logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2024
31m 22s

Charter Closures, Elite College Admissio...

Chelsea Adams, Kate Day
About this episode

Charters Closures Leave Students Scrambling

New research from the National Center for Charter School Accountability and the Network for Public Education reveals troubling patterns in charter school longevity. Analyzing over 2 million Department of Education records, researchers found that 55% of charter schools fail by their 20th year, with a quarter closing within just five years of opening. These closures, often triggered by enrollment decline or mismanagement, create significant disruptions for millions of students annually—frequently with little to no warning.

Elite College Admissions Arms Race

The rise of premium college consulting services, like Jamie Beaton's Crimson Education, has sparked fresh debate about equity in elite college admissions. With consultants working with students as young as 11 to craft the perfect academic profile, and boasting acceptance rates 6-7 times higher than normal at prestigious institutions like Harvard and Yale, we're forced to question: Has college admissions become more about costly strategies than merit?

UK's Bold Moves Against Phones in Schools

UK educators and teachers' unions are pushing for national legislation to ban smartphones in schools. A proposed bill introduced by Labour MP Josh MacAlister would require students to store phones in locked boxes until the end of the school day. Early adopters of similar policies report decreased drama and increased physical activity among students. Even Eton College, Britain's most elite boarding school, is joining the movement, having announced a phone ban that started in September 2024. Their approach? Allow simple Nokia phones for calls and texts while prohibiting smart devices—a move aimed at prioritizing learning and reducing distractions.

Oklahoma's Ongoing Religious Education Controversy

A lawsuit filed with the Oklahoma Supreme Court on October 17th challenges State Superintendent Ryan Walters' plan to spend $3 million on leather-bound Bibles containing the Constitution and Declaration of Independence for public schools. Parents and teachers argue this mandate violates religious freedom by favoring a specific Protestant interpretation.

College Sports' New Era

The National Letter of Intent (NLI) system, a cornerstone of college athletic recruitment since 1964, has been eliminated as of October 2024. Athletes will now sign financial aid agreements that may include revenue-sharing contracts—a change following the 2021 Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) reforms. This shift could widen the gap between wealthy institutions and smaller programs, though its full impact remains to be seen.

Subscribe to 16:1 podcast for more in-depth analysis of education policy and reform. Listen to the full episode on your favorite podcast platform or stream it directly from our website.

Sources & Resources:

Stanton wins ALCS MVP as peers agree: 'This is what Big G lives for'

Tsuchinshan-ATLAS Comet appears on the western horizon

The Guru Who Says He Can Get Your 11-Year-Old Into Harvard - WSJ

Signings of the times: Banished letters of intent, shrunk transfer window equals more college chaos | AP News

NCAA approves elimination of national letter of intent program - ESPN

New students at Eton, the poshest of Britain's elite private schools, will not be allowed smartphones - CBS News

More than 25% of charters shutter within 5 years - K-12 Dive

New Report Reveals Startling Rates of Charter School Failures - WJBF

Texas AFT :‘Doomed To Fail’: New Report Shows How Charter School Churn Harms Students They Purported to Help ‣ Texas AFT

Oklahoma parents and teachers sue to stop top education official's classroom Bible mandate

Bibles that Oklahoma wants for schools match version backed by Trump | AP News

Oklahoma parents and teachers sue to stop top education official’s classroom Bible mandate | CNN

Supreme Court of Oklahoma - Ryan Walters Case

Doomed to Fail - NCCSA

New students at Eton, the poshest of Britain's elite private schools, will not be allowed smartphones - CBS News

First school to ban smartphones adds to pressure on Starmer to protect children | The Independent

Mobile phones in schools - GOV.UK

Fight begins to make mobile-free schools law

Smartphones could be banned in schools in England under new law

Up next
Jun 12
Year in Review: Volume IV
In our final episode of the 2024-25 season, we reflect upon our year of learning and how our philosophies of education continue to evolve. We return to perennial questions: What's the purpose of education? Who gets to learn, and how? How do we best learn? What’s worth unlearning? ... Show More
28m 54s
May 29
The Future of Community News: The Reporting Project at Denison University
Something about the newsroom of The Reporting Project at Denison University in Granville, Ohio feels different. It’s energetic— humming, even when the lights are dimmed and the computer screens are turned off at the end of a long day of writing, collaborating, and crafting storie ... Show More
45m 33s
May 15
The Evidence of Your Eyes and Ears
This week we’re taking a break from the evolving civic situation in the U.S. to shine light on global stories in education that you may have missed.Nepal’s National Teachers’ Strike Lifted: Teachers and Students in Nepal are resuming classes more than a month after teachers began ... Show More
25m 26s
Recommended Episodes
Apr 13
Aaron Kupchik, "Suspended Education: School Punishment and the Legacy of Racial Injustice" (NYU Press, 2025)
Every year, millions of public school students are suspended. This overused punishment removes students from the classroom, but it does not improve their behavior. Instead, suspension disrupts their education, harming the students, their families, and their schools. Black student ... Show More
27m 43s
Mar 2025
529. How Trump Will Save the School System | Corey DeAngelis
Jordan Peterson sits down with bestselling author, commentator, and researcher, Dr. Corey DeAngelis. They shed light on where 50% of all state budgets are spent, the surprising stack of monopolies that strangleholds public education, the partisan lies surrounding school choice, a ... Show More
1h 23m
Jun 3
Trump vs Harvard: India Impact
The Trump-Harvard tussle over international students has aspirants and their parents in a bind. In this episode of The Morning Brief, host Prachi Verma explores the ripple effect of the clash and what it signals for the future of American higher education. With its federal certif ... Show More
20m 10s
Aug 2024
The new wave of private school vouchers
For decades, private school vouchers, often referred to as school choice programs, were limited to low-income students. But recently, several states have passed universal voucher programs that any family, regardless of income, can use to pay their kids’ private school tuition. On ... Show More
27m 2s
Aug 2024
221: How to advocate for the schools our children deserve with Allyson Criner Brown & Cassie Gardener Manjikian
How to advocate for the schools our children deserve   How comfortable do you feel speaking up about something your child’s school needs? Have you noticed that some parents seem to feel more comfortable speaking up than others? Have you ever noticed that sometimes rules and polic ... Show More
1h 11m
Apr 22
Dismantling the Dept of Ed & the Woke Agenda w Linda McMahon
Linda McMahon's Appointment: Linda McMahon was appointed as the Secretary of Education by the President, who wanted her to dismantle the Department of Education. Despite her background not being primarily in education, she has experience on the Connecticut State Board of Educatio ... Show More
17m 14s
Jun 2024
The War for America's Classrooms - From Texas to You
Subscribe for $5.99 a month to get full access to this episode, bonus content most Mondays, bonus episodes every month, ad-free listening, access to the entire 500-episode archive, Discord access, and more: https://axismundi.supercast.com/Mike Hixenbaugh is a Pulitzer finalist, P ... Show More
36m 51s
Jun 2023
Jack Schneider and Jennifer Berkshire, "A Wolf at the Schoolhouse Door: The Dismantling of Public Education and the Future of School" (The New Press, 2023)
Across the U.S., state legislatures-often under the cover of darkness, and usually in spite of public opposition-are passing bills that channel public dollars to private schools. These voucher schemes promise to transfer billions from state treasuries to upper-income families. Bu ... Show More
44m 51s
Oct 2023
John Arena, "Expelling Public Schools: How Antiracist Politics Enable School Privatization in Newark" (U Minnesota Press, 2023)
Exploring the role of identitarian politics in the privatization of Newark’s public school system In Expelling Public Schools, John Arena explores the more than two-decade struggle to privatize public schools in Newark, New Jersey—a conflict that is raging in cities across the co ... Show More
47m 20s
May 2024
The Future of Education in Washington State with Superintendent Chris Reykdal
Washington State Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal has been at the helm of education in this state for seven of the most challenging years in education in recent memory. But that hasn't dissuaded him from seeking a third term this November. In this episode, ... Show More
26m 16s