logo
episode-header-image
May 2021
39m 19s

Cinnamon and Hay

iHeartPodcasts
About this episode

Special prosecutors described the Wagners as “cult like.” In episode two, we take a deeper look at the family that’s allegedly behind the massacre, speaking with a Pike County local who has an intimate connection to them. We also dissect the prosecution's theories on the family’s complex dynamics. On the surface, the Wagners may have seemed all American but behind closed doors, they were anything but. What we found out was far darker and more disturbing than anything we ever could have imagined. 

Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.com

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Up next
Aug 6
Introducing: Hands Tied
Hi, Idaho Massacre listeners! We're excited to share with you a sneak peek at iHeartPodcasts' latest release, Hands Tied! Hands Tied: Lizz Melgar Rose went from being interested in true crime to living true crime. Back in 2012, relatives found her mother Sandy Melgar shut in a cl ... Show More
2m 23s
Jul 19
Introducing: The Girlfriends: Jailhouse Lawyer
What does it mean to be a victim, or a villain? What happens when the line between the two starts to blur? On 7th July 2010, Kelly Harnett says her abusive boyfriend murdered a man right in front of her. So how did she end up in prison for it? Anna Sinfield - the journalist behin ... Show More
5m 29s
Jun 2
Introducing: True Crime Tonight
Hi, Idaho Massacre listeners! We're excited to share with you a sneak peek at iHeartPodcasts' latest release, True Crime Tonight. True Crime Tonight: If you eat, sleep, and breathe true crime, TRUE CRIME TONIGHT is serving up your nightly fix. Five nights a week, KT STUDIOS & iHE ... Show More
1m 3s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2020
Family Interrupted
A family interrupts a burglary in their suburban home. The gunman kills two and wounds two more. Police suspect the crime is related to a string of thefts in the area, but a closer look at the crime scene reveals the real motive and killer. To learn more about how HLN protects li ... Show More
23m 37s
Oct 2023
Introducing... SEVERED AFFAIR: The Gruesome Murder of Shad Thyrion
Wisconsin is no stranger to high-profile cases and horrific murderers, from the notorious Jeffrey Dahmer to the perplexing Ed Gein. But on a cold night in February 2022, a new name was added to the list of Wisconsin’s worst: Taylor Schabusiness. From the outset, the details of th ... Show More
6m 45s
Mar 2024
Inside The Raven
"Inside the Raven" takes listeners behind the scenes of the podcast and one of sports history's most notorious crimes. Host Tim Livingston traces his journey from his own past, to connecting with victims' families in Akron, Ohio, to unearthing new evidence. Livingston also reveal ... Show More
42m 16s
Sep 2022
Pike County massacre; Tammy Daybell’s autopsy; Atlanta murderer still at large - TCD Sidebar
In this episode of True Crime Daily The Sidebar Podcast: Forensics expert Joseph Scott Morgan joins host Joshua Ritter to discuss the crime scene investigations surrounding some of the most notorious cases across the country. They break down the complicated analysis of the Pike C ... Show More
53m 52s
Sep 2023
Introducing: Severed Affair
Wisconsin is no stranger to high-profile cases and horrific murderers, from the notorious Jeffrey Dahmer to the perplexing Ed Gein. But on a cold night in February 2022, a new name was added to the list of Wisconsin’s worst: Taylor Schabusiness. From the outset, the details of th ... Show More
1m 42s
Apr 2023
The Most Wonderful Terrible Person
When Debra Miller woke up on October 8th, 1964, she was expecting to see a black Volkswagen in her family’s driveway. Instead, she saw a police car. “And I knew my father was dead.” Say hello on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. Sign up for our occasional newsletter, The Accomplic ... Show More
46m 26s
Mar 2014
Call Your Mom
There are plenty of things we don't share with our mothers. Dark, sad things. Unless of course, you both speak the same dark language. Kathleen Vernon is a coroner in Albany County, Wyoming, the youngest ever, in fact. But she didn’t come to this preternatural curiosity just on h ... Show More
15m 54s
Dec 2022
Nightmare Next Door (Kristin Scarabelli)
The family, community and police are convinced that a strange neighbor is behind the murder of teen girl. But a phone call confession urges detectives to look in a different direction. For episode information and photos, please visit https://anatomyofmurder.com/. Can’t get enough ... Show More
45m 29s
Jun 2022
The Piketon Massacre: How We Got Here - Seasons 1 & 2 Recap
Hey Dougherty Gang fans, the third season of The Piketon Massacre is finally here, so check our recap episode here before hopping over to the Piketon feed for some incredible new content. Whether you've never listened to The Piketon Massacre or you're already a huge fan, you will ... Show More
54m 30s