It’s Episode 457 and we’re wishing Gio a very happy 10th birthday! Today Em brings us to Christine’s hometown for the very haunted Cincinnati Music Hall. Then Christine covers the case of Little Miss Lake Panasoffkee now known as Maureen “Cookie” Rowan as she’s just been identified after 55 years! And please don’t leave your buckets of formaldehyde gel layin ... Show More
Mar 2025
Episode 335: The Murder of Madalyn Murray O’Hair – Part 1
Critics called her rude, blasphemous, a destroyer of beliefs and values who popped off like a chain of fireworks in a church. The progressive activism of this lawyer, veteran, mom, fighter, and fan of four-letter-words earned her the nickname The Most Hated Woman in America. This ... Show More
1h 23m
Jul 2024
Grandpa Murdered Grandma
<p dir="ltr">An heirloom ring, a tiny island in the middle of a lake, a tragic murder, a malfunctioning gun, addiction, rehab, recovery, long-distance love, poetry. It's the kind of story a true crime podcast could easily spend an entire season on. But we only get one hour with t ... Show More
1h 19m
Feb 2025
Mackenzie Undercover: The Garage Sale
<p>Happy Monday, Sleuthies! It’s a <em>Mackenzie Undercover</em> day, and trust us, you need this one. Today, Mackenzie takes us deep into one of her wildest surveillance cases—except the real story wasn’t even about her original subject. Instead, it led her straight into the dra ... Show More
1h 3m