logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2024
18m 11s

A Bipartisan Effort to Carve out Exempti...

WNYC STUDIOS AND THE NEW YORKER
About this episode

Texas has multiple abortion laws, with both criminal and civil penalties for providers. They contain language that may allow for exceptions to save the life or “major bodily function” of a pregnant patient, but many doctors have been reluctant to even try interpreting these laws; at least one pregnant woman has been denied cancer treatment. The reporter Stephania Taladrid tells David Remnick about how two lawmakers worked together in a rare bipartisan effort to clarify the limited medical circumstances in which abortion is allowed. “If lawmakers created specific exemptions,” Taladrid explains, “then doctors who got sued could show that the treatment that they had offered their patients was compliant with the language of the law.” Taladrid spoke with the state representatives Ann Johnson, a Democrat, and Bryan Hughes, a conservative Republican, about their unlikely collaboration. Johnson told her that she put together a list of thirteen conditions that might qualify for a special exemption, but only two of them—premature ruptures and ectopic pregnancy—were cited in the final bill. Still, the unusual bipartisan action is cause for hope among reproductive-rights advocates that some of the extreme climate around abortion bans may be lessening. 

Up next
Yesterday
After James Comey, Who’s Next on Trump’s Revenge Tour?
The New Yorker contributing writer Ruth Marcus joins Tyler Foggatt to discuss Donald Trump’s “revenge tour”—his effort to use the levers of government to settle personal and political scores. They talk about the indictment of the former F.B.I. director James Comey, why legal expe ... Show More
43m 27s
Oct 6
A Conservative Professor on How to Fix Campus Culture
Robert P. George is not a passive observer of the proverbial culture wars; he’s been a very active participant. As a Catholic legal scholar and philosopher at Princeton University, he was an influential opponent of Roe v. Wade and same-sex marriage, receiving a Presidential medal ... Show More
26m 2s
Oct 4
How Russell Vought Broke the U.S. Government
The Washington Roundtable discusses how this week’s government shutdown can be best understood by looking at the background and influence of Russell Vought, the director of the White House Office of Management and Budget. Vought is a Christian nationalist who served in the first ... Show More
36m 16s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2022
What’s It Like to Be a Red-State Abortion Doctor Post-Roe?
The Supreme Court’s decision to strike down the precedents set by Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which established the right to abortion in the U.S., has created a chaotic legal situation as conservative states rush to ban the procedure. On this week’s show, Vanessa ... Show More
29m 1s
Nov 2024
Abortion Was A Winning Issue – Just Not for Kamala Harris
After abortion access wins in 2022, Democrats made a bet that voters backing abortion on states’ ballot measures would also back Democratic candidates. WSJ’s Laura Kusisto explains why that bet turned out to be wrong. Further Listening: The Scramble Is on to Fill Trump’s Cabinet  ... Show More
19m 24s
Mar 2024
Inside a Hospital’s Abortion Committee
Sarah Osmundson knows how to talk about abortion. She’s learned over the course of her career as a maternal-fetal medicine doctor that some patients are comfortable with the option, and others would never consider it. Osmundson is a physician in Tennessee, a state with one of the ... Show More
24m 29s
Aug 2024
Trump Refuses To Commit To Vetoing A National Abortion Ban
Donald Trump said that he will not support a ballot referendum to expand abortion access in Florida just 24 hours after infuriating religious conservatives with an inartful attempt to sidestep questions about how he would vote in his home state. Vice President Kamala Harris, in a ... Show More
46m 56s
Aug 6
Are abortion numbers rising in the US?
In June 2022 the United States Supreme Court passed what became known as ‘the Dobbs decision’. In doing so they overturned the long standing constitutional right for women to access abortion in the US. Since then a number of states have banned abortion completely with many others ... Show More
8m 58s
Jun 2024
What Republicans Lost When They Won on Roe
For decades, the mainstream Republican position on abortion rights was clear: Overturn Roe v. Wade and send the issue back to the states.But since June 2022, when the Supreme Court’s conservative majority did exactly that, Republicans have faced a question that few seemed to cons ... Show More
48m 29s
Sep 2021
The False Choice of Pro-Life and Pro-Choice. A response to Erick Erickson
NotoriousSA is back, and this time he is talking about Texas, the pro-life movement, and Erick Erickson.  TheOdd1sout: The Truth About Making Cartoons Erick Erickson: You Can't Trust the Narrative on the Texas Abortion Law Dawn Stacey, Ph.D., LMHC: Why Do Women Have Abortions Dai ... Show More
58m 26s
Aug 2024
6 PM ET: Trump’s abortion comments, CA school food bill passes, Brazil blocks X & more
Former President Donald Trump says he’s voting “no” on a Florida amendment that would protect the right to have an abortion until a fetus is viable. California’s legislature became the first in the country to pass a bill banning several artificial dyes in foods served at public s ... Show More
6m 37s
Aug 2023
Jen Psaki's EGREGIOUS Lie About Democrats' Stance on Abortion Until Birth
During the first Republican primary debate, former press secretary Jen Psaki said "no one supports abortion up until birth;" yet, prominent members of her very own party have vocally supported abortion up until the moment of birth. Liz breaks down the lies behind one of the Left' ... Show More
12m 51s
Jun 2025
Carole Joffe and David Cohen on their book After Dobbs: How the Supreme Court Ended Roe but not Abortion
Immediately after the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization Supreme Court case that overturned Roe v. Wade,shock, sadness, and anger were predominant. But even still, abortion providers, abortion fund workers, and other advocates and leaders in the field provided, facilita ... Show More
45m 44s