logo
episode-header-image
Jun 2024
17m 55s

073: Demystifying Career Feedback: Insid...

Sarah Doody from Career Strategy Lab™
About this episode

Get ready to transform your approach to feedback! This episode delves into the art of giving and receiving critiques on career materials. 

Career Strategy Lab Coaches Erin Lindstrom, Becca Santilli, and Steph Knox share their extensive experience from reviewing thousands of resumes, portfolios, and LinkedIn profiles.

They discuss the importance of being specific when asking for feedback and how staying mindful of your goals can make the process more effective. 

Learn how different methods, like live sessions and prerecorded critiques, can help boost your confidence and refine your materials. 

Whether you're looking for a new job or aiming for a promotion, this episode will guide you to get the best feedback possible. 

Tune in to discover actionable tips that ensure you get the feedback you need to succeed.

Reflection Questions

1. What strategies do you typically use when asking for feedback on your career materials, and how can you apply Erin, Steph, and Becca's advice to improve your approach?

2. How do you handle receiving conflicting feedback from different sources, and what steps can you take to discern which feedback is most valuable to you as suggested in the podcast?

3. Erin mentioned the importance of building the skill set to improve any career material bullet point in the future. What specific skills or actions can you focus on to enhance this ability in your own career development?

4. Considering Becca's point about the importance of the compass statement in gaining clarity and confidence, how would you articulate your own compass statement, and in what ways might it serve as your North Star in your career journey?

Time Stamps 

00:00 Introduction and Special Guests

00:11 Understanding Feedback in Career Strategy Lab

00:42 Demystifying the Critique Process

01:30 Meet the CSL Coaches

03:17 The Critique Process Explained

04:50 Personal Critiquing Processes

06:07 Importance of Compass Statement

09:45 Live Calls and Community Support

11:36 Tips for Asking Feedback

16:12 Your Next Steps 



🎬 Watch our free UX Job Search Workshop and learn how to stand out in 2025

👉 Join Career Strategy Lab, a UX job search accelerator for UX and Product people.

👋 Say hi and follow our host, Sarah Doody, on LinkedIn, Instagram, and YouTube.

Up next
May 26
124: Why Sarah Doody's UX portfolio framework still works after 20 years
Applied to 50+ UX or Product jobs & still no interviews or offers? Get UX job search help.Welcome to the Career Strategy Podcast with Sarah Doody, a UX Designer & UX Researcher with 20 years of experience who founded the UX job search accelerator, Career Strategy Lab. She's been ... Show More
29m 4s
May 19
123: How a 25-Year UX veteran rewrote his career story & reclaimed his confidence
Applied to 50+ UX or Product jobs & still no interviews or offers? Get UX job search help.Welcome to the Career Strategy Podcast with Sarah Doody, a UX Designer & UX Researcher with 20 years of experience who founded the UX job search accelerator, Career Strategy Lab. She's been ... Show More
16m 35s
Mar 2025
112: How Emily tripled her UX freelance rate from $35 to $125 / hour (and got a full time job too)
Want to get hired in UX faster? Click here.Welcome to the Career Strategy Podcast with Sarah Doody, a UX Designer & UX Researcher who also founded the UX job search accelerator Career Strategy Lab. She's been doing UX career coaching since 2017.Follow Sarah on: LinkedIn | YouTube ... Show More
14m 43s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2023
How to Future Proof Your Career in 2024
Love Your Career Podcast? Let us know!How to Future Proof Your Career in 2024!  In a recent LinkedIn Livestream, I teamed up with LinkedIn Livestream expert, Gillian Whitney, to discuss how you can Future-Proof Your Career in 2024.   In this episode I share the recording of our ‘ ... Show More
1h 4m
Jan 2024
The Art of Giving Feedback
If you’re a leader, you know how critical feedback is to your team’s success and growth. But giving the kind of feedback that motivates people to improve is harder than it may seem. In this episode, Therese Huston, a cognitive scientist at Seattle University who specializes in gi ... Show More
33m 29s
Apr 2023
03. Two amazing practice methods our most resourceful clients created
In this episode, we talk about 2 unique ways to practice for cases that two case interview coaching clients created, and how you can add them to your practice. We also talk about being resourceful and how that can help you in your case prep and in your job as a consultant. After ... Show More
37m 24s
Mar 2023
S9E25: 4 Ideas to Fill Career Gaps In Your Resume
Send us a textStruggling to gain traction in your consulting job hunt due to career gaps on your resume? Listen in. Today, we're sharing 4 ideas to help you fill in those pesky resume gaps that are stopping your progress. Relevant Links Resume & cover letter edits: Learn Mor ... Show More
15m 16s
Apr 2022
How to Navigate Your Career
Love Your Career Podcast? Let us know!In today’s changing employment landscape it's a challenge to navigate your career effectively to ensure career growth and job satisfaction.  In this episode of Your Career Podcast, you will find the essential elements to get clear on wha ... Show More
30m 53s
Jun 2024
173: Now You Can Make Hard Career Decisions Seem Simple
Are you ready to make career decisions with clarity and confidence?   Listen now and learn how aligning your values and vision leads to better career decisions!   > Full Show Notes, Resources, & More   ============================   When you’re ready, here are three ways I can he ... Show More
15m 41s
Apr 2017
The Muse: Navigating Your Career with Alexandra Cavoulacos and Kathryn Minshew
Human Capital: It’s more valuable than any other investment you have and that’s why we often discuss career development and management on Better Off. If you’re one of the lucky ones like me, then you’re doing what you want to do, but it took me some time to get here… Many of you ... Show More
36m 46s
Aug 2023
12 Steps For Giving Feedback
Feedback often has a negative connotation, but today, Chris and I want to show you how it can be a valuable tool for growth and progress. We walk you through a 12-step approach to providing feedback and offer advice on how to deliver feedback to your teams and employees effective ... Show More
22m 5s
Jun 2023
Comment réussir son recrutement ? | #Leçon174
Vous êtes entrepreneur, indépendant ou en profession libérale et vous appréciez le format de ces leçons ? Je mets mon expérience à votre service dans un format plus approfondi ici : http://demian.education/. Hello les amis, j’espère que vous allez bien. Je vous accueille aujourd’ ... Show More
29m 2s
Oct 2022
#506: Becoming An Expert: How To Position Yourself As An Authority in Your Field
Grab your freebie for this episode here! You don’t have to go back to school or have a million followers on Instagram to be the go-to resource in your industry Positioning yourself as the go-to expert in your industry can be a game-changer for your business. Not only does it help ... Show More
36m 36s