In this gripping episode, we delve deep into the disturbing and mysterious story of the Guy family. What initially seems like an ordinary family harbors dark secrets and an unimaginable tragedy. Discover the chilling events that unfolded in their Knoxville home, leaving everyone shocked and perplexed. Join us as we uncover the unsettling details of this true ... Show More
Aug 28
The Murder of Marta del Castillo: Spain's Most Frustrating Murder Mystery
Marta del Castillo vanished in Seville, sparking Spain’s most haunting murder mystery. Explore the investigation, shifting confessions, missing body, disputed evidence, and unanswered questions that continue to haunt the case. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/ ... Show More
1h 36m
Aug 26
Michael Peterson: The Staircase Killer Who Went Free
Was Michael Peterson a cold-blooded killer or the victim of a flawed investigation? Explore the staircase death, shocking evidence, disputed theories, courtroom battles, and the twists that changed everything. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
1h 33m
Aug 24
Amanda Knox and the Murder of Meredith Kercher.
Meredith Kercher’s murder became one of the world’s most controversial criminal cases. Explore the investigation, Amanda Knox trial, Rudy Guede, disputed evidence, shocking twists, and unanswered questions. Sponsor: shopify.com/casual - start your free trial today Learn more abou ... Show More
2h 13m
Jan 2024
Ep.57 - Joel Guy Jr & the Head in the Pot
Joel Guy Jr was seen as the odd son of the Guy family, and shortly after Thanksgiving one year, his parents were nowhere to be found. When the cops finally gained entry, the discovery was horrifying. Send your spooky stories to mikeohhello@gmail.com! thatchapter@night.co for ... Show More
41m 19s
Apr 2022
EP. 62 CONNECTICUT - The Petit Home Invasion: Cheshire's Dark Stain
This is one of the most disturbing true crime stories we've ever heard, and it impacted so many people. In one night, almost entire family was wiped off the face of the earth by forces of unspeakable evil... and they left only one survivor. This, is th story of the Petit home inv ... Show More
1h 16m
Aug 2025
Brothers, Betrayal, and Beverly Hills: The Menendez Brothers Pt. I
It’s one of those cases where the headlines never told the full story. A picture-perfect family, a brutal crime, and two sons at the center of it all. This week, we’re unraveling the layers behind a case that still doesn’t sit right. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaph ... Show More
52m 5s
Apr 2024
214. The Encounter With Evil - The Groene Family Murder
On this episode, Payton and Garrett dive into the nightmare that happened to an unsuspecting family in rural Idaho.
Case Sources:
wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Edward_Duncan
Stolen in the Night (2007, St. Martin's), by Gary C. King
People Magazine Investigates, episode: "The Gro ... Show More
49m 30s