logo
episode-header-image
May 2017
1h 1m

#19 - Two Deaths, One Unexpected Murdere...

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this episode

This week, we take a peek at the rural town of Eldorado, Illinois, where the successful, and beloved town doctor tries to keep some gruesome family secrets, causing the town to rally behind him, and be horrified by the results of the trial. Along the way, we find out what a "sundown town" is & why it's scary, just how many floats can possibly be in a small town's parade, and how many family members you can kill, in the same manner, before someone starts to catch on!!

Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman


New episodes every Thursday!!

Please subscribe, rate, and review!

Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts!

Head to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder!

For merchandise: crimeinsports.threadless.com

Check out James and Jimmie's other show: Crime in Sports

Follow us on social media!

Facebook: facebook.com/smalltownpod

Instagram: instagram.com/smalltownmurder

Twitter: twitter.com/MurderSmall

Contact the show: crimeinsports@gmail.com


Up next
Today
Deadly Deeds With Dad - Wallburg, North Carolina
This week, in Wallburg, North Carolina, a twisted story unfolds when a seeming fairy tale relationship, between an Irish widower, and his American au pair, ends with bloodshed, lies, and a father/daughter team that stick to their stories, amongst increasingly incriminating facts. ... Show More
3h 3m
Jan 10
The Deadly Grandma & The Doppelgänger - Austin, Arkansas
This week, in Austin, Arkansas, a lonely widow finds a new love, but when the he goes missing, police start to become suspicious. Especially since neighbors say she's had fires going, over a hole in the yard for months. Detectives then make a shocking discovery, that brings her f ... Show More
1h 11m
Jan 8
Panty Sniffing Wife Killer - Greeley, Colorado
This week, in Greeley, Colorado, a woman disappears, leaving detectives to suspect her soon to be ex husband, but just can't find the evidence. The case to goes cold, whille the husband continues on one of the strangest crime sprees, ever. Will they be able to prosecute, or is it ... Show More
3h 2m
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2022
EP. 92 OREGON - Christian Longo: Family Annihilator
On December 19th, 2001, the body of a small child, wearing nothing but underwear, was found in the Alesa River in the Oregon town of Waldport. Little did anyone know at the time that the little boy’s death was not the result of an accident, nor that the rest of little Zachary’s f ... Show More
1h 40m
Feb 2015
Poster Boy
On July 17th, 1889, the residents of Clayton County, Iowa woke up to news of the worst crime in their history. A Civil War veteran John Elkins and his young wife Hattie had been murdered in their bed in a grisly attack. Their two children escaped to raise the alarm. But something ... Show More
18m 37s
Nov 2022
EP. 88 ILLINOIS - John Wayne Gacy (PT. 3): Arrest, Trial, & Execution
With a victim count totalling 32 in the summer of 1978, there was one more life that John Wayne Gacy would take before his rein of terror would come to an end. When Robert Piest, a beloved honors student, went missing in December 1978 the police would soon zero in on the man resp ... Show More
1h 32m
Oct 2017
The Amityville Murders
<p>In a TCATT first, for our Halloween episodes we're combining True Crime All The Time and True Crime All The Time Unsolved. This episode of True Crime All The Time deals with the DeFeo Murders that took place in Amityville, NY. The TCATT Unsolved episode follows up with the res ... Show More
1h 11m