logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2024
1h 7m

Murderinos

Rehash
About this episode

Ever since Serial burst onto the scene back in 2015 , it birthed not only the world of podcasting itself, but an entire cottage industry of true crime podcasts, each one more ethically dubious than the last. But one such podcast may be, at least by title, the very worst: My Favorite Murder. This wildly popular series has been criticized over the years for its flippant water-cooler recounting of people’s real life traumas. And while My Favorite Murder made efforts to correct some of its wrongs, it has facilitated an avid online fandom called Murderinos, comprised mostly of self-proclaimed mentally ill girlies who have grown so prominent on the internet as to embody their own subculture. In this episode, Hannah and Maia discuss the bizarre formation of this alt-girl army, question arbitrary lines drawn in the true crime sand, and ponder whether shame is sometimes a good thing. Tangents include: Hannah and Maia undergoing public couple’s therapy, and Hannah’s coining of the term “shame-negative’. 


Support us on Patreon and get juicy bonus content:

⁠https://www.patreon.com/rehashpodcast⁠


Intro and outro song by our talented friend Ian Mills:

⁠https://linktr.ee/ianmillsmusic



Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Up next
Aug 11
Sabrina Carpenter's Album Cover [teaser]
In a time where Sydney Sweeney is spreading her legs for a popular clothing retailer in the name of eugenics, it’s not so far-fetched to imagine that Sabrina Carpenter would also upset people with her latest album cover. Hair blown out, kneeling at the feet of a suited man, and c ... Show More
9m 29s
Aug 4
Facetune
Why isn’t “airbrushed skin for all” written in the constitution? For years, photoshop was a professional’s game, gatekept, if you will, from the masses. But then Facetune came about and forever changed the course of history, democratizing photoshop to the dysmorphic masses. The p ... Show More
1h 16m
Jul 28
Glossier
For those of us whose “smokey eye” and “blending” skills fell short during the beauty guru makeup regime, Glossier was our saviour. Founded by “super intern” Emily Weiss (who has a brief 3-episode run on The Hills as Lauren Conrad’s more competent counterpart at Vogue), Glossier ... Show More
1h 9m
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2024
81. Not for Meet Cutes + How "Sex and the City" Lied to Us
Welcome back to Not For Everyone, where this week, Jess and Caroline think people need to cool it. They discuss how people don’t know how to be properly annoyed anymore, how people can’t stop demeaning Americans on the internet, and how people go insane in the comment sections. T ... Show More
1h 13m
Aug 2024
Crime Junkies Host Ashley Flowers on True Crime, Activism, and Becoming a Novelist
As part of our summer series of re-airing the best of “For the Love,” we also have Jen’s long time friend, Amy Hardin, joining Jen to introduce this episode that was originally aired on the premium channel. In this new episode, we’ll hear about Jen and Amy’s summer so far and wha ... Show More
55m 6s
Mar 2025
114. Not for Therapy Speak + Behind the Scenes of a Hater Engagement (!!!)
This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. Visit https://www.betterhelp.com/notforeveryone today to get 10% off your first month.Stop putting off those doctors appointments and go to https://www.zocdoc.com/notforeveryone to find and instantly book a top-rated doctor today. __Your hate ... Show More
1h 24m
Nov 2024
13x21: Tinder Girl
Stories in this episode: I Think Someone Tried to Rob/Scam Us | c*ntpunt2000 (0:40) Tinder Girl | Tyler (9:40)  Granny | Bearsliveinthewoods (15:45)  Might Have Saved a Woman and Her Daughter From a Nasty Encounter | alexsupertramp89 (22:23)  Bright Angel | Phat-Assests (30:04)  ... Show More
52m 3s
Jun 2024
Salman Rushdie - ‘I’d rather have had a different life’
TW: this episode contains graphic descriptions of violence and injuries. Two years ago, Sir Salman Rushdie, one of the most celebrated and famous authors in the world was on stage at the Chautauqua Institution in upstate New York, when a figure dressed in black clothes and a mask ... Show More
55m 39s
Jan 2025
105. Not for Wife Guys + Blake Lively and the One Thing No One is Talking About
This show is sponsored by BetterHelp. Visit https://www.betterhelp.com/notforeveryone today to get 10% off your first month. This show is sponsored by Skims. Check out the Fits Everybody Collection at https://www.skims.com/notforeveryone #skimspartner __ Coming off the holidays, ... Show More
1h 10m
Mar 2024
Kind World presents: "Beyond All Repair," a new podcast about an unsolved murder and a woman who wasn’t believed
Introducing Beyond All Repair, a new WBUR podcast hosted by Amory Sivertson. This series tells the story of a murder, but also the woman who was accused of that murder, Sophia. Sophia was newly married and six months pregnant when she was charged with murdering her mother-in-law ... Show More
25m 28s
Mar 2025
112. Hater Hour: Overcoming Imposter Syndrome, Leaving Mormonism, and Making Adult Friendships | ft. Prince Abi Our Editor!
It’s about time we had another Hater Hour…and in this episode, Caroline is joined by Not For Everyone Editor Prince Abi! They’ve got lots to say about listener submissions, including discussions about freelancing, working together while maintaining their friendship, building a li ... Show More
1h 37m
Mar 2025
14x11: Plans For Murder
Stories in this episode: His Plans Escalated to Murder | Anonymous (0:40) Followed on the Sketchy Side of Town | No_Career_2880 (12:19) Don't Go to the Gas Station at Night | Important-Self-6311 (20:05) A Stranger Entered My Apt When I Was 10 | Spoon (23:28) The Fireman's Widow | ... Show More
52m 40s
Oct 2024
243: Pop Apologists 101
Lauren and Chan are taking a trip down memory lane and sharing exactly how Pop Apologists came to be. The gals talk about the earliest days of the podcast, the day the podcast left the airwaves, and what finally brought Pop Apologists back to the podcast world. They go into detai ... Show More
58m 10s