime scenes is not without controversy, however. Tony Brueski, the podcast host, raised the question of the house's presence itself, noting that both prosecution and defense have been indifferent to its standing, stating they "don't care if the house is there or not."
 
 This indifference has sparked speculation. Why would the prosecution, in particular, not insist on preserving the site? Scott offered, "It's really hard to know. We're just speculating... So much of the community wants the house gone...there's a strong sense in the community of just please eliminate this huge, ugly trigger for trauma."
 
 Despite community sentiments, the necessity for justice remains at the forefront. Scott posited, "Justice for Kohberger and justice for the victims, that's got to be the first priority." This tension between community healing and the integrity of the judicial process remains a delicate balance to strike.
 
 Shifting from the physical to the psychological, Brueski and Scott discussed Kohberger's recent courtroom demeanor. Notably, his hand steepling—a gesture typically associated with confidence—marked a departure from his previously subdued presence. "Do you think Kohberger is feeling a little more confident right now?" Brueski asked.
 
 Scott drew comparisons to infamous figures like Ted Bundy, suggesting that if Kohberger is guilty, his apparent confidence could stem from a similar narcissistic and perverse enjoyment of the attention he's receiving, a chilling consideration that echoes throughout the podcast.
 
 When it comes to courtroom optics, the strategy for presenting a defendant like Kohberger, should he not align with reality's terms, remains debatable. "You don't necessarily want them looking out of control in any way...but looking overconfident is not a good optic either," Scott mentioned, hinting at the complex interplay between perception and reality in legal defense.
 
 Yet, as Brueski pointedly concluded, "He may not be very good at that," indicating a potential disconnect between Kohberger's self-perception and the gravity of the charges against him.
 
 This thoughtful exchange on "Hidden Killers" brings to light the multifaceted challenges in the Kohberger case, from the tangible impact of crime scene visits to the enigmatic behavior of the accused. The discourse provides no clear answers but underscores the nuanced aspects of a trial that is as much about psychological understanding as it is about factual evidence.
 
 As the conversation wrapped, a pivotal question lingered: Is justice best served by the cold reality of evidence, or does the psychological interplay within a courtroom hold sway over the scales of justice? And in the case of Bryan Kohberger, which will prove most decisive?

Want to listen to ALL of our podcasts AD-FREE? Subscribe through APPLE PODCASTS, and try it for three days free: https://tinyurl.com/ycw626tj
Follow Our Other Cases: https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
The latest on Catching the Long Island Serial Killer, Awaiting Admission: BTK’s Unconfessed Crimes, Delphi Murders: Inside the Crime, Chad & Lori Daybell, The Murder of Ana Walshe, Alex Murdaugh, Bryan Kohberger, Lucy Letby, Kouri Richins, Malevolent Mormon Mommys, Justice for Harmony Montgomery, The Murder of Stephen Smith, The Murder of Madeline Kingsbury, and much more! Listen at https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
Up next
Yesterday
Will Anyone Get Inside The Brain Of Bryan Kohberger To Explain His Evil Deeds?
Will Anyone Get Inside The Brain Of Bryan Kohberger To Explain His Evil Deeds? Description: Bryan Kohberger may have pled guilty, but the bigger question still lingers—why did he do it? In this chilling episode, defense attorney Bob Motta explores whether we’ll ever truly get ins ... Show More
16m 41s
Yesterday
How Bryan Kohberger THOUGHT He Could Get Away With It, Psychotherapist Break Down
How Bryan Kohberger THOUGHT He Could Get Away With It, Psychotherapist Break Down Description: What drives a man with extensive criminology training to commit a horrifying quadruple homicide and genuinely believe he could evade justice? In this compelling episode, esteemed psycho ... Show More
17m 57s
Yesterday
Was Bryan Kohberger An Incel? Howard Blum Breaks It Down
Was Bryan Kohberger An Incel? Howard Blum Breaks It Down Description: Was Bryan Kohberger motivated by ideology, obsession, or something even more psychologically fractured? In this provocative episode, NYT bestselling author Howard Blum joins us to explore a question that’s been ... Show More
16m 56s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2024
How Did Only One Alex Murdaugh Juror Feel Influenced By Becky Hill?
In a recent turn of events that continues to grip the nation, the legal saga of Alex Murdaugh took another twist with Judge Toal denying a retrial for the disgraced South Carolina lawyer, despite a juror's testimony suggesting influence by Becky Hill, the clerk of court. This dec ... Show More
9m 9s
Nov 2023
Can Jury Tampering Be Proven in Alex Murdaugh Trial?
Is the quest for justice in the Alex Murdaugh case blurring the lines between right and wrong, and revealing deep-seated issues within the South Carolina legal system? These are the questions that Tony Brueski and former defense attorney, Lori Hellis, tackle in a recent episode o ... Show More
8m 48s
Dec 2023
Eric Bland Explains Why Alex Would Still Be Found Guilty on A Re-Trial
Can justice be as elusive as the morning mist, disappearing before our eyes just when we think we've grasped it? This question hovers over the recent episode of the "Hidden Killers" podcast, where Tony Brueski engages in a thought-provoking conversation with Eric Bland, the attor ... Show More
7m 36s
Feb 2024
Should Alex Murdaugh Juror Tamping Claim Been Taken More Seriously?
As the legal saga surrounding Alex Murdaugh continues to unravel, the latest chapter has left many more perplexed than ever. In a recent episode of "Hidden Killers," host Tony Brueski and his guest, retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke, dissect the developments from the latest ... Show More
9m 36s
Dec 2023
Eric Bland On the Credibility Of Becky Hill And The Likelihood Of An Alex Murdaugh Re-Trial
Is the pursuit of justice an ever-winding road? In the latest episode of the "Hidden Killers" podcast, host Tony Brueski, alongside attorney Eric Bland, tackles the ongoing complexities of the Alex Murdaugh saga, with a specific focus on the potential for a retrial in light of ne ... Show More
11m 7s
Sep 2023
Bob Motta On New Bombshells in Alex Murdaugh Case
In a riveting discussion on the podcast "Hidden Killers," Tony Brueski and Defense Attorney Bob Motta delve deep into the latest twists and turns of the Alec Murdoch case, raising concerns about the very integrity of the jury deliberation process. Motta, a seasoned lawyer, expres ... Show More
14m 37s
Dec 2023
How Ignorance and Egos Of Some May Give Alex Murdaugh A New Trial
The Alex Murdaugh case continues to unravel layers of complexity, this time involving not only the mother, Becky Hill, accused of jury tampering but also her son, Jeffrey Colton Hill, who faces wiretapping charges. This development begs the question: Is this mere coincidence or a ... Show More
6m 5s
Nov 2023
Ret FBI Jennifer Coffindaffer Thinks It's Time for Alex Murdaugh Judge to Recuse Himself Going Forward
In the ever-evolving legal saga of Alex Murdaugh, the question of whether a retrial is warranted looms large, especially considering recent allegations of jury tampering. On the podcast "Hidden Killers," host Tony Brueski and former FBI Special Agent Jennifer Coffindaffer discuss ... Show More
8m 59s