logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2024
26m 15s

E2: Mistaken Identity

CBC
About this episode

When baby Clarence Hynes was brought home from the hospital, someone casually asked if this small dark haired baby was really a Hynes? His parents ignored it, taught to let mysteries lie. And after they died early, Clarence put his head down and focused on being a good big brother and supporting his family. So when someone mistook him for an Avery brother, he shrugged it off: “Somebody always looks like somebody, right?” But the coincidences became too insistent to ignore.

Up next
Jun 2024
E3: The Bricklayer’s Dance
At the same time people were mistaking Clarence Hynes for an Avery, others were mistaking Clifford Avery, Craig’s older brother, for Clarence. In side by side photographs, the two men with their bushy mustaches looked eerily alike. So when Clifford and Craig finally take a DNA te ... Show More
29m 18s
Jun 2024
E4: The Truth
As the Avery family mourns a devastating loss, Clarence Hynes resists their multiple appeals. But the cost of turning away becomes greater and greater for Clarence. The two families hurtle towards an inevitable truth. Note: This episode references suicide, please take care when l ... Show More
28m 22s
Jun 2024
E5: A Close Call
If what happened with the Hynes and Averys’ feels like a one in a million chance — it wasn’t. A few months before Clarence and Craig were born at the Come By Chance hospital, a young mother named Muriel felt like the little baby boy she brought home from the hospital wasn’t hers. 
24m 15s
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2024
Why Netflix's Menendez brothers series is murder porn
Experts have called Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan’s new Netflix show, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story, murder porn. The series explores the real-life brutal murders of Kitty and Jose Menendez back in 1989 committed by their sons Lyle and Erik – who alleged their father s ... Show More
13m 37s
Mar 2023
Patrice Alègre • Episode 5 sur 5
Lorsque l’on croise un jeune homme au regard clair, lumineux, profond, il est difficile de croire que son sourire charmeur cache une cruauté rare, un esprit pervers comme il en existe peu, un sadique intelligent, calculateur, machiavélique. Mesdames, méfiez-vous des yeux bleus de ... Show More
11m 1s
Jan 2025
Au Pair & Husband’s Affair Leads To Double Homicide? The Christine Banfield & Joseph Ryan Case
In 2023, Brendan Banfield and his au pair, Juliana Peres Magalhães–whom he was having an affair with–planned and went through with the murder of Banfield's wife, Christine, and another man, Joe Ryan. And they had tried to make it look like a pre-arranged fetish sex meetup gone wr ... Show More
56m 30s
May 13
A Tangled Web - Part 2 (Kevin James & George Taylor)
The murder of a young father soon uncovers a tangled web of deceit. A second murder is discovered and just may be linked to the first. View source material and photos for this episode at: anatomyofmurder.com/a-tangled-web-part-2/Can’t get enough AoM? Find us on social media!Insta ... Show More
44m 12s
Mar 2023
Patrice Alègre • Episode 4 sur 5
Lorsque l’on croise un jeune homme au regard clair, lumineux, profond, il est difficile de croire que son sourire charmeur cache une cruauté rare, un esprit pervers comme il en existe peu, un sadique intelligent, calculateur, machiavélique. Mesdames, méfiez-vous des yeux bleus de ... Show More
13 m
Dec 2024
Bruce McArthur Part 2
Bruce McArthur is a grandfather who worked as a landscaper and a mall Santa in the off-season. For nearly eight years, McArthur lived a secret life as a serial killer, primarily targeting men in The Gay Village, an LGBTQ+-friendly area of Toronto.Join Mike and Gibby as they discu ... Show More
1h 8m
Mar 2023
Patrice Alègre • Episode 2 sur 5
Lorsque l’on croise un jeune homme au regard clair, lumineux, profond, il est difficile de croire que son sourire charmeur cache une cruauté rare, un esprit pervers comme il en existe peu, un sadique intelligent, calculateur, machiavélique. Mesdames, méfiez-vous des yeux bleus de ... Show More
12m 42s
Nov 2024
Judge Say's Diddy's Jane & John Doe Accusers Need To Be Named
Did Diddy’s alleged past just get even darker? In this episode, the layers of allegations against Sean "Diddy" Combs go deeper, with chilling claims stretching back nearly two decades, including accusations involving minors. Former prosecutor and attorney Eric Faddis breaks down ... Show More
23m 5s
Mar 2023
Patrice Alègre • Episode 1 sur 5
Lorsque l’on croise un jeune homme au regard clair, lumineux, profond, il est difficile de croire que son sourire charmeur cache une cruauté rare, un esprit pervers comme il en existe peu, un sadique intelligent, calculateur, machiavélique. Mesdames, méfiez-vous des yeux bleus de ... Show More
12m 18s
Mar 2023
Patrice Alègre • Episode 3 sur 5
Lorsque l’on croise un jeune homme au regard clair, lumineux, profond, il est difficile de croire que son sourire charmeur cache une cruauté rare, un esprit pervers comme il en existe peu, un sadique intelligent, calculateur, machiavélique. Mesdames, méfiez-vous des yeux bleus de ... Show More
12m 3s