logo
episode-header-image
Aug 5
55m 15s

#12312 Are Annulments Too Legalistic? Un...

CATHOLIC ANSWERS
About this episode

“Are Annulments Too Legalistic?” This episode delves into the complexities of marriage and divorce within the Catholic Church, addressing concerns about the perceived bureaucratic nature of annulments. Tune in as we explore questions about the validity of annulments granted under specific circumstances, the implications for non-Catholics, and the Church’s teachings on relationships during the annulment process.

Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here

Invite our apologists to speak at your parish! Visit Catholicanswersspeakers.com

Questions Covered:

  • 03:25 – Aren’t annulments legalistic, bureaucratic, and all about control?
  • 07:08 – Why was an annulment granted if it doesn’t seem like it should be granted?
  • 13:36 – My boyfriend is Protestant, married in the protestant church and is divorced. Why does he have to get an annulment if he’s not Catholic? He’s not interested in joining the Catholic church at this point. He’s doing this for me because I want to be married in the Catholic Church.
  • 16:24 – Why don’t they call in the priest who gave the couple the pre marriage instruction to a couple seeking an annulment?
  • 18:46 – I got an annulment 20 years ago. Is there a way for me to see what my ex husband submitted on his side of the annulment report?
  • 22:33 – What does the Church teach on pursuing romantic relationships while waiting for an annulment? Is there anything that is offered to help prevent future annulments?
  • 31:05 – You keep talking about the Marriage bond. Does that also include the covenant?
  • 34:14 – If my nephew decided to return to the Church one day, could he have an annulment and remarry one day?
  • 41:48 – Once the annulment is granted the marriage is not valid. Does that mean the kids and their sacraments are also invalid?
  • 44:49 – Can an annulment decision be appealed?
  • 47:55 – Is there any hope to get an annulment if the witnesses are no longer able to be located?
  • 50:51 – My marriage was annulled 50 years ago and all I got was a letter in the mail and I never participated with it. It felt like a slap in the face to be told that my 9.5 year marriage never existed. I left the Catholic Church after that. Should there be a limit to when you can seek an annulment?
Up next
Yesterday
#12341 Is the Eucharist a Literal Sacrifice or Just Symbolic? Body, Blood, and Sacrifice - Joe Heschmeyer
“Is the Eucharist a Literal Sacrifice or a Symbolic Act?” This episode delves into the nature of the Eucharist, addressing questions like whether Jesus spoke symbolically when He said, “This is my body,” and how His command to ‘eat my flesh and drink my blood’ aligns with Jewish ... Show More
55m 15s
Aug 23
#12340 Was the Holy Spirit on Earth Before Jesus? Gospel Order and Apologetics - Jimmy Akin
“Was the Holy Spirit on Earth before Jesus?” This episode explores the role of the Holy Spirit in the context of the Gospel order and apologetics. Additionally, we tackle intriguing questions such as whether Christians can be labeled as “psychopaths on a leash,” the nature of Chr ... Show More
55m 15s
Aug 22
#12339 When Was the Church Born When Christ’s Side was Pierced? - Jimmy Akin
“When was the Church born: At the Cross or at Pentecost?” This episode dives into this question while also exploring diverse topics such as whether Jesus knew the day and hour in Matthew 24:36, the evolution of the term “Christianity” since the Reformation, and the meaning of div ... Show More
55m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
Can't I Go Straight to Jesus? Do I Need the Catholic Church? [Fr. Mike Weighs In]
Maybe you've heard the phrase before, "the middleman is a lie." Or maybe you've found yourself wondering why we have an institutional church as Catholics when the Scriptures state clearly that there is only one mediator between God and man, namely Jesus Christ. Today, Fr. Mike ta ... Show More
8m 41s
Mar 2024
#532 The Accurate Date of the Crucifixion - Jimmy Akin
A topic that tends to come around during Holy Week is the accuracy of the crucifixion, including when it occurred. In this episode, Cy and Catholic Answers Senior Apologist, Jimmy Akin, discuss the question of when exactly Jesus was crucified. Cy Kellett: Hello and welcome to Foc ... Show More
1s
Aug 2024
How Science Proves God! (Dr. John Bergsma) | Ep. 477
Dr. John Bergsma is Professor of Theology at the Franciscan University of Steubenville. A former Protestant pastor, Dr. Bergsma entered the Catholic Church in 2001 while getting his Ph.D. in Bible from the University of Notre Dame. A close collaborator of Dr. Scott Hahn, Bergsma ... Show More
3h 40m
Feb 2024
Being Roman Catholic vs Orthodox
It's Open Line Friday on EWTN Catholic Radio with Colin Donovan. What is the difference between Roman #Catholicism and Orthodox Christians? #Jesus #EWTN #OrthodoxChristianity #EasternOrthodox 
1 h
Feb 2023
#470 Why Is the Filioque a Big Deal to Eastern Orthodox? - Michael Lofton
Michael Lofton, from the Reason and Theology podcast, gives us a primer on the words that many people think are the main divider between Orthodox and Catholic Christians. Does the question about whether the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Father “and from the son” really divide chu ... Show More
31m 51s
Mar 2024
This Day You Will Be with Me in Paradise
Why should we appeal to natural law in moral debates? How do you respond to Protestants about Judith and the deuterocanonical books being historically inaccurate? Where did the thief on the cross go? and more on today's Open Line with Fr. John Trigilio. 
1 h
Aug 2024
Day 223: Differences in Religion in Marriage (2024)
Can a Catholic marry a baptized non-Catholic or a non-baptized person? Fr. Mike breaks down the Church’s teaching on mixed marriages and disparity of cult. The Catechism teaches us that while a difference in religion “does not constitute an insurmountable obstacle for marriage,” ... Show More
17m 35s
Feb 2015
Re-Marriage in the Orthodox Church
In light of the debate in the Roman Catholic Church about divorce and re-marriage, Fr. Tom offers the Orthodox view of this topic as well as an explanation of the fundamental difference in how marriage is viewed in Orthodoxy. We are so happy to have Fr.Tom back recording podcasts ... Show More
32m 30s
Feb 2024
Why Did Paul Hate Jesus and His Followers?
Next to Jesus, Paul is the most important figure in the history of Christianity, but as is well known, before he was a zealous apostle he was an equally zealous antagonist. What was that all about? Why would a Jew in the Roman world outside Israel even care if a small group of Je ... Show More
43m 29s
Aug 2024
When Is a Christian Not A Christian?
Why do so many Christians claim that other Christians are not really Christians? Is there a definition written in the sky somewhere? Here we talk about the history of the problem, from its very beginning. Among other things we'll discuss why some biblical scholars today refuse to ... Show More
42m 5s