logo
episode-header-image
Jul 2022
59m 8s

How Many Plotholes To Stars Hollow?

Tara Llewellyn & Haley McIntosh
About this episode

This week, Tara and Haley are starting part one of their dive into the many plotholes and inconsistencies on Gilmore girls. Relationships just end with no phone call or explanation? Absent fathers become even more absent if possible? How did Luke and Lorelai never know each other prior to meeting? So many to mention it couldn't be contained to just one episode. Grab a coffee and get comfortable because the girls have more to say. 

Up next
Jul 8
Gilmore to Consider #49: Rory Gilmore takes Lorelai’s Partings Plot
Where you call, we will answer! This week, we’re revisiting our June 3rd episode and implementing some of your ideas! What if Luke and Lorelai get married but Rory took Lorelai’s plotline in “Partings”?? Or if Jess was revealed to be a foil to Christopher all along? Grab a cup of ... Show More
32m 9s
Jul 1
Take the Gilmore Girls out of Stars Hollow
A roadtrip to Harvard? A cross-country bus ride to California? Playing hooky in New York City to visit the boy who isn’t your boyfriend?! It’s officially Gilmore Girls Summer and nothing says “summer” quite like a lil vacation. This week, we’re leaving Stars Hollow and breaking d ... Show More
1h 7m
Jun 26
Gilmore to Say Revisited: Tara as the Stars Hollow Bachelorette
Did we manifest Hannah Brown coming on the podcast back in 2022??? One of our listeners, Hannah, called in three years ago and asked Tara to come up with a season of the Bachelorette using Rory's men on Gilmore Girls and it was VERY silly. In the following GTC, Haley challenges T ... Show More
35m 32s
Recommended Episodes
Mar 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Bunheads: Too Soon to Say Goodbye
It’s the second to last episode of the series, and we are sad to see it go!    We loved watching everyone together in one spot, but why did this episode hit too close to home for Amy and Danielle?   Plus, we’ll tell you which two characters are responsible for giving us the Gilmo ... Show More
23m 42s
Nov 2016
Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life S:1 | Summer; Fall E:3 & E:4 | AfterBuzz TV AfterShow
AFTERBUZZ TV -- Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life edition, is a weekly "after show" for fans of Netflix's Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life. In this episode hosts Marisa Serafini, Zach Wilson, and Hayley O'Connor discuss season 1 episodes 3 & 4. ABOUT GILMORE GIRLS: Set in a stor ... Show More
1h 30m
Nov 2024
Where You Lead, I Will Follow (Season 1 E1 “Pilot”)
It’s Fall, and that means the rewatch of Gilmore Girls begins NOW!  Sean Gunn joins us and shares a hilarious story of why he’s watched the only episode he isn’t in several times.  Hello Unionville! We get to meet the small town that inspired our beloved Stars Hollow.   Is the pi ... Show More
1h 9m
Nov 2016
Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life S:1 | Winter; Spring E:1 & E:2 | AfterBuzz TV AfterShow
AFTERBUZZ TV -- Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life edition, is a weekly "after show" for fans of Netflix's Gilmore Girls: A Year In The Life. In this episode hosts Marisa Serafini, Zach Wilson, and Hayley O'Connor discuss season 1 episodes 1 & 2.. ABOUT GILMORE GIRLS: Set in a sto ... Show More
1h 28m
Dec 2024
Gilmore Girls Gazette Bunheads: It’s Almost Perfect
This episode brought us the drama, and we are here for it!  Hello, Digger! Another Gilmore Girls actor cameo by Chris Eigeman.   Plus, Danielle gives her theory on what’s not working in the series. Tell us if you agree!See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
13m 54s
Aug 2024
We're not stopping for a milkshake (S7 E19 “It’s just like riding a bike”)
Thank goodness Luke and Lorelai are spending time together! Although Scott has a critique. (About his own performance.)   We have a disagreement over Paris and those envelopes.     The dollhouse though, ohhh nooo.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
49m 49s
Apr 2023
It’s Lorelai (S5 E2 "A Messenger, Nothing More”)
Luke and Lorela :  Cute phone conversations and an "about to kiss" moment interrupted by a marching band! Lane:  She loves Zach but do we??? Kirk:  Where was Kirk?? Lindsay and Dean:  Yikes! Lindsay and her mom vs Rory and Lorelai:  Double YIKES!   Would you have been "a messenge ... Show More
1h 7m
Feb 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Gossip Girl Here
We’re your one and only source of into the headline making Gilmore Girls elite. A Gilmore guy is sharing the screen with a Gossip Girl, on a certain hit tv show. We’ll tell you which one. Spotted, a Stars Hollow staple hanging out with a stand up comedian from Maisel, what univer ... Show More
26m 56s
Apr 24
TGI – Episode 610 “And In Case I Don’t See Ya”
In a rare move by Boy Meets World writers, they pulled a storyline straight from the big screen for this Season 6 romp, putting Eric right in the middle of “The Truman Show.”   Will can perfectly recall a line from an obscure sitcom from the ‘70s, but has no memory of filming thi ... Show More
1h 5m
Feb 2025
TGI – Episode 601 “His Answer”
The wait is over! The hosts are entering the halls of Pennbrook, leaving behind the naive salad days of John Adams High, and the podcast is officially in its Season 6 era. With a wedding proposal looming from a cliffhanger, and the addition of a new cast member, we have a lot of ... Show More
1h 31m