logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2023
18m 10s

are mental disorders brain diseases ‘in ...

Mollie Adler
About this episode

In this thought-provoking episode, join me as we dive deep into the biopsychosocial model, critically examining the prevailing claims that label mental health conditions as brain diseases. In this preview of a premium epiosde, we’ll navigate the complex landscape of mental health by analyzing the powerful words of renowned psychiatrist Dr. Joanna Moncrieff. Dr. Moncrieff has been vocal in questioning the notion that mental disorders—such as schizophrenia—are conclusively brain-based. Through this exploration, we’ll delve into the science behind brain imaging, cognitive function, and the nuanced differences between brain diseases and mental disorders.


What We’ll Cover:


  • The Biopsychosocial Model vs. Brain Disease Theory: Understanding the model that integrates biological, psychological, and social factors to better explain mental health struggles.
  • Dr. Joanna Moncrieff’s Perspective: A deep dive into Moncrieff’s critique of the rhetoric tying mental conditions like schizophrenia to conclusive biological evidence.
  • What Brain Imaging Really Tells Us: The limits and potential misinterpretations of brain imaging studies in defining mental health conditions as brain diseases.
  • Brain Disease or Cognitive Disturbance? Differentiating between cognitive deterioration due to brain diseases and behavioral patterns observed in mental disorders.
  • Implications for Psychiatry and Mental Health Treatment: How rethinking these definitions might impact the future of mental health care, therapy, and individual autonomy.


Tune in to challenge mainstream beliefs, explore the interplay between the mind and body, and gain a richer understanding of mental health beyond conventional psychiatric boundaries. This episode invites you to engage in a nuanced and eye-opening discussion about what it truly means to view mental health through a biopsychosocial lens.


Craving more? Become a Premium Submarine. Join an exclusive community and unlock hundreds of hours of members-only content: full-length episodes, deep-dive series, guided meditations, and more—all for the cost of a couple of coffees a month. Start exploring at backfromtheborderline.com.


The information contained in this podcast episode is for educational and entertainment purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for treatment or consultation with a licensed mental health professional.


Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Up next
Yesterday
the holy grail and the lost wisdom of the west
<p>For centuries, the Holy Grail has been treated as a Christian relic or a medieval myth. But the Grail is <em>far</em> older than this, and its meaning was never meant to be lost. </p><br><p>In this episode, we will follow the lineage of the sacred cup from prehistoric carvings ... Show More
1h 15m
Nov 20
how we all became a little satanic
<p>The popular image of Satanism belongs to horror movies, pentagrams, and black candles, but the <em>real</em> influence sits in work culture and the chase for personal. A promotion. A streak of discipline that borders on obsession. A pressure to build a better version of yourse ... Show More
40m 20s
Nov 18
digital scapegoats and the ritual of outrage
<p>One single mistake online can set off a collective judgment that moves faster than thought itself. A name starts to trend and a crowd quickly forms around it. The event feels public, but it somehow reaches into private instinct. The pull to condemn and to belong. But most impo ... Show More
1h 10m
Recommended Episodes
Jan 2022
How To Reverse Brain Trauma And Disorders
<p>Approximately half of the people in the United States experience some mental health issue. "If your brain is not right, you're going to get nowhere," Dr. Phil says.</p> <p>New breakthroughs in neuroscience are helping to identify different brain types, helping to prevent and r ... Show More
56m 39s
May 2023
How to Harness Brain Energy for Mental Health with Dr. Chris Palmer
Dr. Chris Palmer is a psychiatrist with a wealth of personal experience and professional expertise in the field of mental health. Having faced mental health challenges himself, Dr. Palmer has a unique understanding and empathy for those who struggle with mental illness. His deter ... Show More
1h 21m
Jul 2022
341: Interpersonal Neurobiology And Understanding The Mind with Dr Daniel Siegel
<p>Welcome back to Therapy Chat! This week&#39;s episode is replay of a fascinating conversation with someone who needs no introduction. <a href="http://drdansiegel.com/" rel="nofollow">Dr. Dan Siegel</a> is this week&#39;s guest, and he explains the concept of interpersonal neur ... Show More
48m 34s
Jan 2024
Is There a Genetic Test to Diagnose Mental Illness?
Why do mental health professionals diagnose mental illness by medical observation and not by something more definitive like a blood test or a brain scan? It’s often pointed out that illnesses like cancer or diabetes have blood or urine tests, scans, and so forth. So why not menta ... Show More
31m 57s
Mar 2022
Sarah Fay on The Challenges of Mental Health Diagnoses
Sarah Fay is an author and activist.  Her writing appears in many publications, including The New York Times, The Atlantic, Time Magazine, The New Republic, Longreads, The Michigan Quarterly Review, The Rumpus, The Millions, McSweeney’s, The Believer, and The Paris Review, where ... Show More
1h 10m
May 2023
Can You Detect Psychopathy From Pupil Dilation?
Healthy//Toxic Healthy versus Toxic is a podcast where licensed mental health professionals explore what makes a relationship healthy or unhealthy. Our hosts aim to provide a scientifically informed perspective on what factors go into making healthy relationships, how to build se ... Show More
13m 22s
Jan 2023
The Brain-Gut Microbiome Axis and Its Impact on Mental Health
<p>Your gut health directly impacts your mental health. From nutrient absorption that impacts the physical building blocks of the brain, to inflammation which can lead cytokines to damage the brain, to your microbiome which impacts your physical and mental health, your gut health ... Show More
10m 16s
Nov 2022
From Borderline to Beautiful: Dissociation Demystified.
Borderline Personality Disorder is no longer considered a chronic illness. You can lead a great life with a sensitive, intense, hyperbolic... or any temperament for that matter with hard work, grit, endurance, tenacity, and the willingness to get uncomfortable. Check out this art ... Show More
26m 35s
Oct 2023
Revolutionizing Brain Health and Emotional Well-Being
<p>Dr. Phil takes a deep dive into the heart of mental health, uncovering transformative insights and strategies for overcoming brain health issues and uplifting our emotional well-being. He offers a glimpse into a future where mental health treatments are not only accurate and e ... Show More
56m 28s
Jun 2023
The Surprising Link Between Metabolism & Mental Illness | Dr. Chris Palmer
<p>Discover the compelling link between mental health and metabolic dysfunction with Harvard psychiatrist, Dr. Chris Palmer and author of the book <a href="https://amzn.to/3OFbyZr" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank"><em>Brain Energy: A Revolutionary Breakthrough in Underst ... Show More
1h 9m