logo
episode-header-image
Jan 2022
1h 14m

#131: Pretty Little Liars Killers (Case ...

STEPHANIE SOO
About this episode

The three girls never went anywhere without each other. They were besties.

Well, except Biology Class - the one class that only Rachel and Sheila were in.

Maybe that’s why during biology Sheila would ask a lot of strange questions.

“Excuse me, what kind of acid would you dispose of a body in?”

“I don’t know… why?”

“Oh, we’re trying to figure out what to do with Skylar.”

Rachel would be off on the side giggling. That’s how the two girls started to plot their best friend’s murder in biology class.


Full Source Notes: rottenmangopodcast.com

Up next
Yesterday
“My Parents Were Pedophiles & Forced Me Into Being With Other Pedophiles”- A Day With Lisa Plumb
Family nudist camps. They’re real and exist today. Children are 100% allowed. Clothes are not. A lot of people wonder if it’s uncomfortable for children, which one camp addresses in their website’s FAQs: Q: Are children forced to be nude? A: The word “forced” is an emotionally lo ... Show More
1h 48m
Oct 5
I Saw Luigi Mangione In Court & This Is EVERYTHING That Happened
We went to see Luigi Mangione in court. September 16, 2025, in a New York State Courthouse, Mangione’s terrorism charges are dropped. The courtroom remains silent with court officers stationed at every corner. There are cheers from protestors right outside the courthouse. A stran ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 28
D4vd Uses Celeste’s Voice In New Songs Months Before Her Body Is Found? + New Updates From Police
It is not until Spetmber 17th, 2025 that the body found in D4vd’s Tesla is identified as 14 year old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. And she has been missing for over a year. The last time her family saw her in person seems to be in April of 2024 though her family has remained out of th ... Show More
2h 14m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2022
43. She fell in love with her bully but when he ends up murdered, everyone thinks she did it
She didn’t know how to read or write - she only knew how to survive. She knew what the townspeople called her. “Marsh Girl.” They made fun of her, made up tall tales about how her eyes glowed in the dark, and how she was “feral.” She did raise herself in the wilderness with nobod ... Show More
1h 27m
Jan 2022
22: #22: 5 Students In Detention - Only 4 Walked Out Alive
After Simon (a student who ran a “tea” page about the dirty secrets of fellow students) was killed in detention - a new blog popped up. “I figured out how I was going to kill Simon by watching an episode of Dateline.” It was the supposed killer. Everyone in the school had a motiv ... Show More
1h 39m
Jun 2021
2. What I Don’t Know I Don’t Know
Ivy asks a nature educator to teach her survival skills, because she’s afraid of what she doesn’t know she doesn’t know. But camping lessons are not the cheat code she was hoping for. Transcripts and show notes: https://fogopodcast.com/shownotes Learn more about your ad choices. ... Show More
42m 18s
Jan 2024
84. High School Classmates Kidnapped - Must Lie & Secretly Kill Each Other To Survive
They didn’t know why this was happening to them or who was doing this. What was supposed to be a nice weekend school trip with the entire class turned into a hostage situation… They were kidnapped, trapped in the dorm buildings, and the only way to get out - is to kill each other ... Show More
1h 23m
Apr 2018
Shadowing Sheila
SPOILER WARNING: Please listen to our first episode about Sheila, Episode 88: Cold Case, before you listen to this one. This episode contains descriptions of violence and may not be suitable for everyone. Sheila Wysocki became a private investigator to try to help solve the murde ... Show More
31m 14s
Apr 2024
EP62: Scissor Sisters (Part 1)
The notorious "Scissor Sisters" case ranks among the most brutal and shocking in Irish history, leaving a dark mark on the true crime genre. Linda and Charlotte Mulhall, despite a troubled existence marred by alcohol and drug addiction and a history of abuse, had never shown sign ... Show More
1h 18m
Apr 2018
Cold Case
In 1984, Sheila Wysocki found herself helping the police investigate the murder of her college roommate, Angela Samota. Detectives asked her to help gather information, and even sent her out to dinner with the main suspect, a man named Russell Buchanan. But the case remained unso ... Show More
37m 59s
May 2024
The Wedding Vow Murder Pact Killers
Serial killer or serial liar? Kelly Cochran is guilty of two homicides, which she blames on a pact she made with her husband, Jason. But Kelly’s history of lies and manipulation may have concealed up to thirty-two murders and at least one case of cannibalism.Keep up with us on In ... Show More
1 h