logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2021
2h 44m

#251 - The Nightmare House - Fair Lawn, ...

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this episode

This week, in Fair Lawn, New Jersey, was it a random & vicious attack, or a family Thanksgiving, turned bloodbath? A woman found, in her own kitchen, bludgeoned & stabbed, with two knives still protruding from her back, and her family's story just isn't quite adding up. In addition, it comes out that this isn't the first time something so horrific has happened in this very house. Another act of violence, committed by the dead woman's husband. In the end, fingers are pointed, and no one wants to take responsibility, but will this woman get any justice?

 

Along the way, we find out that judges think pregnant women can't leave the house, that some family holidays are worse than others, and that some houses may just be cursed!!

 

Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman

 

New episodes every Thursday!

 

Donate at: patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com & use our email: crimeinsports@gmail.com

 

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder & Crime In Sports!

 

Follow us on...

twitter.com/@murdersmall

facebook.com/smalltownpod

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

 

Also, check out James & Jimmie's other show, Crime In Sports! On iTunes, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Up next
Today
Strange Affairs & Frozen Blood - Pottstown, Pennsylvania
This week, in Pottstown, Pennsylvania, a twisted tale emerges, when a rich, brash local, with a million enemies, is found horribly murdered & frozen solid, in his own car. Detectives have a mess on their hands, comsidering the dead man's nephews was having an affair with his wife ... Show More
3 h
Oct 3
Murder In The Blood - Grasshopper Junction, Arizona
This week, in Grasshopper Junction, Arizona, a man tries to have a morning coffee, with his friends, who run the town's only restaurant, but discovers a bloody mess of a scene, with their brutally murdered bodies. At the same time, a pair of brothers, on the run from the law in A ... Show More
1h 11m
Oct 2
The Murder And The Miracle - Mont Vernon, New Hampshire
This week, in Mont Vernon, New Hampshire, a comfy country home is the setting for a terrible massacre, causing detectives to be suspicious of the spouse, only to find out that it’s actually a much darker plot. A group of teens, calling themselves "Disciples of Destruction" set ou ... Show More
2h 57m
Recommended Episodes
Apr 2023
#437: Who Killed 3 Young Sisters in Texas | Part 1
On a hot summer night last July in a small town in east Texas, sisters Zi’Ariel Robinson-Oliver, 9, A’Miyah Hughes, 8, and Te’Mari Robinson-Oliver, 5, were reported missing by their babysitter. Their mother Shommaonique Oliver-Wickerson rushed home from work to find the Cass Coun ... Show More
30m 25s
Jan 2018
Murders That Created Laws
In this episode we're doing something a little different. We're discussing two different cases that resulted in laws being created to help protect children. Megan Kanka was murdered in 1994 by a repeat child sex offender who lived across the street from the Kanka family. Unfortun ... Show More
1h 15m
Oct 2020
#281: American Murder: The Family Next Door, Part 4
Laura, Jim and Lisa are joined by special guest Jenny Popplewell, the Director of the #1 Netflix show American Murder: The Family Next Door.Jenny takes us behind the scenes and explains why this case spoke to her as well as the gender bias in the media on reporting on domestic vi ... Show More
36m 24s
Oct 2017
The Amityville Murders
In a TCATT first, for our Halloween episodes we're combining True Crime All The Time and True Crime All The Time Unsolved. This episode of True Crime All The Time deals with the DeFeo Murders that took place in Amityville, NY. The TCATT Unsolved episode follows up with the result ... Show More
1h 11m
Jan 2017
Listener Hometown #1 Jorden
On September 2nd, 2016 Kody Lott allegedly gunned down one precious 13 year old girl and wounded another in Wichita Falls, TX. We use the word allegedly only because he has yet to be tried and convicted. He has admitted to the crimes. The circumstances, details, and motives behin ... Show More
1h 12m
Jul 2019
The Cheshire Murders
Bill Petit and his wife Jennifer Hawke-Petit had built a wonderful life. They lived in the upscale neighborhood of Cheshire, Connecticut with their two amazing daughters 17-year-old Hayley and 11-year-old Michaela. In 2007, Jennifer and Michaela were at the grocery when they caug ... Show More
1h 17m
May 2022
#167: The Deadly Housewives of Missouri (Case of Betsy Faria & Pam Hupp)
Pam was a normal housewife, she had a nice husband, and a job in the insurance industry. Everything about her was normal.Except, the dead body in her hallway.She had been ambushed in her own home and shot her attacker.When the police arrive they find the attacker had no ID, but a ... Show More
1h 40m
May 2023
#439: Menendez + Menudo: Boys Betrayed | Part 1
There are high profile cases you think you know, but the truth is far more nuance, complicated and terrible than anything the media could ever cover during a headline making trial. On the evening of June 20th 1989, Lyle Menendez (21) and his brother Erik Menendez (18) shot their ... Show More
37m 18s
May 2023
#440: Menendez + Menudo: Boys Betrayed | Part 2 (BONUS)
Lisa and Jim pick up where their conversation left off, breaking down the details of the Menendez case and posing questions about the events. There are so many things that have been buried in the past three decades, there is a lot to discuss. You can watch the entire first 1993 t ... Show More
30m 25s
Jun 2018
The Murders of Christopher Newsom and Channon Christian
Christopher Newsom and Channon Christian were on their way to a party on the night of January 6th, 2007 when they were carjacked at gunpoint. The couple, who had only been dating a short time, would be taken to a house of horrors. The crimes committed against this couple were ext ... Show More
1h 27m