logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2025
57m 38s

Tiffany Cole: Buried Alive | #404

Wondery | RedHanded
About this episode

Party girl Tiffany Cole had always relied on the kindness of strangers – including her former neighbours, Reggie and Carol Sumner. This frail older couple helped Tiffany out as if she were their own daughter…

And she repaid their kindness by digging their grave. Literally.

Tiffany claimed it was all her boyfriend’s idea, and she never meant for the Sumners to get hurt. But how did a boneheaded robbery plot by a bunch of party rats go so terribly wrong? And crucially: how much did Tiffany really know? We unearth the dark truth in this week’s episode.

Exclusive bonus content:

Wondery - Ad-free & ShortHand

Patreon - Ad-free & Bonus Episodes

Follow us on social media:

YouTube

TikTok

Instagram

Visit our website:

Website

Sources available on redhandedpodcast.com

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Oct 8
Unit 731: Japan’s Secret Human Testing Program | #420
One of WWII’s lesser-known horrors, Japan’s secret biological warfare testing program is so brutal and inhumane that it’s hard to believe it could ever happen. And at its helm was a twisted microbiologist Shiro Ishi. Victims, known inside as “logs”, were injected and exposed to c ... Show More
1h 6m
Oct 7
ShortHand: Hell
Boiled in blood, hacked at by knives, torn apart by iron dogs… the world’s religions differ on what exactly might await sinners in the afterlife. But one thing they can all agree on is that if you were naughty on Earth, you are in for one hell of a horrible time.We take a quick t ... Show More
32m 15s
Oct 2
Arne Cheyenne Johnson: The Devil Made Me Do It | #419
In 1981, nineteen-year-old Arne Cheyenne Johnson stabbed his landlord to death – but claimed he wasn’t guilty. Why? Because he was possessed by the literal Devil.With a wild alibi starring a possessed tween, budget exorcisms and even a cameo from America’s most notorious spooky g ... Show More
1 h
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
Kansas Moms Killed by Grandma & God’s Misfits: The Case of Veronica Butler & Jilian Kelley
Veronica Butler was in a long-standing custody battle for her children with her mother-in-law, Tiffany Adams, for several years, but in March of 2024, it all came to an end when Tiffany orchestrated and carried out her murder. Veronica had been granted supervised visitation with ... Show More
1h 1m
Feb 2024
309: The Murder of Rachel Burkheimer
Hey ya'll! Tori was sick for this one so I hope you can put up with just me! -Tyrella In September of 2002, 18-year-old Rachel Burkheimer went to a house party with friends, thinking that she’d have a night of fun. Unfortunately, Rachel never returned home from the party. Instead ... Show More
43m 32s
Mar 2025
Murder on Steroids (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
On a summer night In 2013, newlyweds Joe and Olga Connell walked into their condominium in Wilmington, Delaware. Joe flipped on the light and sat down on the couch, while Olga headed to the bedroom to get changed. Suddenly, Joe heard a loud scream. He got up, and ran down the hal ... Show More
34m 37s
Dec 2024
The Seductive Suburban Housewife that Got away with Murder: case of Kent Leppink
Michelle Hughs grew up being the prettiest woman in the room. She had a charm that made people feel special and when you spoke to her she could make you feel heard and like you were the only one in the room. And while working at a nightclub, Michelle would use this charm to manip ... Show More
47m 24s
Sep 2024
The Murder of Natalie Scheublin (Massachusetts)
Investigators who first worked the 1971 homicide case of Natalie Scheublin in Bedford, Massachusetts considered every possible theory for her death – kidnapping for ransom, burglary gone wrong, a random attack in an otherwise quiet community – and yet nothing led police to the tr ... Show More
39m 42s
Feb 2025
Shelly Knotek: Mother, Manipulator, Murderer
Retired FBI agent and criminal profiler Candice DeLong delves into the chilling case of Shelly Knotek, a woman who hid monstrous cruelty behind a facade of kindness. For years, Shelly inflicted years of abuse, control, and torture on her own family and friends – completely undete ... Show More
51m 34s
Sep 18
The Murder of Lena Bruce (Massachusetts)
Lena Bruce had a bright future ahead of her. She’d just graduated from a top university and landed a great job, and she was settling into a new apartment in the heart of Boston’s South End neighborhood, already living the life she’d worked for since she was a child. But one night ... Show More
34m 58s
Feb 2025
Tamala "Nikki" Wells
In early August 2012, 33-year-old Tamala “Nikki” Wells vanished from her Detroit, Michigan, home under mysterious circumstances, leaving her friends in a state of confusion and despair. The last person to see Tamala, her boyfriend, claims she drove off from their home on the even ... Show More
1h 2m
Sep 8
Betrayed By Kindness : Episode 460
We all know the quote, "If you can be one thing, be kind."Edna Slater was a kind woman. She wasn't wealthy, but she did all she could to help people in her community in Leeds who were down on their luck, by lending money or allowing them to do odd jobs in her home for cash. But E ... Show More
27m 37s
Oct 5
The Facebook Trap that Ended in Murder.
Virgina, 2021: Chelsea Perkins, a married mum of 2, opened up Facebook to reconnect with an old school friend called Matthew Dunmire. But this catchup had dark intentions… Chelsea had a very serious axe to grind with Matthew. Back in 2017 Chelsea accused him of assaulting her but ... Show More
54m 5s