logo
episode-header-image
Nov 17
1h 3m

Petty or Crime?

Tara Llewellyn & Haley McIntosh

About this episode

It’s the 25th anniversary of Season 2’s “The Ins and Outs of Inns”, where Jess Mariano staged the phony murder outside of Doose’s Market. So in honor of our favorite small-town mischief maker, we’re talking about petty crimes on the show. Cornstarch, Deviled Eggs, Bell-Breaking, Robe Theft?! Maybe some honorable mentions of crimes against our feelings? Grab a cup of coffee and get comfortable because Tara and Haley have more to say!

I smell snow much more to say in Orlando! Get tickets to STARS HOLLOWDAY SOCIAL HOUR, trivia, and details on the Books, Brews, and Blooms holiday market here!

Our Small-town Girl drop is available now at www.gilmoretosay.com <3 Shop(pe) now!!

Our podcast, A Marvelous Time: A Marvelous Maisel Recap Podcast, is underway exclusively on Patreon. Be sure to join the Super Cool Party People tier or the Vicious Trollops tier to receive weekly episodes!

But if you’re still rewatching our favorite series, now you can watch with us! Join us for The Rewatch Club by visiting our Patreon to rewatch the entire series with us OR you can also stream our entire recap catalog of Gilmore Revisited only on Patreon <3

Want to be on our next GTC? Call in with your thoughts at 860-578-4653!!!!

Now you can watch the girlies every week by subscribing to us on YouTube!

Where you lead I will follow...us @gilmoretosaypodcast



Our Sponsors:
* Check out Cure Hydration and use my code GTS for 20% off: https://www.curehydration.com
* Check out Quince and use my code GTS for a great deal: https://www.quince.com
* Check out Timeline and use my code Timeline.com/GTS for a $22 trial! https://www.timeline.com/gts


Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Up next

Nov 19
Gilmore To Read: Ellen O'Clover Loves Jess, If Not Tristin
Gilmore Girls lovers, on Wednesdays, we talk books!!!USA Today bestseller Ellen O'Clover is here for Jess Marinovember to represent for the Jess girlies... and maybe the Tristin girlies. Her latest novel, IF NOT YOU is in keeping with our Oct/Nov book club rivals to lovers vibes ... 
1h 44m
Nov 12
Your Choice, My Choice, Ace
It’s Part 2 of our scene analysis week! How does Rory and Jess’s conversation that we analyzed on Tuesday impact the deeper conversation with Logan about Rory’s dropping out of Yale? Did the writers use Logan’s ire to represent the growth in Jess to walk away? And Haley has even ... 
1h 1m

Recommended Episodes

Mar 2025
Saying "I Love You", Emoji Wars and the Brits fallout #162
How do you know you’re in love? And just as importantly – How do you say those three words for the first time? Charleen and Ellie – Notorious lover girls, look at their past history of saying ‘I love you’, the nerves, the regrets and fear of not hearing it said back!They discuss ... 
58m 31s
Jul 2021
54: Awkward Romance & Saying "I Love You" First
This week we're talking about saying I Love You to your partner, when to say it, and The Giving Tree (aka The Taking Boy). FOLLOW US! @arielmfulmer @becksmecks2 @magsbustamante @rcole Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices 
46m 55s
Feb 2023
What’s Not to Love? • EP413
<p>While OTH certainly had its episodes where multiple girls were in love with the same guy, we don’t think there’s been a case where three girls have fallen in love with one episode. That is…until now. Hilarie, Joy and Sophia go head over heels for this rewatch. </p> <p>Find out ... 
56m 12s
Mar 2025
IAAI Town Meeting: Break Ups and Make Ups (Season 1 E17 “The Break Up Part 2")
A lot is happening at 6am! Suzanne and Tara wonder about the timing of Rory’s early morning. Is this episode making us like Max for Lorelai? Plus, it wasn’t just us wondering about the ice cream Rory eats to wallow... find out if a big tub of Jerry’s really does exist! Follow @ia ... 
19m 33s
Jun 2022
Everything I Know About Love S1 E3: I Love You
Olga Koch and Sophie Duker are rewinding to 2012 with Maggie, Birdy, Amara and Nell, and you’re invited. This week they’re remembering the most mortifying things they were called out for in their early twenties, and the people they said I love you to despite not meaning it. Plus, ... 
38m 9s
Apr 2025
Gilmore Girls Gazette: Call Her Lorelai
<p>Take a seat because Lauren Graham spilled some MAJOR tea with Alex Cooper on Call Her Daddy.&nbsp;</p> <p>Work place romance anyone? Lauren shared she dated some of Lorelai&rsquo;s on screen boyfriends&hellip; Who are they??</p> <p>Plus, we debunk one of Lauren&rsquo;s theorie ... 
29m 47s
Oct 2022
Would have been pathetic if you hadn’t (S4 E6 "An Affair to Remember”)
<p>Happy Halloween!!<br>Can we offer you a broccoli tart??!!</p> <p>Go Kirk!  We meet the lovely Lulu and our hearts are full.</p> <p>We discuss the heartwarming moments between Luke and Kirk and the heartbreaking scene Emily and Lorelai share. </p> <p>Do we like Digger?  Do we l ... 
53m 48s
Feb 2024
We’ve Been Missing Each Other Lately (S6 E21 “Driving Miss Gilmore”)
<p>Luke and Lorelai….are things really as bad as Lorelai seems to think they are?</p> <p>If you were in a similar situation, would you have postponed the June 3rd wedding?</p> <p>Are you with Lorelai?  Or is there another side to the story?</p> <p>And, the house… what a wedding g ... 
1h 4m
Jun 2023
girl talk: advice on ur romantic dilemmas
<p>the girlies are here to give you their thoughts on YOUR romantic dilemmas, situationships and questions. this week i&#39;m joined by my two amazing house mates and besties ale and vaish, and we give you our honest (and sometimes opposing) thoughts...</p> <p>from unrequited lov ... 
50m 48s