logo
episode-header-image
Mar 2022
50m 18s

The Clinical Reasoning Series - Why shou...

Oliver Thomson
About this episode

Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast. 

We continue the clinical reasoning series, and I hope you enjoyed the first two episodes with Roger Kerry and Mark Jones where we covered how we can think about our practice, evidence and our patients.

However, given that the series is exploring clinicians’ reasoning around people with disease, it would seem prudent to consider what disease is both as a concept and phenomena but also the ethical and moral issues tied to and emanating from it and which motivate us to begin to reason about it.

As such, I’m speaking again to Prof. Bjørn Hofmann. I spoke with Bjørn in November last year – on Episode 55: about Dediagnosing- with his co-author Dr Marianne Lea.

Today we speak about his work on bioethics and talk around and about a recent paper of his titled 'Acknowledging and addressing the many ethical aspects of disease'. This is a two-part episode where the second part of the conversation focuses on his work on overdiagnosis and follows nicely from this episode.

Bjørn is a scholar in philosophy of medicine and bioethics with a special interest in the relationship between epistemology and ethics.

He is affiliated with the Department of Health Science at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) and the Centre for Medical Ethics at the University of Oslo. Bjørn's  main fields of interests include the basic concepts for health care including disease, causality, (over)diagnosis, medicalization and severity.


In this episode we speak about:

  • What we mean when we say ‘disease’?
  • Disease as both a concept and phenomena and how the concept of disease provides us with knowledge and guides our actions.
  • Disease from a biological perspective, the experience of disease which we term called illness, and the societal perspective we call sickness.
  • How these perspectives interact and how they might at times be in conflict with each other.
  • We consider disease an an experienced phenomenon with a scientific description and a moral imperative
  • We discuss the the moral functions, and why are they of great importance to patients and us as health professionals?
  • And finally we touch on how the science and the ethics of disease relate.

Support the podcast and contribute via Patreon here

If you liked the podcast, you'll love The Words Matter online course and mentoring to develop your clinical expertise  - ideal for all MSK therapists.

Follow Words Matter on:

Instagram @Wordsmatter_education @TheWordsMatterPodcast

Twitter @WordsClinical

Facebook Words Matter - Improving Clinical Communication

★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

Up next
Nov 2022
Ask Me Anything #6
Welcome to another episode of The Words Matters Podcast. Many of you may be familiar with a recent paper I was proud to co-author titled: Avoiding nocebo and other undesirable effects in chiropractic, osteopathy and physiotherapy: An invitation to reflect – Journal of MSK Science ... Show More
40m 13s
Oct 2022
The Outsiders - Clinicians divorced from their profession with Eliud Sierra
Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast.Apologies for the slight delay in the episode, work and life events continue to get in the way of my passion for producing these conversations.So it’s time for another Outsider episode (see prior Outsider episodes here, here, ... Show More
59m 57s
Sep 2022
Sociology for practice - the 'ology' you’ve been looking for with Dr Rebecca Olson
Welcome to another episode of The Words Matter Podcast.I hope you’ve enjoyed the last couple of episodes exploring pseudoscientific claims and how to think about, and respond to them (here and here). And to give us all a break from the frustration, today I’m speaking with Dr Rebe ... Show More
57m 59s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2020
Inside JABA #4, Session 123: Telehealth and Public Health Special Series
In the fourth edition of the Inside JABA Series, I am joined by Drs. Dorothea Lerman, Linda LeBlanc, and Matt Normand to discuss the forthcoming JABA Special Series on Telehealth and Public Health. Linda and Matt are no strangers to this podcast, but this is Dorothy Lerman's firs ... Show More
1h 2m
Nov 2023
Solutions and Key Research to Advance High-Quality Cancer Care
Drs. Cardinale Smith and Raymond Osarogiagbon discuss key research featured at the 2023 ASCO Quality Care Symposium, including the role of AI in quality measurement and solution-focused approaches addressing care delivery, financial toxicity, and clinician well-being. TRANSCRIPT ... Show More
17m 41s
May 2024
Everything You Need to Know About Therapy
In this mega-episode, clinical psychologist Dr. Rick Hanson and Forrest Hanson explore everything you need to know about therapy. They share how you can get more from therapy, finding the approach that’s right for you, and some perspectives on why therapy is so expensive. They th ... Show More
1h 35m
Mar 2024
Case Study: Pathological Vulnerable Narcissism
Cluster BThis show aims to educate the audience from a scientifically informed perspective about the major cluster B personality disorders: narcissism, histrionic, borderline, and antisocial. References: American Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual ... Show More
22m 7s
Aug 2023
the crisis of contemporary psychiatry with dr. bruce levine
Has psychiatry lost its way? Increasingly, voices within and beyond the profession argue that Western mental health institutions may be perpetuating psychological suffering rather than alleviating it. In this episode, I sit down with Dr. Bruce E. Levine, a clinical psychologist a ... Show More
2h 8m
Oct 2023
Case Study: BPD and Excitement Seeking
Cluster BThis show aims to educate the audience from a scientifically informed perspective about the major cluster B personality disorders: narcissism, histrionic, borderline, and antisocial. ReferencesArthur, A. R. (2000). Psychodynamic counseling for the borderline personality ... Show More
22m 15s
Jan 2024
Healing Cycles of Trauma with Dr. Mariel Buqué
Dr. Mariel Buqué joins the podcast to help us learn how we can heal from the past, create healthier patterns, and break cycles of trauma. Forrest and Dr. Buqué talk about what intergenerational trauma is, how we can “hand trauma down,” and how these problematic patterns show up i ... Show More
1h 19m
May 2023
Can You Detect Psychopathy From Pupil Dilation?
Healthy//ToxicHealthy versus Toxic is a podcast where licensed mental health professionals explore what makes a relationship healthy or unhealthy. Our hosts aim to provide a scientifically informed perspective on what factors go into making healthy relationships, how to build sec ... Show More
13m 22s
Apr 2023
Mental Health in the Workplace
Healthy//ToxicHealthy versus Toxic is a podcast where licensed mental health professionals explore what makes a relationship healthy or unhealthy. Our hosts aim to provide a scientifically informed perspective on what factors go into making healthy relationships, how to build sec ... Show More
23m 28s
Feb 2024
College Student Mental Health 101
Jeff talks to Dr. Sarah Ketchen Lipson about common mental health concerns for college students and they discuss tips for recognizing and addressing these challenges and the conditions they can lead to. Jeff also asks Sarah some audience questions about typical campus resources f ... Show More
58m 26s