logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2024
42m 5s

When Is a Christian Not A Christian?

Bart Ehrman
About this episode

Why do so many Christians claim that other Christians are not really Christians? Is there a definition written in the sky somewhere?

Here we talk about the history of the problem, from its very beginning. Among other things we'll discuss why some biblical scholars today refuse to use the word "Christian" for the apostle Paul, the members of his churches, and for followers of Jesus in the first century altogether; and we'll ask whether there is something about "Christianity" in particular that leads to debates about what it actually means; and we'll try to work out if there's any satisfactory answer to the questions: "Is it possible to define the term to everyone's satisfaction?" and "Does it matter?"

Up next
Yesterday
Fixing Gospel Contradictions: 2nd Century to Now
Around 170 CE, a Syrian Christian named Tatian noticed what a lot of readers have noticed since: the four Gospels don't always agree. So he fixed it. Tatian wove all four into a single, seamless account of Jesus' life. And for roughly two hundred years, in the Syriac-speaking chu ... Show More
37m 53s
Sep 8
Why Are There Four Gospels?
Most Christians are used to reading four Gospels. But why are there four? Why not one? Or twelve? The early Church thinker Irenaeus fought hard to keep Christians reading all four gospels, but it wasn't a foregone conclusion. In this episode, Bart unpacks how a four gospel new te ... Show More
44m 8s
Sep 1
Was Paul an Eyewitness of Jesus' Resurrection?
In a recent response to Wes Huff, Bart said the only eyewitness we know of who's converting people is Paul. A lot of people pointed out that Paul never met Jesus. Fair. But Paul is also the only person in the New Testament who tells us, in his own words, that he saw Jesus alive a ... Show More
40m 2s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2023
Is Christianity Exclusive?
Kyle Worley and Rebecca McLaughlin faithfully explore the question, is Christianity exclusive?Questions Covered in This Episode:Is Christianity exclusive? What does that mean?Isn’t it arrogant to say there is only one true religion?When we say Christianity is exclusive and that J ... Show More
26m 8s
Nov 2025
What Is a ‘Fleshly’ Christian?
Are “fleshly” Christians truly Christian? Pastor John traces Paul’s distinctions between natural people, carnal Christians, and spiritual Christians. 
13m 55s
Oct 2023
Apologetics and Academia Part One
What is the difference between popular apologetics and Christian scholarship? 
20m 47s
Mar 2023
Can Christians Argue Ideas?
Kyle Worley and Rebecca McLaughlin have a conversation about what it looks like for Christians to argue ideas.Questions Covered in This Episode:Ideas matter, right?Can Christians argue about ideas?Does it matter how we argue?What does it mean to argue with gentleness and respect? ... Show More
44m 50s
Jul 2025
God’s Word, Human Words, and Political Idols
Is Christian nationalism compatible with the teachings of Jesus? Is the Bible purely divine, or also human? And how should Christians understand atonement and explain it to children?In this episode of Ask NT Wright Anything, Tom Wright and Mike Bird tackle the controversial topic ... Show More
34m 26s
Sep 2025
Are Christians Too Biased to be Trusted?
J. Warner Wallace examines the popular objection that Christians are biased toward their beliefs and, therefore, cannot assess evidence fairly. Is this true? Is anyone truly free of bias and what role does this play in making decisions in the first place? 
1h 7m
Sep 2021
“Show me a single verse from the Quran where Jesus (pbuh) himself says, “I am only a Prophet” or “Do not worship me”
A Christian Challenges 
4m 20s
Aug 2023
#496 Major Controversies in First Century Christianity - Jimmy Akin
The first century of Christianity was often a raucous argument. Essential truths were constantly under threat, and confusion was common. Jimmy Akin joins us to discuss what the great arguments of the first century were about and what we can learn from them. Cy Kellett: Hello and ... Show More
44m 21s