logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2023
46m 21s

Mysteriously Vanished - The McStay Famil...

Crime Salad
About this episode

Join Ashley and Ricky as they examine the puzzling case of the McStay family, who mysteriously vanished from their California home in 2010. Years later, when investigators discovered the truth, shocking revelations and unexpected twists emerged, shocking a community and forever changing the lives of those involved.


This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/CRIMESALAD and get on your way to being your best self.


Up next
Jul 7
Weird History (Bonus): The Town That Danced Itself to Death
In the summer of 1518, the people of Strasbourg started dancing… and just didn’t stop. No, seriously—they danced for days, some even to their deaths. Was it a curse? A case of mass hysteria? Or just some really bad moldy bread? In this fun bonus episode, Ashley and Ricky are taki ... Show More
12m 16s
Jun 28
Disappeared: Amber Dubois and Chelsea King
Content Warning: This episode contains detailed discussion of child abduction, sexual violence, and murder. Listener discretion is advised. In February 2009, 14-year-old Amber Dubois disappeared while walking to school in Escondido, California. Her family searched tirelessly—with ... Show More
24m 56s
Jun 22
Murder Without Justice: Jason Corbett
When Irish father Jason Corbett relocated to North Carolina with his two children, it was meant to be a fresh chapter after the tragic loss of his first wife, Mags. He eventually married Molly Martens, an American woman hired to help care for his young children. But nearly a deca ... Show More
38m 59s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2022
Skeletons in the Closet
When 18 year-old Brittany Loritts is murdered in her North Carolina home, investigators are at a loss as to who would commit such a crime. The case gets hot when investigators find that this family home is built on buried secrets.Season 1, Episode 13 originally aired on ID on Jul ... Show More
43m 34s
Sep 2023
The Cold Case Murder Of A Mother And Daughter
On September 2nd, 1994, a horrific crime sent shockwaves through the hardworking community of Williamsport, PA. 23-year-old Gail Matthews was found holding her 5-year-old daughter, Tamara Berkheiser, the pair bloodied, strangled, and stabbed. Gail was well-liked by everyone in he ... Show More
59m 2s
Feb 2022
Sex Lies & Murder: Soccer Mom's Secret
The community of Grand Junction, Colorado is shocked and devastated to learn that soccer mom, Paige Birgfeld, has been living a double-life as an escort when she goes missing in 2008. Investigators begin looking for clues that may lead them to Paige’s whereabouts and in the proce ... Show More
47m 10s
Jan 2021
All American Family Murder
On February 4, 2010 the McStay family disappeared without a trace from their home in Fallbrook, California. Over the years, the case made international headlines and everyone seemed to have a theory about what happened to the family of four: Did they walk over the border to Mexic ... Show More
31m 48s
Oct 2023
Thicker Than Blood
Kenneth and Kari Allen appeared to be loving siblings from an all-American family in Indianapolis. But a contentious divorce tore the siblings apart and sent them down two different paths. Hardened by crime and isolation, and crippled with a gambling addiction, Kenneth returns ho ... Show More
40 m
Jan 2022
Murderer in the Midst
When a family of four is terrorized in their suburban home, only three survive. Investigators wonder if this is a robbery gone wrong or something more sinister. As the case unfolds, police are shocked to learn that this is a betrayal of the worst kind.Season 1, Episode 10 origina ... Show More
43m 37s
Mar 2023
Wrong Way Home
When 12-year-old Michelle Winter goes missing without a trace, her family doesn't have a clue as to who could have whisked this pre-teen away. Cops have many leads, but it isn't until evidence is linked to the killer that they get their big break.Season 3, Episode 4 originally ai ... Show More
40m 37s