logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2023
1h 23m

Betrayed By My First Love

Chris Gethard
About this episode

This week's caller is a self-described "woman of stories" who shares one with Geth about being deeply betrayed by someone she loved. In the proces of telling her story, she gives a masterclass on empathy and compassion.

Thanks to everyone who came out to the first Laughing Together show. LaughingTogether.org for more information. 

Preorder Unreliable Narrator by Aparna Nancherla now. 

Keep up with Gethard's tour dates at chrisgeth.com

Leave us a voicemail at (973) 306-4676‬

Follow Beautiful/Anonymous on Instagram @beautifulanonymouspod

 

Up next
Aug 4
Gratuitous Live Turkeys
This week's caller had an encounter with a psychic that is tailor-made for Beautiful/Anonymous. She tells Gethard that story, shares memories of her free-range '90s childhood, and opens up about an experience from those years that left her with a unique phobia. It might sound a l ... Show More
1h 9m
Jul 28
A Completely Normal Call That Goes Exactly As Planned
Let's all agree we can blame Mercury retrograde for the technical difficulties we had in getting this one off the ground. The rest of the chaos, though, is entirely on this week's caller, a true maker of mischief who calls in on their birthday eve eve looking for a little trouble ... Show More
1h 6m
Jul 21
Stopped a Serial Killer?
Recovering from surgery and ten days into a liquid diet, our caller is hungry for conversation. Geth and this Good Vibes Caller compare shared surgeries, shared interests, and decide whether or not he once stopped a woman from becoming a serial killer's next victim. Sign up for B ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2025
Betrayal in the Self, Friendships and Relationships
On this week's episode, we are joined by a return guest, Layla K. Saleh to help navigate the topic of betrayal. The betrayals we commit against ourselves in the name of love, loyalty, or fear of abandonment. Reflecting on friendships and romantic relationships, she explores how w ... Show More
1h 8m
Mar 2025
Befriending The Other Woman
Once a cheater, always a cheater. Besties Thelma & Louise are sharing the mic with their real-life friend Jennifer who has been through hell and back.  From what she thought was her happily ever after, to an affair that tore her marriage apart, to how she picked up the pieces and ... Show More
51m 27s
Jun 2023
EP 27 play chess not checkers
Hi angels,Welcome back to the oversharers podcast <3333This week we’re back with two intense scenarios from our listeners. One woman shares her story of revenge following a massive betrayal from her partner. Second scenario is about a leaving a difficult marriage with a toxic par ... Show More
52m 46s
May 2024
Secrets and Surprises of a Deceitful Partner
This is a story about a woman who shares her experience of a deceitful partner. Connect with me on: TikTok: ⁠https://www.tiktok.com/@manjitruprai⁠ Instagram: ⁠https://www.instagram.com/manjit_ruprai/?utm_medium=copy_link⁠ YouTube: ⁠https://www.youtube.com/c/ManjitKaurRuprai⁠ Face ... Show More
21m 7s
Sep 2025
betrayal in my girl interrupted era
this week i talk about betrayal and how it never stops catching me off guard, no matter how much i think i’ve prepared myself for it. i get into the way it rewires your nervous system like a mf-ing xmas tree, how it lingers in the body, and why it feels harder to let go of than s ... Show More
40m 8s
Apr 2023
S3 Ep15: When she found a letter from his mistress.... - S3E15
[SCROLL FOR CW]-This week we're raising awareness for Women Against Abuse in Philadelphia, PA: https://www.womenagainstabuse.org/donate-Submit a break up story/couple: https://forms.gle/ATdabGFwyy7tEx3W8-Follow the podcast!-Abby's IG: https://www.instagram.com/theabbymurphy/-Abby ... Show More
29m 14s
Jun 2023
EP 25 my Hoyoo cut me out of her life
Hi angels,Welcome back to the oversharers podcast <3333This week we discuss a scenario from one of our listeners who is confused if a guy is into her or simply leading her on. The second scenario is about a woman who is struggling with a difficult relationship with her mum. She s ... Show More
46m 1s
Mar 2024
growing up & growing apart: betrayal, boredom, & the trauma olympics
tail spinning
38m 44s