logo
episode-header-image
Apr 2017
1h 4m

#13 - Murder Bubbling Under The Surface ...

James Pietragallo, Jimmie Whisman
About this episode

This week, we look at the close knit town of Old Orchard Beach, Maine, where a young man's murderous urges went unnoticed, until it was too late. His actions would shock everyone, and leave nothing the same in this beach community.Along the way, we see why it's so dangerous to grow apples, how much cocaine can be bought with enough money for a trip to England, and how many flags you have to sell to be able to send a child to college!!

Hosted by James Pietragallo & Jimmie Whisman


New episodes every Thursday!!

Please subscribe, rate, and review!

Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, or wherever you listen to podcasts!

Head to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder!

For merchandise: crimeinsports.threadless.com

Check out James and Jimmie's other show: Crime in Sports

Follow us on social media!

Facebook: facebook.com/smalltownpod

Instagram: instagram.com/smalltownmurder

Twitter: twitter.com/MurderSmall

Contact the show: crimeinsports@gmail.com


Up next
Nov 22
A Deadly Blame Game - Pierre, South Dakota
<p>This week, in Pierre, South Dakota, an affair turns into a need for a divorce, which leads to a woman, disappearing. She leaves her phone, purse & car, but she's nowhere to be found. Detectives look to her new boyfriend, but eventually blame the husband, claiming it was a brut ... Show More
1h 11m
Nov 20
Murder For My Love - Lynchburg, Virginia
<p>This week, in Lynchburg, Virginia, when a powerful couple is brutally murdered, in their home, detectives don't have a lot to work with, besides some bloody footprints, and blood from an unknown source. According to their daughter, they have a million enemies, ranging from ang ... Show More
3h 3m
Nov 15
Deadly Dark Delusions - Lashmeet, West Virginia
<p>This week, in Lashmeet, West Virginia, a sudden, and brutal murder may have been brought on by a very strange living arrangement, involving a woman, her boyfriend, and her ex-husband, One day, both the woman, and her boyfriend begin drinking, in the morning. This leads to argu ... Show More
1h 13m
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2018
Bank Robbery, My Personal Story Collaboration with Morf from Criminology | Murderish BONUS EPISODE
In this episode of Murderish, Jami teams up with Mike Morford (“Morf”) who co-hosts the Criminology podcast. Jami tells Morf her personal story about going through an armed takeover robbery at a Bank for which she use to work. Mike and Jami also talk about true crime cases, which ... Show More
1h 27m
Jun 2023
Al Capone, Eliot Ness, and Cleveland’s Torso Murderer
In 1934, a man collecting driftwood along the Lake Erie shore found a human torso on the beach. No one could figure out what had happened. Over the next several years, more bodies were discovered. Eventually, a coroner assembled something he called the “Torso Clinic” to work on t ... Show More
40m 40s
May 2022
Jill & Kirstie Foster: Familicide丨MURDERISH Ep. 110
When a family’s financial situation drastically improves, temptation can lurk around every corner. And sometimes, outward appearances completely obscure a less glamorous reality. Chris Foster of Lancashire, England had known a working-class lifestyle for most of his adulthood. In ... Show More
1h 3m
Apr 2022
Pat Tillman: “Humble Hero”丨MURDERISH Ep. 108
Pat Tillman was a star in his hometown of San Jose, California. He was an accomplished and envied athlete who led his high school team to a Central Coast Division I Football Championship, even after being told he was too small to play football. But Pat wasn’t a stereotypical high ... Show More
43m 1s
Dec 2022
Dr. Thomas Burchard: “Killing Kindness” | MURDERISH Ep. 125
Kelsey Turner was the kind of woman who drew people in without trying. Her bleach-blonde hair and hourglass figure made her a natural model. In a sea of beautiful California women, though, modeling gigs weren’t plentiful enough to support her expensive tastes. Like many young wom ... Show More
41m 13s
Apr 2014
Dropping Like Flies
Every year for the past few years, tens of thousand of flytraps have gone missing – from the wild, from gardens, from nurseries. And, really, nobody knows where they go. What’s cropped up in rural North Carolina is essentially a Venus Flytrap crime ring — with lackies, middle men ... Show More
23m 30s
Jun 2022
Wendy DiRodio: “Deadly Envy” | MURDERISH Ep. 112
At 61 years old, Wendy DiRodio’s life was just getting started. An accomplished author, therapist and dance instructor, she was ready to excel in the only part of life where success had escaped her: love. She’d begun dating a handsome younger man; there was even talk of marriage. ... Show More
55m 4s
Feb 2015
Poster Boy
On July 17th, 1889, the residents of Clayton County, Iowa woke up to news of the worst crime in their history. A Civil War veteran John Elkins and his young wife Hattie had been murdered in their bed in a grisly attack. Their two children escaped to raise the alarm. But something ... Show More
18m 37s
Sep 2015
No Place Like Home
In the early 90s, a wealthy magazine publisher was convicted of fraud and sentenced to 18 months in a minimum security prison in Louisiana. But white collar criminals weren't the only people living there, and the other people inside had basically been forgotten about by the outsi ... Show More
25m 59s