logo
episode-header-image
Sep 24
1h 10m

Big Muddy Monster

Dan Cummins, Lynze Cummins
About this episode

Dan starts off the week in Chicago, in the suburbs. We will explore the very well documented legend of the Big Muddy Monster. Did a variety of people see some sort of big, terrifying, bipedal cryptid in a swamp back in 1973? And have people been intermittently been seeing it since? 
Then we head to our favorite city in America, New Orleans. We explore a less documented legend - the legend of the Carter Brothers? Did a pair of vampires get arrested for murder back in 1932? And following their executions, are they still feasting on human blood in the French Quarter? Lynze is taking us to New Orleans as well, in a tale about a nanny and a harrowing experience she had. Wrapping up this weeks show, Lynze takes us to Pennsylvania for a possible interrupted satanic ritual. 

Wet Hot Bad Magic Summer Camp 2026: We are so excited to be hosting the 4th Annual Wet Hot Bad Magic Summer Camp again in 2026! That’s right, we will be back in action next year! Here’s what you need to know right now! All of this info can be found badmagicproductions.com
WHEN: SEPTEMBER 10-13, 2026 

WHERE: SAME PLACE! EQUINUNK, PA

TIX: Tickets are going on sale on MONDAY, SEPT. 22nd, 2025 at 12 noon PT.

New next year is upgraded private housing! The camp basically built a mini hotel. There are 90 private rooms available. All of them are en-suites AKA (private bathroom!). The private rooms always sell out so be ready to punch in your info and lock it down!  Over the coming weeks and months, we will reveal to you the theme the entertainment for camp, the limited edition merch and more! Gather all the info you need at badmagicproductions.com Then head back over to badmagicproductions.com NEXT WEEK on MONDAY SEPT 22ND AT 12 NOON PT to get your brand new private room and your tickets! If you are looking for the inside scoop on camp, join our Facebook group for camp! Search for Wet Hot Bad Magic Summer Camp. Everyone there is a veteran and can offer guidance!

Do you want to get all of our episodes a WEEK early, ad free? Want to help us support amazing charities? Join us on Patreon!

Want to be a Patron? Get episodes AD-FREE, listen and watch before they are released to anyone else, bonus episodes, a 20% merch discount, additional content, and more! Learn more by visiting: https://www.patreon.com/scaredtodeathpodcast.

Send stories to mystory@scaredtodeathpodcast.com

Send everything else to info@scaredtodeathpodcast.com

Please rate, review, and subscribe anywhere you listen.

Thank you for listening!

Follow the show on social media: @scaredtodeathpodcast on Facebook and IG and TT

Website: https://www.badmagicproductions.com/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/scaredtodeathpodcast

Instagram: https://bit.ly/2miPLf5

Mailing Address:

Scared to Death

c/o Timesuck Podcast

PO Box 3891

Coeur d'Alene, ID 83816

Opening Sumerian protection spell (adapted):

"Whether thou art a ghost that hath come from the earth, or a phantom of night that hath no home… or one that lieth dead in the desert… or a ghost unburied… or a demon or a ghoul… Whatever thou be until thou art removed… thou shalt find here no water to drink… Thou shalt not stretch forth thy hand to our own… Into our house enter thou not. Through our fence, breakthrough thou not… we are protected though we may be frightened. Our life you may not steal, though we may feel SCARED TO DEATH."

Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes of Scared to Death ad-free and a whole week early. Start a free trial now on Apple Podcasts or by visiting siriusxm.com/podcastsplus.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

Up next
Yesterday
Bringing Evil Home
Dan's first tale this week is wild. What if you brought some type of demonic presence home from a vacation and it ended up possessing your neighbor, and then your demonically possessed neighbor than attacked you? We head to Ireland for that one. And then, we’ll take a quick trip ... Show More
1h 16m
Oct 3
Nightmare Fuel #41: The Judge
In this forty-first installment of fictional horror written and narrated by Dan Cummins, we meet Lachlan Harrison. Maybe not the best guy. But does he deserve what happens to him in the forest when he goes for what's supposed to be a light, refreshing hike? And will he atone? For ... Show More
1h 13m
Oct 1
The Eye Dwellers
Dan takes us to China, back to the 17th century for a truly weird and deliciously creepy tale. Then, England, where we explore another story involving a supposedly haunted doll, a doll with no name. Lynze brings us to the UK for a haunted house tale that has the most peculiar rhy ... Show More
1h 6m
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2025
Encounters x264
Well, this episode might be haunted. Our video recording mysteriously stopped midway through, leaving us wondering if our new studio guest (a creepy thrift-store clown) had something to do with it. Whatever the cause, this episode is filled with eerie encounters, wild cryptid sig ... Show More
50m 14s
Mar 2025
Episode 315 - The Vampire Epidemic of Medveđa: A True Horror Story
Episode 315 - The Vampire Epidemic of Medveđa: A True Horror Story What if we told you that one of the most terrifying vampire stories ever… is actually documented in government records? 😱 In this episode, we unearth the chilling legend of Arnold Paole, a Serbian soldier whose a ... Show More
1h 3m
Nov 2024
264: National Park After Dark is Scared to Death
Dan and Lyndze Cummins, hosts of Scared to Death join us today to share some creepy tales. First, we chat about their personal thoughts on and experiences with the other side before they bring us to California and Idaho for some very strange stories filled with legends, curses an ... Show More
1h 22m
Sep 2024
13x12: Early 2000s Internet Predator
Stories in this episode: My Encounter With a Would-Be Axe Murderer | hundmeister420 (0:41) The Fifth Floor | 8bitfarmer (10:49) Random Person in my Driveway at Midnight | Southern-Builder-121 (17:03) The Hostel Creep in Seoul | semper-eadem96 (22:28) No More Laundromats For Me | ... Show More
53m 17s
Mar 2025
Episode 311 - Appalachia | Lore and Superstitions (Part 1)
If you see something, no you didn't. If you hear something, no you didn't. We are diving into one of the most haunted places in the world: the Appalachian Mountain Range. These ancient mountains contain secrets, curses, beats, and cannibals. It's a place where you must rely on al ... Show More
1h 16m
Sep 3
136. Reddit Scary Stories: True Camping Horror Tales (feat. ‪National Park After Dark)
From a recent and tragic double murder in Devil's Den State Park, to a hiker entering a time warp, to unknowingly encountering a serial killer while camping, today we're talking through all the terrifying and mysterious national park stories. Make sure to follow our guests of tod ... Show More
1h 20m
Jan 2025
145 | ATTACKED on the FARM! (6 True Scary Farm Stories)
Become an Eeriecast PLUS Member! https://eeriecast.com/plus GET MY WIFE'S ADORABLE STICKERS!!! https://ko-fi.com/ruffledragons/shop ORDER PHANTOM PHENOMENA: https://a.co/d/3hQAV7e ORDER APPALCHIAN FOLKLORE UNVEILED: https://a.co/d/iteR5xZ Get CRYPTID: The Creepy Card Battling Gam ... Show More
1h 6m
Oct 2024
60 | I'll NEVER Go CAMPING Again - 6 TRUE Scary Outdoor Stories
ORDER PHANTOM PHENOMENA: https://a.co/d/3hQAV7eORDER APPALCHIAN FOLKLORE UNVEILED: https://a.co/d/iteR5xZ VERIFY YOUR ORDERS TO GET THE BONUS! First 100 only. Kindle orders do count! https://eeriecast.com/verify Get CRYPTID: The Creepy Card Battling Game https://cryptidcardgame.c ... Show More
1h 1m
Sep 2024
126 | 5 DISTURBING Confessions from Camp Counselors
Get CRYPTID: The Creepy Card Battling Game https://cryptidcardgame.com/ Read our new wendigo horror novel https://eeriecast.com/lore Sign up for Eeriecast PLUS for bonus content and more https://eeriecast.com/plus Get our merch http://eeriecast.store/ SCARY STORIES TIMESTAMPS: 0: ... Show More
57m 40s
Mar 2025
Episode 313 - The Raven Mocker & The Squonk | Haunted Appalachia Cryptids (Part Three)
Episode 313 - Appalachia's Saddest Cryptid & A Shape-Shifting Witch | Haunted Appalachia (Part 3) From soul-stealing cryptids to the saddest creature you’ve never heard of, we’re wrapping up our three-part deep dive into the eerie folklore of one of the most mysterious regions in ... Show More
1h 6m