logo
episode-header-image
Feb 2024
9m 36s

Should Alex Murdaugh Juror Tamping Claim...

True Crime Today
About this episode
As the legal saga surrounding Alex Murdaugh continues to unravel, the latest chapter has left many more perplexed than ever. In a recent episode of "Hidden Killers," host Tony Brueski and his guest, retired FBI Special Agent Robin Dreeke, dissect the developments from the latest hearing regarding Murdaugh's request for a new trial. Despite a juror's testimony indicating that their verdict was influenced by the actions of Becky Hill, a former clerk of court, the judge, remarkably, found this to be insufficient for granting a retrial. This decision has cast a spotlight not only on the intricacies of legal standards but also on the broader implications for the justice system's integrity.
The anticipation for a potential new trial for Murdaugh was met with a sudden halt when the judge overseeing the case declared the presented evidence and testimony inadequate for such a measure. According to Dreeke, this outcome was somewhat unexpected, given the gravity of Hill's alleged misconduct. "I was a little surprised, actually, because I think Becky Hill really overstepped what she should and shouldn't do in her position of trust," Dreeke reflected on the judge's ruling.
At the heart of the matter lies the challenging burden of proving not just jury tampering but also its intended prejudice against Murdaugh. This distinction, as Brueski and Dreeke noted, requires a deep dive into the motivations and impacts of Hill's interactions with jurors, a task that evidently proved too complex for the defense to surmount in the eyes of the presiding judge.
Dreeke's initial reaction to the decision was one of relief, underscoring a belief in the conviction's righteousness and a desire to uphold it despite Hill's alleged errors. "You would hate for a righteous conviction to get overturned or to be retried because of one fool that did things that she shouldn't have done," Dreeke stated, emphasizing his confidence in the judicial process as it unfolded in South Carolina, in stark contrast to other high-profile cases.
The conversation between Brueski and Dreeke also ventured into the judge's possible reasoning behind her decision. They speculated on the difficulty of distinguishing between the pressures exerted by Hill and those naturally arising from the deliberation among jurors. This nuanced interpretation of jury dynamics and influence raises critical questions about the thresholds for overturning convictions based on alleged external pressures.
With the door to a new trial for Murdaugh seemingly closed for now, attention turns to the appellate process. Dreeke and Brueski pondered the potential for further legal battles and the prospect of revisiting the decision at a higher judicial level. The appellate courts' willingness to engage with the complexities of this case could ultimately determine Murdaugh's fate and either reinforce or challenge the public's faith in the legal system's ability to self-correct.
As the podcast episode concluded, Brueski and Dreeke left listeners with a compelling question: In a legal system fraught with human errors and subjective interpretations, what does it truly take to ensure justice prevails? The ongoing saga of Alex Murdaugh, marked by twists and turns at every stage, continues to captivate and confound, serving as a vivid reminder of the justice system's inherent complexities and the enduring quest for truth.
The Murdaugh case, with its blend of high-stakes legal battles, personal tragedy, and systemic scrutiny, remains a focal point for those concerned with the integrity of justice in America. As developments unfold, the conversation between Brueski and Dreeke offers a critical lens through which to view the challenges and responsibilities of those tasked with administering justice, reminding us that the path to truth is often as convoluted as it is consequential.
Want to listen to ALL of our podcasts AD-FREE? Subscribe through APPLE PODCASTS, and try it for three days free: https://tinyurl.com/ycw626tj
Follow Our Other Cases: https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
The latest on Catching the Long Island Serial Killer, Awaiting Admission: BTK’s Unconfessed Crimes, Delphi Murders: Inside the Crime, Chad & Lori Daybell, The Murder of Ana Walshe, Alex Murdaugh, Bryan Kohberger, Lucy Letby, Kouri Richins, Malevolent Mormon Mommys, Justice for Harmony Montgomery, The Murder of Stephen Smith, The Murder of Madeline Kingsbury, and much more! Listen at https://www.truecrimetodaypod.com
Up next
Jun 26
Big Breakdown: The Fallout From The Crimes of Alex Murdaugh
Big Breakdown: The Fallout From The Crimes of Alex Murdaugh This comprehensive episode retraces the dramatic unraveling of the once-powerful Murdaugh dynasty of South Carolina. We begin the timeline in February 2019, when Alex’s son Paul and friend Mallory Beach went missing afte ... Show More
57m 3s
Jun 15
Alex Murdaughs Last Hope - Why Court Clerks Arrest Could Mean Retrial-WEEK IN REVIEW
Welcome to the "Week in Review," where we delve into the true stories behind this week's headlines. Your host, Tony Brueski, joins hands with a rotating roster of guests, sharing their insights and analysis on a collection of intriguing, perplexing, and often chilling stories tha ... Show More
17m 13s
Jun 9
Alex Murdaugh's Last Hope: Why Court Clerk's Arrest Could Mean Retrial
Alex Murdaugh's Last Hope: Why Court Clerk's Arrest Could Mean Retrial The Alex Murdaugh murder trial took a stunning turn when court clerk Becky Hill was arrested on four felony charges in May 2025, potentially opening the door for one of the most controversial retrials in Ameri ... Show More
17m 8s
Recommended Episodes
Nov 2023
Idaho Murders - Why the King Road House Needs To Stand For Kohberger Trial
Can the walls of a crime scene whisper the truths of a tragic event? This question seems to encapsulate the recent discussion between Tony Brueski and former FBI Special Agent Jennifer Coffindaffer on the "Hidden Killers" podcast. The focal point of their conversation was the per ... Show More
7m 43s
Sep 2023
S2E40: Jury Tampering? Retrial? Bombshell new allegations in Murdaugh murder case
Alex Murdaugh's lawyers are demanding a retrial after several jurors who convicted their client of murdering his wife and son have suddenly come forward to accuse Colleton County Clerk of Court Rebecca ("Becky") Hill of impropriety. Attorneys Jim Griffin and Dick Harpootlian say ... Show More
53m 57s
Nov 2023
Bryan Kohberger's Courtroom Optics Look Worse and Worse
Can a crime scene visit sway the jury's verdict? This crucial question has emerged in the latest discussions around the Bryan Kohberger case on the podcast "Hidden Killers," featuring psychotherapist and author Shavaun Scott. With the FBI recently unboarding the house on King Roa ... Show More
8m 14s
Aug 2023
Bob Motta On Consequences Of Rushing Kohberger Trial
In a recent episode of the podcast "Hidden Killers," hosted by Tony Brueski, a spotlight was shone on the intricate details surrounding the Bryan Kohberger case. Bob Motta, a seasoned defense attorney and host of the podcast "Defense Diaries," joined Brueski to discuss the evolvi ... Show More
11m 9s
Feb 2023
Murdaugh on Trial: The Prosecution Rests
Go inside the courtroom for the trial of the year.  Today Show Anchor and Dateline Correspondent Craig Melvin and Dateline Producer Carol Gable — two proud natives of South Carolina — dissect the just-concluded prosecution case against Alex Murdaugh for the murders of his wife an ... Show More
29m 40s
Sep 2023
Will BTK Dennis Rader End Up Back In Court?
Serial killer Dennis Rader, infamously known as BTK (Bind, Torture, Kill), is back in the headlines with connections to several cold cases. His daughter recently tweeted that there are about five unsolved missing person cases possibly attributed to her father. One case under clos ... Show More
6m 27s