logo
episode-header-image
Oct 2021
1h 5m

#107: The Barbie Doll Kidnapper (Case of...

STEPHANIE SOO
About this episode

“Big John” loved his little apartment. It wasn’t nice but it was his.

He was in his 40’s and he wanted to decorate it with whatever style he pleased. His bedroom was more of a game room with a mattress on the ground.

The walk-in closet was wall-to-wall with the newest and latest games. Nintendo games, board games, barbies, you name it. His drawers were stuffed full with candy and his mini-fridge only had soda in it.

The only thing is - none of these things were for Big John.


Book Rec: “Buried Memories” - by Katie Beers (Written by the victim of the crime - and how she recovered from such a traumatic event. Get your tissues ready)

Full Source Notes: rottenmangopodcast.com

Up next
Oct 9
“My Parents Were Pedophiles & Forced Me Into Being With Other Pedophiles”- A Day With Lisa Plumb
Family nudist camps. They’re real and exist today. Children are 100% allowed. Clothes are not. A lot of people wonder if it’s uncomfortable for children, which one camp addresses in their website’s FAQs: Q: Are children forced to be nude? A: The word “forced” is an emotionally lo ... Show More
1h 48m
Oct 5
I Saw Luigi Mangione In Court & This Is EVERYTHING That Happened
We went to see Luigi Mangione in court. September 16, 2025, in a New York State Courthouse, Mangione’s terrorism charges are dropped. The courtroom remains silent with court officers stationed at every corner. There are cheers from protestors right outside the courthouse. A stran ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 28
D4vd Uses Celeste’s Voice In New Songs Months Before Her Body Is Found? + New Updates From Police
It is not until Spetmber 17th, 2025 that the body found in D4vd’s Tesla is identified as 14 year old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. And she has been missing for over a year. The last time her family saw her in person seems to be in April of 2024 though her family has remained out of th ... Show More
2h 14m
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2021
8: #8: Crime Researcher Stalks Her New Neighbor After Believing He’s A Serial Killer (Book - Before She Knew Him)
Life was finally getting back to normal - she wasn’t staying up all night obsessing over details in unsolved murders anymore. She just moved into a new house.... But all of that comes to an end - when she finds a familiar trophy displayed on her neighbor’s bookshelf. The trophy l ... Show More
1h 25m
Sep 2021
Tall, Dark, and Shadowy - Listener Stories
Let's get spooky with some listener stories! Eileen has a story about something evil in the woods. Caleb tells us about a spooky house near the Bell Witch town. Brendan moved into a haunted apartment. Sherry saw a tall dark and shadowy figure. Sarah had a spooky doll and saw a le ... Show More
1h 29m
Jan 2024
EP46: Dollhouse of Death
Dolls, those eerie, lifeless figures designed to mimic human form, occupy a strange and unsettling place in our psyche, often stirring a blend of intrigue and fear. As rational adults, we typically view dolls as mere objects made of plastic, porcelain, or other synthetic material ... Show More
1h 19m
Nov 2020
169: What if you were an Adult Baby Diaper Lover?
“I would do everything I could that had to happen to engage with this object that I needed to do and then I would bury it….And I had to realize at a certain point that it was just not going to work.”Producers: Whit Missildine, Andrew WaitsEpisode Summary: At a young age, a man de ... Show More
39m 30s
Mar 2024
Dad accused of drugging daughter’s friends at sleepover; Reformed convict allegedly dismembers man
This Week on True Crime Daily The Podcast: A father charged with serving his daughter and her friends spiked smoothies during a sleepover. Plus, a reformed convict who appeared on Joe Rogan’s podcast arrested for a man’s brutal murder and dismemberment. Dr. Judy Ho joins host Ana ... Show More
1h 7m
Apr 2022
Mother stabbed, left in hockey bag by ex-lover; Father kills family and dog to 'save their souls'
This Week on True Crime Daily The Podcast: A mother stabbed in her Queens community and stuffed in a hockey bag. Police allege that after a heated argument ending their affair, her former handyman ended her life. Plus, a father turns his family home into a house of horrors. After ... Show More
57m 36s
Nov 2021
#251 - The Nightmare House - Fair Lawn, New Jersey
This week, in Fair Lawn, New Jersey, was it a random & vicious attack, or a family Thanksgiving, turned bloodbath? A woman found, in her own kitchen, bludgeoned & stabbed, with two knives still protruding from her back, and her family's story just isn't quite adding up. In additi ... Show More
2h 44m
Dec 2023
769: Funeral Confessions, Cookie Monster, & Progressive Flo
We're already preparing for 2024 (probably because 2023 was such a dud). Susie recommends the new Mike Birbiglia comedy special, The Old Man and the Pool, and discusses his sleep disorder that caused him to jump out of a La Quinta window while he was sleeping. Sarah is still reco ... Show More
1h 49m
Jun 2023
Protective Services
It was May of 1998 in the small town of Romeo, Michigan and a crew of detectives found themselves knee-deep in a hoarder’s nest. The once quaint home of the Verellen Sisters now resembled the inside of a dumpster. The whole house was littered with trash: greasy paper bags, half-e ... Show More
32m 59s