logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2021
41m 8s

Shelia Eddy & Rachel Shoaf Pt. 1

SPOTIFY STUDIOS
About this episode
In West Virginia, a once-inseparable trio of teenage girls became toxic after two of them struck up a secret romantic relationship. Fearing their friend would expose them, 16-year-olds Shelia Eddy and Rachel Shoaf plotted to keep Skylar Neese silent for good.  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices 
Up next
Oct 9
Killer in the Suburbs: Cop’s Wife Found Dead in Quiet Town
Behind the picture-perfect marriage of a longtime Massachusetts police detective Brian Fanion and his devoted wife, secrets were beginning to surface, and just months before retirement, another woman entered the picture. Then Amy Fanion was found dead from a gunshot wound, shot w ... Show More
32m 54s
Oct 2
Murdered By The In-Laws: The Killing of Dan Markel
A Florida law professor is gunned down in his own driveway in broad daylight. No witnesses, no immediate suspects, and no answers. For years, the case goes cold, but the deeper they dig into Dan Markel's life, the more they realize this wasn't random. Get the full story on this e ... Show More
32m 47s
Sep 25
The Missing PI: Murder of Taylor Wright
A private investigator was reported missing by her partner after she never came home from running errands. Taylor Wright, a former police officer turned PI, was embroiled in a heated legal battle with her ex-husband over custody and finances. Wright lent her money to a friend to ... Show More
40m 49s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2020
“Part of the Family” Pt. 1: Karen Severson and Laura Doyle
A revenge plot turned deadly in 1985 after two teenage girls unleashed their jealous rage on their former friend, Missy Avila. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices 
43m 43s
Oct 2024
Popular Girls didn't wanna be Friends with her, So they Killed Her: Case of Skylar Neese
High school for most is either the best years of your life or the worst years of your life. High school and teens years are usually a time for self discovery trying to figure out who you are you want to be, and the people you want to surround yourself with. And in 2012 a group of ... Show More
32m 54s
Jan 2022
#131: Pretty Little Liars Killers (Case of Skylar Neese)
<p>The three girls never went anywhere without each other. They were besties.</p><p>Well, except Biology Class - the one class that only Rachel and Sheila were in.</p><p>Maybe that’s why during biology Sheila would ask a lot of strange questions.</p><p>“Excuse me, what kind of ac ... Show More
1h 14m
Jun 2025
Teenage Love Spiral: Stacey Hanna, Kelly Gibbs, Domica Winckler, Tracy Bitner
<p>A group of teenage lesbians finds comfort, support and even love with one another in late 90's Richmond, Virginia. The harmonious environment is disturbed however when love triangles emerge, lies blend with truth and friendships turn deadly.</p><p><strong>Sources:</strong></p> ... Show More
1h 44m
Jan 2019
The Murder of Skylar Neese
Skylar was a well-liked and bubbly 16-year-old who lived in West Virginia. She had two best friends and three of them did everything together. As with many teenagers, their lives played out on social media. But the friendship between the trio began to fray and in 2012 Skylar's fr ... Show More
1h 12m
Jan 2024
Trial by Twitter | Season 1 Trailer
<p>After midnight on July 6th, 2012, three teenage girls walked into the thick Appalachian woods somewhere along the Mason-Dixon line. Hours later, under the glow of a nearly full moon, only two walked out. </p><p>The very last time Dave and Mary Neese saw their only child Skylar ... Show More
2m 51s
Mar 2021
Rachel Wade
When Rachel Wade and Sarah Ludemann both started dating the same boy, they were each under the impression that the other one was an ex-girlfriend. This led to a social media feud that would escalate to a deadly level.For more stories of the worst people on earth, visit our YouTub ... Show More
34m 38s
Nov 2024
Scarlett Jenkinson and Eddie Ratcliffe
Scarlett Jenkinson was a troubled teen who transferred schools due to a serious incident involving another student. At her new school, she met Brianna Ghey, a lonely girl who needed a friend. The relationship turned deadly.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Scarlett Jenkinson an ... Show More
1h 15m