logo
episode-header-image
Sep 2023
27 m

The Secret to Giving Great Feedback

Harvard Business Review
About this episode

Some managers give meaningless positive feedback. Others are unreasonably critical. But Kim Scott, cofounder of the executive coaching firm Radical Candor, says good leaders can give honest feedback in the moment—as long as it’s rooted in a strong relationship.

“You want to show that you care personally,” she tells IdeaCast host Curt Nickisch. “Your job as a leader is to paint a picture of what success looks like. You want to show what the possibilities are.”

In this episode, Scott explains the steps that managers can take to challenge their employees more directly, while also communicating empathy. She also offers advice for how to solicit useful feedback on your own work.

Key episode topics include: leadership, business communication, giving feedback, managing people, communication, difficult conversations, developing employees, empathy.

HBR On Leadership curates the best case studies and conversations with the world’s top business and management experts, to help you unlock the best in those around you. New episodes every week.

· Listen to the original HBR IdeaCast episode: Defining Radical Candor – and How to Do It (Feb 2020)

· Find more episodes of HBR IdeaCast

· Discover 100 years of Harvard Business Review articles, case studies, podcasts, and more at HBR.org

Up next
Yesterday
How to Succeed in Your Career When Change Is a Constant
Disruption and transformation are the new normal in nearly every industry. So how do you stay ahead of the curve? Over the past four decades, Bonnie Hammer successfully adapted to massive changes in the media industry, rising from production assistant to leadership roles in broad ... Show More
29m 28s
Jul 2
The Right Way to Step Down as CEO
When news breaks of a CEO succession, much of the attention is given to the new leader and how they will change the company. But new research shows that the leave-taking process of the outgoing chief executive is often mishandled, with negative impacts on succession and the organ ... Show More
28m 43s
Jun 25
Why Profits Follow Purpose
This month, we're highlighting some of the best conversations from the 2025 HBR Leadership Summit held in April. In today’s episode, Anish Shah, CEO of Mahindra Group, one of India's largest and most prominent conglomerates, discusses the importance of purpose in driving profit. ... Show More
30m 9s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2021
159: Experience Managerial Greatness with Steph Richter
I’m in the process of writing my second book on what it means to be a modern manager. The process of writing this book included interviewing dozens of people about their great manager in search of themes, practices and habits from the best managers. Instead of talking to the mana ... Show More
33m 53s
Oct 2022
Radical Candor by Kim Scott | Book Summary and Review | Free Audiobook
Show notes / PDF & Infographic / Free Audiobook / Radical Candor teaches a direct management approach for leaders in the workplace. READ 1 MILLION BOOKS IN MINUTES. For free. Get the PDF, infographic, full ad-free audiobook, and animated version of this summary of Radical Candor ... Show More
18m 55s
Feb 2020
Defining Radical Candor – and How to Do It
Kim Scott, a cofounder of the executive coaching firm Radical Candor, says that too many managers give meaningless positive feedback, while many others are highly critical without showing any understanding. Scott, who previously worked at Google and has consulted for Twitter and ... Show More
25m 25s
Jul 2023
113: Stop Being Nice and Start Leading Kind with Karyn Ross | Award-Winning Author and Leadership Expert
What’s the difference between niceness and kindness? What is the solution to our current leadership crisis? How can you neutralize negative self-talk?   Listen now for these answers and more!   ============================   When you’re ready, here are three ways I can help you b ... Show More
55m 49s
Aug 2022
THE WIRE: Answering the call of leadership
When taking up the call for a leadership role, Janine Rule believes that “you can sink or swim, but you’ve got to take your shot”. In this exciting episode, the recently named director of Stockdale & Leggo Ferntree Gully tells the interesting story of how an out-of-the-blue phone ... Show More
34m 28s
Dec 2023
#184 Best of 2023: Conversations of the Year
The Knowledge Project closes 2023 with a look back at some of the best conversations of the year. Featuring interviews from nine of the most downloaded and acclaimed episodes of 2023, this collection of conversations offers a variety of insights into the power of intention, how t ... Show More
1h 36m
Jul 2023
The Key to Great Strategies? Timing.
What role does timing play in strategic thinking — for an organization's growth, but also for you and your career? New York Times best-selling author Daniel Pink says it can play a big part in how successful your strategy will be. “I think people underestimate timing,” he tells D ... Show More
45m 51s
Feb 2023
#160 TKP Insights: Leadership
In the third installment in a series of episodes, The Knowledge Project curates essential segments from five guests revolving around one theme: leadership. This episode helps put a unique definition on leadership and examines whether or not good leaders are context-dependent, the ... Show More
1h 1m
May 2024
Healing the World of Work
Welcome to another insightful episode of "Accelerate Your Business Growth," where we explore crucial aspects of workplace dynamics and personal well-being that directly impact business success. Today, host Diane Helbig is joined by Candice Elliott. In this episode, we dive deep i ... Show More
33m 40s
Jun 2024
686: How to Benefit from a Chief of Staff, with Laurie Arron
Laure Arron: Who Has Your Back? Laurie Arron is the founder of Arron Coaching, LLC and trusted adviser and executive coach to C-suite executives and Chiefs of Staff. She spent 30+ years climbing the corporate ladder at a Fortune 10 company in sales leadership, strategic planning, ... Show More
39m 44s