logo
episode-header-image
Sep 12
13m 55s

What You Need to Know Before Choosing a ...

MORNINGSTAR
About this episode

Exchange-traded fund launches have continued to accelerate, but not every shiny new strategy is worth owning. Good investment strategies can compensate investors with an appropriate return for the risks they take on. What kinds of ETFs are able to deliver over the long term, and which ones fall short? Dan Sotiroff is joining me today to explain the hidden risks in stock ETFs and what investors should look out for. Dan is a senior manager research analyst for Morningstar Research Services and the editor of Morningstar’s ETFInvestor newsletter.

 

Can you talk about the idea that ETFs should be able to compensate investors for the risk they take on? What is an “appropriate level of return”?

When looking at the risk and return profiles of ETFs, the term “active risk” often comes up. Can you give us a definition?

What kinds of funds have the lowest active risk?

Can you give an example of two ETFs that appear similar but take on different levels of risk?

You’ve written that “any stock ETF with fewer than 100 holdings is a red flag.” Why is that?

Does the management style of the fund make a difference for concentrated funds? Would a passive, index-tracking ETF run into the same issues as an actively managed ETF?

Thematic ETFs are a popular example of concentrated portfolios with high active risk. How have they performed?

Do investors tend to miss the timing on thematic funds? It seems like strong returns tend to be short-lived.

At Morningstar, we often talk about fees as a predictor of performance. Do you see the same thing here?

Should investors always choose a fund that takes on predictable risk? Or are there cases where higher active risk is worth it?

What is one takeaway you have for investors that are trying to choose an ETF?

 

 

Read about topics from this episode.  

Subscribe to Morningstar’s ETFInvestor newsletter

The Hidden Risks in New ETFs

The Best ETFs and How They Fit in Your Portfolio

Morningstar′s Guide to ETF Investing

Passive Funds Beat Active Amid This Year’s Market Volatility

 

What to watch from Morningstar. 
Investing in AI? Here Are 6 Undervalued Stocks for Buy-and-Hold Investors

Do Dividend Stocks Benefit From Non-US Revenue?

This Classic Investment Strategy Is Still Alive in 2025

These 16 Standout Funds Are Making Big Bets. Do They Fit in Your Investment Portfolio?

 

Read what our team is writing.

Daniel Sotiroff

Margaret Giles

 

Follow us on social media.

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/MorningstarInc/

X: https://x.com/MorningstarInc

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/morningstar... 

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/5161/

 

Up next
Oct 3
How Inflation, AI, and Budget Battles Will Shape the Stock Market in Q4
Investors’ exuberance is fueling this year’s stock rally, but will key economic risks dampen the market’s mood? The current bull run has lifted stocks from their springtime lows to higher levels in autumn. The artificial intelligence boom is one of the big factors driving it. Mea ... Show More
23m 33s
Sep 26
Is Your Dividend Income at Risk? Here’s How to Spot Dividend Traps
It might be tempting to buy dividend stocks with the highest yields, but not all dividend payers are safe. Those big payouts could be signaling that a company’s fundamentals are cracking. Looming financial risks could wreak havoc on income-focused investors’ portfolios. But there ... Show More
14m 49s
Sep 19
Should You Hold Cash Investments After the Fed Cuts Interest Rates?
There’s a tug-of-war between investing in cash and long duration bonds in today’s interest environment. The longer-end of the yield curve may look more appealing since anticipation is building about interest rate cuts. Morningstar’s economics team and market watchers are predicti ... Show More
18m 26s
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2025
2025 State of the Stock Market | Brian Feroldi | Ep 531
Explore the latest insights on the stock market performance and investment strategies with friend of the show and frequent guest Brian Feroldi. This episode dives deep into the trends that shaped 2024 and what to expect in 2025, discussing everything from the significance of the ... Show More
40m 3s
May 2025
Warren Buffett’s Real Estate vs. Stocks Strategy & Thoughts on Bitcoin
In this enlightening clip, join Rashad Bilal, Troy Millings, and Ian Dunlap as they break down Warren Buffett’s investment preferences and debate the classic question: stocks or real estate? The trio dives into public records showing Buffett famously owns just one home and prefer ... Show More
7m 19s
May 2020
What the Market Crash Says About How Investing Works
We’ve seen a huge market crash this year and a number of firms reporting portfolio losses. So why were so many big investors crowded into the same trades, and what does it say about investing as a whole? Should investors be playing up to their competitive advantage, or following ... Show More
43m 14s
Jan 2021
SI125: Will the FED always prevent prolonged market crashes ft. Mark Rzepczynski
Mark Rzepczynski joins us today to discuss the Gamestop short-squeeze, democratisation of the investment industry, the increasing expectation among investors that the Federal Reserve will always prevent prolonged market crashes, the 3 main ingredients for a market bubble, whether ... Show More
1h 19m
Mar 2025
We reveal our 2025 investment performance - here's the strategy that works
It’s been an uncertain start to 2025, but how have our portfolios performed so far? In this episode, we break down our real portfolio results, what’s working, what’s not, and the simple investing strategies that have helped us stay on track. Also in this episode; Listener Jenny w ... Show More
15m 57s
Mar 2025
108: How We're Approaching Volatility in 2025
2025 has been a volatile year thus far, as we had predicted months ago. The good news is there are a ton of different ways to position yourself to take advantage of this volatility. NEOS Investments' ETFs, specifically QQQH, has a built in "hedge" for downside risk. Their oth ... Show More
56m 28s
Oct 2023
Duration Remains Unattractive, Says Veteran High Yield Bond Investor
On todays episode, Craig Manchuck Vice President & Portfolio Manager at Osterweis joins the show for a discussion on the end of the zero interest rate era.  We deep dive into the bond market sell-off over the past 3 years, where to find opportunities in the bond market & the rise ... Show More
1h 12m
Mar 2025
Motley Fool’s Ricky Mulvey: Why I’m Buying MORE Stocks Despite Growing Recession Risk
Are we headed right for a recession, or are stocks on sale? We don’t own a crystal ball, but Ricky Mulvey from The Motley Fool is capitalizing on the recent stock market swing by loading up on some of his favorite equities. Stay tuned to find out if now is an ideal time for YOU t ... Show More
55m 10s