logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2025
59m 20s

I Was a Time Out Magazine Bachelor (w/ L...

Headgum & Nicole Byer
About this episode

TV writer Lauren Ashley Smith (A Black Lady Sketch Show, Smith Sisters Live) joins Nicole to talk about how she met her wife the old-fashioned way - through Time Out New York’s Singles issue.

Lauren reveals the strange public response to being a “bachelor” in a magazine, how her wife was one of the only white women working at BET, and the complications that came with planning an interracial lesbian wedding.

She also recalls a bizarre school Valentine’s Day test that matched students based on compatibility, and she and Nicole discuss who gets to keep the friends after a breakup. Plus, Nicole gets a magical hot massage and somehow walks away being fluent in Greek.

And Lauren shares one big piece of dating advice: why straight people should try dating more like lesbians -letting go of the gender roles getting in the way.


Watch this episode on our YouTube channel at https://www.youtube.com/@WhyWontYouDateMePodcast


Support this podcast and get discounts by checking out our sponsors:

» OneSkin: OneSkin is redefining the aging process with their proprietary OS-01 peptide. Get 15% off OneSkin with the code DATEME at https://www.oneskin.co/ #oneskinpod

» EarnIn: Make Any Day Payday! When you download the EarnIn app, type in Why Won't You Date Me under PODCAST when you sign up – it’ll really help the show. 

» Booking.com: Book now at Booking.com!

» Wayfair: Wayfair. Every Style, Every Home.

View all of our sponsors and discounts codes at wwydm.notion.site/sponsors.


Follow:

Tour Dates: linktr.ee/nicolebyerwastaken

YouTube: @WhyWontYouDateMePodcast

TikTok: @whywontyoudatemepod 

Instagram: @nicolebyer

X: @nicolebyer

Nicole's book, #VERYFAT #VERYBRAVE: indiebound.org/book/9781524850746

This is a Headgum podcast. Follow Headgum on TwitterInstagram, and Tiktok. Advertise on Why Won't You Date Me? via Gumball.fm.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Oct 3
The Viral Hijabi Pole Dancer (w/ Neda Momeni)
Nurse practitioner and pole dancer Neda Momeni is here and teaches Nicole a lot! From her years as a labor and delivery nurse, she explains what actually happens in the hospital during childbirth and what most people never hear about until they’re living it. She talks about Musli ... Show More
1h 2m
Sep 26
Hooking Up with Go-Go Dancers (w/ Adore Delano)
Drag queen, singer, and actress Adore Delano (RuPaul's Drag Race S6, All Stars 2, American Idol) joins Nicole to share stories about hooking up with go-go dancers, filming a sex tape she regrets, and her path to sobriety. She opens up about transitioning twice, the facial feminiz ... Show More
1h 1m
Sep 19
Sex Talk Got Me Fired (w/ Rachel Bilson)
Actress Rachel Bilson (The O.C., Broad Ideas) once lost a job over something she said on a podcast. She tells Nicole what that was like, current cancel culture, and why “free speech” doesn’t always apply to everyone. Rachel shares some of her wildest dating stories, from terrible ... Show More
47m 24s
Recommended Episodes
May 2025
How to Take No Sh*t From Men (and Still Date Them) with Drew Afualo
Put this episode on if you want to get fired up (in the best way). We loved having author and influencer Drew Afualo in the studio going all the way off about the patriarchy and taking no shit from men (on the internet and IRL). She shares her journey of working in sports, gettin ... Show More
1h 23m
Apr 2025
First Date Red Flags with Jeremy Jacobowitz
We have our friend, content creator, and second GGE guest ever Jeremy Jacobowitz back on the show to talk about our favorite topics – food and dating. We kick this fun convo off talking about the most underrated food cities, traveling to Japan, LA vs. NYC food scenes, Jeremy’s be ... Show More
1h 41m
Feb 2023
E544 Bachelor Recap with Jason Ritter
Welcome back to another episode of The Viall Files: Bachelor Recap Edition! We’re joined by actor and producer, Jason Ritter! to discuss the fifth episode of Zach’s season. We start out by covering the week’s Bachelor Tea, including Erich Schwer’s new romance and rumors of Chris ... Show More
1h 26m
Nov 2024
107: Are They Avoidant, Narcissistic, or Just An A*shole? With Joe Nucci
Sabrina welcomes Joe Nucci to discuss dating and relationship dynamics, starting with the misconception that location is the root of dating struggles. Joe notes that while cities like New York and Colorado have distinct dating cultures, true obstacles often stem from avoidance an ... Show More
48m 33s
Nov 2019
Chicks In The Office: Mario Ciuffo & Fran Mariano
Host of Bartool Sports' Chicks In The Office - MARIA CIUFOO & FRAN MARIANO - share their journey from college dropouts to sports interns to to running a hit podcast... and how they refused to hate each other! ALSO: Bella Thorne - Tati Westbrook - James Charles - and Jenna's expos ... Show More
47m 18s
Jan 2025
Why Dating Feels IMPOSSIBLE: Physical Attraction, Can’t Commit & Why You’re Single! Kait and JJ
On today’s episode we have Christian dating coaches, Kait and JJ, on to discuss the downfall of men in our society, does attraction in relationships matter, why is divorce on the rise, and what Does God want for godly relationships? Thanks for listening! We’ll see you back here F ... Show More
1h 6m
Mar 2025
128: Why Men REALLY Pull Away—The Truth No One Tells You with Connell Barrett
Ever feel like dating is one giant guessing game? You meet a guy, everything’s great—until suddenly, he's pulling away. Or maybe you keep hearing, "You're amazing, but I just don't feel the spark." What the hell is actually going on in their heads? In this episode, I sit down wit ... Show More
59m 52s
Feb 2025
E886 - Traitors & SNL50 w/ Cazzie David, Love Is Blind w/ Dave, Summer House Premiere & Valentine's Day
Welcome back to The Viall Files: Reality Recap!  Today we are joined by Cazzie David to get her hot takes on SNL50, Traitors, and her new movie I Love You Forever. Meanwhile, Dave joins to talk about the newest season of Love Is Blind (only to those on the couch under 30), and Pa ... Show More
2h 4m
Feb 2025
The ‘Let Them Theory’ Will Change Your Relationships feat. Mel Robbins
We are honored to be joined by Mel Robbins, author of the bestselling, life-changing book The Let Them Theory. We talk to her about the theory and how you can apply it to relationships, daily stress, career goals, and family conflicts to live a more free and authentic life. We di ... Show More
1h 18m
Aug 2024
Lessons from Your 20s with Lisa Gilmore
Episode 277: This week, Nat is joined by her friend Lisa Gilmore, a jewelry entrepreneur living in Miami, as they chat about everything from the Miami dating scene to personal growth to why Instagram will likely never have a search function to see who’s looked at your stories (co ... Show More
56m 30s