Real cases pulled apart through the Octalysis Core Drives, sent to your inbox over a few days. Get the free guide: professorgame.com/WildCD
Episode Summary
Rob breaks down why the same reward can pull a team forward or quietly wreck it, using three cases where the design decided the outcome. He walks through a school in Caracas where escalating fines for late pickups made lateness worse, the sales bonus patterns that produce burnout and sandbagging, and The Octalysis Group's project with Procter & Gamble's distributor Navo Orbico, where a gamified ship upgrade tightened the feedback loop instead of paying for the sale. Along the way he separates two mechanisms that often get treated as one: a fine turning a moral obligation into a price, and the over-justification effect crowding out intrinsic motivation on the reward side. Listeners learn how to match the reward to the job it actually has to do, and when to hand off to something more durable.
About the Host
Rob Alvarez is Head of Engagement Strategy, Europe at The Octalysis Group (TOG), a leading gamification and behavioral design consultancy. A globally recognized gamification strategist and TEDx speaker, he founded and hosts Professor Game, the #1 gamification podcast, and has interviewed hundreds of global experts. He designs evidence-based engagement systems that drive motivation, loyalty, and results, and teaches LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® and gamification at top institutions including IE Business School, EFMD, and EBS University across Europe, the Americas, and Asia.
Key Takeaways
- A school in Caracas replaced the moral weight of collecting your child on time with an escalating fine, and lateness went up instead of down. Core Drive 5 (Social Influence and Relatedness) stopped doing its job the moment the delay carried a price.
- Gneezy and Rustichini's study "A Fine is a Price" documents the same reversal in day-care centers: a monetary fine for late pickups increased late pickups, and removing the fine did not bring them back down.
- A standing sales commission with nothing behind it pays for the behavior forever. Reps chase the next check to make ends meet, and with no other motivation in the system, the commission burns them out rather than building anything durable.
- Capped bonuses fail in two directions. Targets set too high get read as unreachable, so reps stop trying, and reachable targets get sandbagged, with closed-ready deals held into the next cycle so the company waits on revenue it wanted today.
- In The Octalysis Group's project with Procter & Gamble's distributor Navo Orbico, ship upgrades inside Masters of the Endless Seas cut the roughly week-long CRM lag on seeing whether a sale landed, tightening the Core Drive 2 (Development and Accomplishment) loop instead of paying for the sale. Rob was not on the project team and saw it presented at Brighton.
- Nearly every reward failure is one of two mistakes: treating the get-them-through-the-door reward as the whole engine, or bolting an extrinsic reward onto behavior that already had an intrinsic reason, which is where the over-justification effect crowds that reason out.
Topics Covered
- 0:00 — The reward is a tool, not a motivator
- 1:56 — The Caracas school that fined late parents
- 2:45 — How a fine replaced a moral obligation
- 4:07 — A Fine is a Price, Gneezy and Rustichini
- 4:44 — When rewards do an honest job
- 6:07 — Standing commissions and sales rep burnout
- 7:07 — Bonus targets set too high to chase
- 8:06 — Hitting the number, then sandbagging deals
- 8:52 — The over-justification effect in action
- 9:27 — P&G's Masters of the Endless Seas
- 11:15 — Why the ship worked when the bonus failed
- 12:20 — Choosing the reward that fits the job
Mentioned in This Episode
- Core Drives in the Wild, the free guide with real cases analyzed through the Octalysis Core Drives
- Episode 453: Why Users Agree But Never Start, where Rob covers the Procter & Gamble project in full
- "A Fine is a Price" by Uri Gneezy and Aldo Rustichini, Journal of Legal Studies, 2000
- The Octalysis Group, and its project with Procter & Gamble's distributor Navo Orbico
- Masters of the Endless Seas, the gamified world built for the Procter & Gamble sales rep network
- The over-justification effect, and Core Drives 1, 2, 3, and 5 of the Octalysis Framework
Free Resources and Get in Touch
