logo
episode-header-image
Jul 28
1h 3m

Sexual Ethics on Campus: Consent and Pow...

Brain in a Vat
About this episode

Colin McGinn joins to discuss sexual ethics on campus. Drawing on thought experiments and his own experiences in academia, McGinn argues that universities too often conflate harassment with consensual relationships while overstating the role of power imbalances. He explains why he believes current policies can undermine academic freedom, due process, and the proper limits of institutional authority.


Chapters:

[00:00] Introduction

[00:16] A Thought Experiment

[08:19] Microenticements

[12:09] Harassment vs. Consensual Relationships

[22:38] Reporting Relationships

[36:06] The Power Imbalance

[45:06] MeToo, Cancellation, and Academia

[49:53] Devil's Advocate

[1:00:17] Should Universities Regulate Romance?

[1:10:58] Final Reflections

Up next
Aug 10
The Man Who Exposed Jason Arday: Cancelled at Cambridge | Nathan Cofnas
Nathan Cofnas, the academic who recently drew widespread attention for exposing plagiarism allegations against Cambridge professor Jason Arday, returns to Brain in a Vat to discuss academic freedom, institutional conformity, and his own controversial departure from Cambridge.Cofn ... Show More
58m 58s
Aug 4
Free Speech, Schools, and Children | Jimmy Mullen
Former Brain in a Vat producer Jimmy Mullen returns to discuss free speech in schools, exploring how educational institutions should balance student expression with their responsibility to maintain an environment conducive to learning.Drawing on constitutional law and landmark ca ... Show More
56m 52s
Jun 28
The Philosophy of Pluribus | Spencer Case
Spencer Case returns to discuss Pluribus, one of the most philosophically ambitious science fiction series in recent years. The conversation explores whether individuality is worth preserving if giving it up would create a happier and more peaceful world, raising questions about ... Show More
58m 9s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2022
Impossible (?) Conversations: The Best and Worst of "Woke Culture"
Psychologists Dr. Hector Garcia and Dr. Valerie Tarico join us for a complex, nuanced, and thoughtful conversation about the dying of discourse in a hyper-divided world. When should we speak, and when should we shout? Are we picking the right battles? When should we declare war o ... Show More
56m 35s
Nov 2017
Mind Games
How to make people like you, why you should lick rocks, and what an awkward person is really thinking. Angela Duckworth (Grit author) is co-host; Mike Maughan (Qualtrics) is live fact-checker. 
47m 46s
Aug 2022
how to start a new chapter: omw to my "???" era
tail spinning
57m 45s
Jun 2023
Gut instinct
The Skeptic Editor Michael Marshall talks to Matthew Sweet about how we judge actions and truth. They're joined by New Generation Thinkers Elsa Richardson, who is a historian of the emotions at the University of Strathclyde working on a popular history of the gut-brain connection ... Show More
45m 58s
May 2025
can friends survive a political divide?: new enemy unlocked
podmothers sephy & wing enter the chat: spiralling on opinions, morals, and political differences, managing expectations for yourself and others, failure, redirection, and knowing when to change course. ✷see more ✷ youtube @sephyandwing ✷ instagram @sephyandwing ✷ tiktok @sephyan ... Show More
52m 37s
Feb 2025
407: Concepts of a Bubble
Is it socially appropriate to cover my ears and go “ahhhhhh?” Where did all the water on Mars go? How do I deal with friends who disrespect my favorite singer? Why are there perfectly uniform bubbles in my soap? Why don’t people just take the bribe and not do the corruption? Shou ... Show More
48m 58s
Jun 2022
Gay Son or Thot Daughter?
<span>The girlies answer the tough questions: has Google created sentient AI? Can you romanticize your way out of a shitty job? How can you tell if the vibes are off? Digressions include everything. It's all digressions this week.</span><br /> <br /> Advertising Inquiries: <a hre ... Show More
1h 6m
Apr 2025
You’re Fine WIth That?
We are back getting Ros and Eric weighing in on some headlines that have caught their eye. In true He Said, Ella Dijo fashion, these two don’t always have the same opinion on these topics. What bathroom should a parent be taking their child of the opposite sex into, would you be ... Show More
19m 49s