logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2022
27m 16s

EPISODE 2: Not Your “Typical” Murder Sui...

WNYC
About this episode

The Sheridans’ eldest son Mark is consumed with getting to the bottom of what happened to his parents. As the lawyer for Governor Chris Christie’s election campaign, Mark is in a unique position to uncover answers. Instead, he’s met with roadblock after roadblock. The questions really pile up when he learns that detectives haven’t even interviewed several key witnesses or completed a thorough investigation of the crime scene. Not only that, a key piece of evidence is missing.

New voices interviewed in episode:

    Barry Jansen, retired forensic technician for the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office
    Tom Draper, Sheridans’ neighbor
    Michael Baden, medical examiner hired by the Sheridan brothers
Up next
May 2022
EPISODE 3: A Bloody Fingerprint, A Bent Fire Poker, and Mystery DNA
The knife used to kill John Sheridan is just the first of many clues casting doubt on law enforcement’s conclusion of murder suicide. A newspaper crime reporter, a veteran homicide detective out of Philly, and a whistleblower point to significant pieces of evidence that have been ... Show More
32m 45s
May 2022
EPISODE 4: The Dirt on the Garden State
After it becomes clear the Somerset county prosecutor’s office couldn’t have done a worse job (unless their goal was to destroy the crime scene), some 200 prominent citizens send a letter to the state attorney general asking for his office to intervene in the investigation. Despi ... Show More
24m 4s
May 2022
EPISODE 5: New Jersey’s Other Boss
John Sheridan’s decision to go work at Cooper University Hospital came at a curious time. It was just months after news about the Palmyra tapes came out. The tapes caught George Norcross bullying and offering a favor to a small town official; they are a rare instance where eviden ... Show More
28m 53s
Recommended Episodes
Feb 2020
How is a 20 -year-old-woman, covered in blood with the word 'boy' carved in her arm, connected to a dead body sprawling out of a car? What happened to Ezra McCandless?
Ezra McCandless stumbles to the door of a home covered in blood, asking for help after reportedly being assaulted. But as the police investigation continues, the facts don't add up. What's the connection to the dead body of her boyfriend found in his car? What happened to Ezra Mc ... Show More
42m 56s
Apr 2021
Serial Killer starts with murder of wife, now suspected in 16 deaths
Sean Lannon says he murdered 16 people, including his ex-wife and a former mentor who allegedly sexually abused him as a child. Lannon allegedly enticed four of the victims to a residence in New Mexico before killing and dismembering two of them. Authorities have tied Lannon to t ... Show More
43m 19s
May 2024
Episode 6 - The Hitman
After going public about the reopening of the Billy Halpern murder investigation, Detective Danny Smith receives a mysterious call from someone who claims to have insider knowledge about Billy's murder and other related homicides. This caller unveils the dark underbelly of the So ... Show More
38m 15s
Feb 2023
Episode 240: Gilbert King on the shocking murder of Michelle Scholfield and the new evidence which puts a convicted murderer at the scene of the crime
When Gilbert King was asked by a Judge to look into a case of wrongful conviction he was shocked by the request and intrigued by the story.Michelle Scholfield was murdered in 1987, and her husband Leo, who protests his innocence, has remained behind bars for the crime ever since. ... Show More
39m 44s
Jun 2024
Episode 10 - No Pain, No Gain.
The reinvestigation into the 1986 murder of Billy Halpern has taken two years, leading both Detective Danny Smith and an investigative journalist Scott Weinberger down a path filled with new witnesses, the discovery of new evidence, and a pool of original suspects to be charged o ... Show More
38m 4s
Dec 2022
Episode 216: The amateur super sleuths solving real-life crimes
WHO says you can’t solve crime in your spare time? Elderly armchair detectives with a penchant for puzzles are the inspiration for Richard Osman’s chart-topping 'Thursday Murder Club' novellas, but far from his pages of perfect prose there are groups of amateur sleuths who invest ... Show More
50m 38s
Apr 2023
Episode 273: Gerry 'The Monk' Hutch walks free after Regency murder trial
GERRY ‘The Monk’ Hutch walked free from court an innocent man after being found not guilty of the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel.After a dramatic end to proceedings and a sensational judgement that branded State witness Jonathan Dowdall a callous, base and violent cri ... Show More
48m 43s
Feb 2023
ALEX MURDAUGH TAKES THE STAND IN 'HAIL MARY'
Alex Murdaugh took the stand today in his own defense. The accused killer stated emphatically that he did not shoot his wife and son. Murdaugh did admit, however, that he lied to police. He said his opioid addiction made him paranoid of police.  The disgraced attorney repeatedly ... Show More
1 h