logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2021
42m 8s

Shelia Eddy & Rachel Shoaf Pt. 1

SPOTIFY STUDIOS
About this episode
In West Virginia, a once-inseparable trio of teenage girls became toxic after two of them struck up a secret romantic relationship. Fearing their friend would expose them, 16-year-olds Shelia Eddy and Rachel Shoaf plotted to keep Skylar Neese silent for good.  Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
Up next
Dec 2022
The Murder of Laci Peterson Pt. 2
In our final episode, we take a look back at the trial against Scott Peterson, the moment Amber Frey took the stand, and what’s happened in the case in the two decades since Laci Peterson and her unborn son Conner first went missing. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcas ... Show More
43m 11s
Dec 2022
The Murder of Laci Peterson Pt. 1
On Christmas Eve twenty years ago, a pregnant woman vanished from her Modesto, California, neighborhood. Relentless media coverage pulled at every thread in her case — most notably, her husband’s strange behavior. Decades since her body, and the body of her unborn son, were found ... Show More
44m 51s
Dec 2022
Brenda Delgado Pt. 2
By September 2015, Brenda has masterminded a murder. She secures multiple accomplices and a solid alibi. But Brenda’s plan isn’t as airtight as she thinks. As investigators close in, a murder-for-hire leads to an international manhunt. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podc ... Show More
34m 25s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2020
“Part of the Family” Pt. 1: Karen Severson and Laura Doyle
A revenge plot turned deadly in 1985 after two teenage girls unleashed their jealous rage on their former friend, Missy Avila. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices 
44m 43s
Jan 2019
The Murder of Skylar Neese
Skylar was a well-liked and bubbly 16-year-old who lived in West Virginia. She had two best friends and three of them did everything together. As with many teenagers, their lives played out on social media. But the friendship between the trio began to fray and in 2012 Skylar's fr ... Show More
1h 12m
May 2018
SMNTY Classics: Why You're Seeing Cyntoia Brown's Tragic Story Everywhere
Anney and Bridget revisit this classic episode to discuss the heartbreaking story of a 16 year-old victim of sex trafficking. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
41m 24s
Apr 2022
27: Girl Stalks Married Couple & Falls In Love - She Gets RID Of The REAL WIFE In A Creepy Deadly Way
When Pippa & her boyfriend move into their dream loft - they never imagined they would become stalkers. But it was just too addicting. Watching their wealthy neighbor’s steamy s*x sessions, fights, and affairs made them feel alive again. What started off innocent became dangerous ... Show More
1h 17m
Mar 2021
#48: The "Best Friends Forever" Murder (Case: Christine Paolilla & Vera Jo Reigle)
They met in High School and became popular and inseparable. One of them was even voted “Miss Irresistible.”  Best friends forever & ever they said - but when four of them are found brutally murdered you have to wonder if someone close to them was involved… Secrets between friends ... Show More
1h 43m
Mar 2019
Diane and Rachel Staudte
Mother and daughter Diane and Rachel Staudte committed two horrific murders and attempted a third. These two women made the decision to poison their family members using antifreeze. They planned the murders, researched the use of antifreeze, and almost go away with it.Join Mike a ... Show More
1h 12m
May 2018
E95: The Wanda Beach Murders
Australian teens Christine Sharrock, Marianne Schmidt, and Marianne's four younger siblings set out for the beach. When the younger siblings became tired, the older girls continued on, promising to be back soon. Their bodies were discovered the next day. Were the girls in the wro ... Show More
42m 39s