logo
episode-header-image
May 2022
32m 58s

EPISODE 3: A Bloody Fingerprint, A Bent ...

WNYC, Nancy Solomon
About this episode
The knife used to kill John Sheridan is just the first of many clues casting doubt on law enforcement’s conclusion of murder suicide. A newspaper crime reporter, a veteran homicide detective out of Philly, and a whistleblower point to significant pieces of evidence that have been disregarded—even thrown into a dumpster. Although Mark has the state attorney g ... Show More
Up next
May 2022
EPISODE 4: The Dirt on the Garden State
After it becomes clear the Somerset county prosecutor’s office couldn’t have done a worse job (unless their goal was to destroy the crime scene), some 200 prominent citizens send a letter to the state attorney general asking for his office to intervene in the investigation. Despi ... Show More
24m 16s
May 2022
EPISODE 5: New Jersey’s Other Boss
John Sheridan’s decision to go work at Cooper University Hospital came at a curious time. It was just months after news about the Palmyra tapes came out. The tapes caught George Norcross bullying and offering a favor to a small town official; they are a rare instance where eviden ... Show More
29m 6s
May 2022
EPISODE 6: On the (Camden) Waterfront
A couple months after his parents’ deaths, Mark Sheridan comes across a paper trail: extensive email exchanges, dated memos, and handwritten notes detailing a real estate deal on the Camden waterfront. His father, John Sheridan, wrote himself a note on an envelope: “I have a duty ... Show More
32m 17s
Recommended Episodes
Aug 2024
6 | The Stranger
The South Australian Director of Public Prosecutions examines the evidence and reveals a bombshell finding, while conflicting witness accounts continue to cause confusion. Is it possible Anthea was killed by a random stranger? Detectives finally confront Jeff Hall in a tense inte ... Show More
35m 37s
Jun 2024
Episode 7 - The Ghost
The relentless pursuit of Billy Halpern’s killer intensifies. Detective Danny Smith uncovers new intel from a surprising witness, while investigative journalist Scott Weinberger reveals crucial updates on the DNA testing. A shocking new piece of evidence, potentially holding fres ... Show More
38m 15s
Mar 2024
Episode 4: “The Cave”
The investigation by the Benton County Sheriff’s Office heats up in Dana Stidham’s gruesome murder, zeroing in on one particular suspect.  Phelps digs deeper, speaking to the suspect and wonders if law enforcement has been chasing the wrong man. Just over the Missouri border, not ... Show More
38 m
Mar 2023
The Reckoning
Investigators working Tammy’s case take a big risk in an effort to match her killer’s DNA. Phelps and former Master Sergeant Marty McCarthy have a heated conversation about the issues with his prime suspect, as a former detective comes forward with a troubling new claim. See omny ... Show More
39m 20s
May 2024
Episode 3 - Danger Road
Detective Smith meticulously examines the forensic evidence from Billy Halpern's murder, uncovering crucial details. Meanwhile, Scott discusses the case with the prosecutor of a previous multiple-murder incident on Danger Road, exploring potential links to their current investiga ... Show More
54m 37s
Apr 2024
Episode 7: “Killer Confrontation”
With investigative pressure mounting on the Benton County Sheriff’s Office’s suspect in Dana Stidham’s murder, Phelps uncovers a disturbing phone call made to a local woman in charge of Dana’s tip-line. Meanwhile, Phelps continues to make connections to his new suspect. Phelps un ... Show More
51m 24s
Dec 2021
Episode 9: Fast Hands
<p>Detectives face tough questions from John Peros&rsquo;s legal team at a committal hearing prior to his murder trial. William Daniel and Levii Blackman are witnesses &ndash; and Levii denies William told him, 'I did it'.</p> <p>Frustrated detectives sought answers for the lack ... Show More
1h 5m
Feb 2024
Episode 2: “The Evidence of Things Not Seen”
As the search for Dana Stidham continues, her sudden disappearance baffles family, friends, and police, as everyone grows increasingly alarmed that Dana has met with foul play. Then, a break in the case comes as Paper Ghosts executive producer, host and investigative journalist M ... Show More
47m 51s
Aug 2024
5 | Bloodstains and Alibis
Police from Anthea's home city conduct their own investigation into the Brunei murder. They examine how Jeff Hall got blood-like stains on his shirt, the timeline, and his alibis are revisited, casting doubt on previous accounts. A crucial witness sighting of Anthea is scrutinise ... Show More
37m 21s