logo
episode-header-image
Sep 8
57m 25s

Safe Withdrawal Rates, Drawdown Strategi...

ChooseFI
About this episode

ChooseFI unveils a new feature on the website that allows listeners to have their financial independence questions answered by experts. Featuring in-depth discussions with Karsten Jeske (Big Earn) and Fritz Gilbert, the episode explores the ramifications of potentially increasing the safe withdrawal rate and provides critical insights into retirement strategies, including cash flow considerations like Social Security and required minimum distributions (RMDs).

Key Topics Discussed:

  • Introduction to New Features (00:00:00)

    • Introduction of a Q&A functionality on the ChooseFI website for community engagement.
  • Listener Questions Segment (00:00:36)

    • Introduction to the expert answers provided by Karsten and Fritz.
  • Discussion on Safe Withdrawal Rates (00:05:26)

    • Explanation of the traditional 4% rule and its significance.
  • Karsten's Perspective on the 5.5% Rate (00:07:45)

    • Critique of Bill Bangan’s proposed increase in the safe withdrawal rate and why it may be misleading.
  • Nuances of Early Retirement (00:34:25)

    • Insights on adjusting retirement strategies when planning for longer horizons, emphasizing the time value of money.
  • Fritz on RMDs and Safe Withdrawal Rate (00:36:16)

    • Explanation of how RMDs impact withdrawal strategies, highlighting that RMDs apply only to pre-tax accounts.

Actionable Takeaways:

  • Adjust SWR to account for extended Retirement horizons
  • Incorporate potential income sources such as Social Security into your retirement planning. (00:35:01)
  • Carefully consider your asset allocation to manage risks related to early retirement (e.g., sequence of return risk). (00:48:06)

Key Quotes:

  • "The proposed 5.5% withdrawal rate is misleading and overly optimistic." (00:09:21) - Karsten Jeske
  • "A safe withdrawal rate must not fall below 3.25% for financial security." (00:35:41) - Karsten Jeske
  • "Plan for additional income sources like Social Security in retirement." (00:35:01) - Karsten Jeske
  • "RMDs do not dictate your total spending in retirement." (00:39:00) - Fritz Gilbert
  • "Behavioral finance warns against the pitfalls of emotional investing." (00:51:16) - Brad Barrett

Timestamps:

  • 00:02 - Invitation to submit questions at choosefi.com/feedback.
  • 00:05 - Introduction of Karsten Jeske and Fritz Gilbert.
  • 00:09 - Discussion on the safe withdrawal rate controversy.
  • 00:35 - Required minimum distributions explained.
  • 00:49 - Dynamic withdrawal strategies overview.

Discussion Questions:

  • How do you view the proposed increase in safe withdrawal rates?
  • What strategies are you incorporating to prepare for early retirement?
  • In what ways can Social Security impact your withdrawal strategy?
  • How do you reconcile RMDs with your personal withdrawal goals?

Related Resources:

Up next
Oct 6
Are We Taking the Wrong Risks? With Chris Hutchins | Ep 567
Brad interviews Chris Hutchins, host of the podcast All The Hacks. They dive deep into challenging the traditional mindset of financial independence (FI), exploring the balance between saving for the future and enjoying life experiences in the present. The discussion revolves aro ... Show More
1h 16m
Sep 29
Risk Based Guardrails for Drawdown | Ep 566
Brad welcomes Aubrey Williams, a financial advisor and member of the ChooseFI community. They discuss innovative strategies for financial independence (FI), focusing on flexible withdrawal rates, dynamic spending adjustments using historical analysis, and how adopting a more adap ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 22
Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement | Cody Garrett & Sean Mullaney | Ep 565
Brad Barrett hosts Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney, co-authors of Tax Planning To and Through Early Retirement, exploring essential tax strategies for the FI community. They address misconceptions about retirement taxes, the drawdown process, and effective tax rates, emphasizing t ... Show More
1h 6m
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2017
Michael Kitces – The 4% Rule and Financial Planning for Early Retirement
One of the internet’s most-respected retirement researchers and financial planners, Michael Kitces, joins me for an episode of the Financial Independence Podcast! You may remember that my Safe Withdrawal Rate post drew heavily from the incredible research Kitces has done on the t ... Show More
1h 7m
Aug 2024
Q&A: The Unintended Consequences of Early Retirement
#529: Anonymous, 60, recently lost her job and is worried about retirement. She owns a paid-off triplex, living in one unit and renting the others for $30,000 a year. She used her 401(k) funds to buy the triplex and now has $50,000 in retirement savings and $150,000 in cash. She ... Show More
1h 16m
Sep 2024
560: Dude ACTUALLY Withdraws From His 401(k) and Retires at 47
Did you know you can use your 401(k) to retire early? Yep, it’s possible. And today’s guest, Eric Cooper, is doing it atage 47! Most FIRE chasers search for how to withdraw from a 401(k) early but know that doing so will hit them with substantial penalties. The best way around th ... Show More
50m 39s
Aug 2024
5 Ways to Improve America’s Retirement Savings
Why the Employment Retirement Income Security Act Has Been SuccessfulHow Well Workers from Upper, Middle, and Lower Incomes are Saving for RetirementRetirement Savings by Race and EthnicityHow the Government and Employers Could Expand 401(k) Coverage  Improving Social Security  W ... Show More
15m 39s
Sep 2024
Don't Overlook These Crucial Parts of Your Retirement Plan
Dan Lefkovitz, Morningstar Indexes strategist, explains how following the money can reveal how exposed your portfolio is to geopolitical risks. Christine Benz, Morningstar Inc director of personal finance, is the author of the new book, How to Retire: 20 Lessons for a Happy, Succ ... Show More
26m 23s
Aug 27
Smarter Strategies for Retirement, Wealth Building, and Taxes with Michael Kitces
#243: Discover smarter strategies to grow your wealth and create financial flexibility. We dive into when it makes sense to invest beyond retirement accounts, how to access savings early through Roth conversions and 72(t) distributions, ways to reduce taxes with HSAs, tax-advanta ... Show More
59m 45s
Sep 2024
How to Retire: Stay Flexible with Your Retirement Spending
Christine Benz, Morningstar’s director of personal finance and retirement planning, interviews financial experts about different aspects of retirement in ‘How to Retire,’ the companion podcast to her book of the same name. In this episode, Christine sits down with senior nerd at ... Show More
19m 6s
Feb 2024
Roger Young: Visualizing Retirement Is So Important
Our guest on the podcast today is Roger Young. Roger is thought leadership director at T. Rowe Price, where he and his team conduct research on retirement planning and financial planning matters. Roger has been with T. Rowe Price since 2017. Prior to that, he was a financial advi ... Show More
49m 44s
Feb 2025
3035: [Part 1] Generating Retirement Income Before Age 59 by Darrow Kirkpatrick of Can I Retire Yet
Discover all of the podcasts in our network, search for specific episodes, get the Optimal Living Daily workbook, and learn more at: OLDPodcast.com.Episode 3035:Darrow Kirkpatrick explores various strategies, from leveraging taxable investment accounts to taking advantage of Roth ... Show More
11m 34s
Oct 1
Which Accounts Should I Draw From In Retirement? (Rapid Fire Q&A)
In this episode of The Personal Finance Podcast, Andrew answers 15 listener questions ranging from Solo Roth 401k strategies and crushing $117,000 in student loans to whether a 19-year-old should build credit and how to pass brokerage accounts to your kids without tax headaches. ... Show More
36m 38s