logo
episode-header-image
Dec 2017
1h 11m

Episode 29, Stephen Law and 'The Evil-Go...

Jack Symes | Andrew Horton, Oliver Marley, and Rose de Castellane
About this episode

This episode is proudly supported by New College of the Humanities. To find out more about the college and their philosophy programmes, please visit www.nchlondon.ac.uk/panpsycast. Everything you could need is on www.thepanpsycast.com! Please tweet us your thoughts at www.twitter.com/thepanpsycast. Dr Stephen Law is a Reader in philosophy at Heythrop College, University of London, and editor of the Royal Institute of Philosophy journal THINK. Amongst many other books, Stephen Law is the author of A Very Short Introduction to Humanism, The War for Children's Minds, The Philosophy Gym, and Believing Bullshit: How Not to Get Sucked into an Intellectual Black Hole. Stephen Law has debated many Christian philosophers, including William Lane Craig, John Lennox and Alvin Plantinga. Our central focus today is Law's main argument against the existence of God – 'The Evil-God Challenge'. The evil-god challenge can be stated as follows: why should we consider the hypothesis that there exists a good-god, significantly more reasonable than the hypothesis that there exists an evil-god? Part I. The Evil-God Challenge (start of Part I), Part II. Further Analysis and Discussion (start of Part II).

Up next
Nov 16
Episode 149, 'The Philosophy of Jainism' with Marie-Hélène Gorisse (Part I - Liberation)
<p class="">Jainism, along with Buddhism and Hinduism, is one of India's great dharmic traditions – though far less well known than its siblings. Emerging around the second century BCE, it is best-known for valuing ahimsa in pursuit of liberation – a devout practice of non-violen ... Show More
34m 33s
Nov 2
Episode 148, 'Divine Commands' with Paul Taylor (Part II - Further Analysis and Discussion)
Most people believe in moral facts – that is, there's something about torturing and murdering innocent people that makes it wrong, which goes beyond just a feeling. Yet it's hard to locate morality anywhere in the natural world. For this reason, many have understood God to be the ... Show More
37m 53s
Oct 19
Episode 148, 'Divine Commands' with Paul Taylor (Part I - The Euthyphro Dilemma)
Most people believe in moral facts – that is, there's something about torturing and murdering innocent people that makes it wrong, which goes beyond just a feeling. Yet it's hard to locate morality anywhere in the natural world. For this reason, many have understood God to be the ... Show More
31m 41s
Recommended Episodes
Jul 2023
The new 10 commandments | Massimo Pigliucci, Simon Baron-Cohen, Sophie Grace Chapel
Are we bound by traditional rules for life or is it time for a new playbook? Tune in to find out!Seeking the link mentioned in this episode? It's right here: https://linktr.ee/philosophyforourtimesIn this thought-provoking discussion, our distinguished panelists delve into the fo ... Show More
43m 43s
Jul 2024
Is our metaphysics beholden to common sense? | Fragments and reality with Michael Della Rocca, Timothy Maudlin, Kathleen Higgins
Should we follow our philosophical conclusions wherever they take us? Or is there a hard wall of common sense that we are beholden to?Listen to some of today's leading philosophers in science and metaphysics as they talk it out!Tim Maudlin is Professor of Philosophy at New York U ... Show More
42m 6s
Nov 2024
Ep. 354: Guest Tim Williamson on Philosophic Method (Part One)
<p>Oxford philosophy professor Timothy Williamson talks to us about his new book, <em>Overfitting and Heuristics in Philosophy</em>.</p> <p>How can we best apply the insights of philosophy of science to philosophy itself? Maybe some alleged philosophical counter-examples are just ... Show More
42m 33s
Jan 2025
Ancient solutions for modern problems | Stoicism Series PART 2 | Massimo Pigliucci
How to be a StoicWhat can Zeno of Citium teach you about going to the movie theatre?Join philosopher and author Massimo Pigliucci for part two of a series on the ancient practice of Stoicism, exploring and analysing ideas from Seneca, Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus, and Zeno of Citiu ... Show More
20m 44s
Apr 2022
Episode 5 - Un XXème siècle inspirant - Sartre et De Beauvoir
<p>Philosophy Is Sexy n’est pas qu’un podcast, c’est une parenthèse intime, un pas de côté, pour oser la philosophie, la désacraliser, la remettre au cœur de notre vie et se laisser inspirer. Marie Robert, auteure du best-seller traduit en quinze langues, "Kant tu ne sais plus qu ... Show More
25m 41s
Mar 2022
Episode 3 - Un XXème siècle inspirant - Russell et le cercle de Vienne
<p>Philosophy Is Sexy n’est pas qu’un podcast, c’est une parenthèse intime, un pas de côté, pour oser la philosophie, la désacraliser, la remettre au cœur de notre vie et se laisser inspirer. Marie Robert, auteure du best-seller traduit en quinze langues, "Kant tu ne sais plus qu ... Show More
17m 25s
Jan 2025
Ancient solutions for modern problems | Stoicism Series PART 1 | Massimo Pigliucci
How to be a StoicWhat can Marcus Aurelius teach you about the iPhone?Join philosopher and author Massimo Pigliucci for part one of a series on the ancient practice of Stoicism, exploring and analysing ideas from Seneca, Marcus Aurelius, Epictetus, and Zeno of Citium.Massimo Pigli ... Show More
19m 10s
Sep 2024
478. Heaven, Hell, & the Human Condition | Jack Symes
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson sits down with author and philosopher Jack Symes. They discuss the ability of man to conceptualize God, the arguments for and against both an evil God and a perfect God, the evidence for a transcendent good to exist, and why happiness and suffering are the ... Show More
1h 38m
Mar 2025
#100 Philosopher Shootout - 16 Thinkers, Ranked (With Joe Folley)
<p>For episode 100 of Within Reason, I'm joined by Joe Folley, from the YouTube Channel <a class="mention-chip ytcp-social-suggestion-input" href="https://www.youtube.com/@unsolicitedadvice9198">"Unsolicited Advice"</a>, to tackle a completely arbitrary and ridiculous tournament ... Show More
3h 8m
Dec 2023
#48 Edward Feser - Aristotle's Argument for God
<p>Edward Feser is an American Catholic philosopher, and Associate Professor of Philosophy at Pasadena City College in California.</p> <p>He is the author of "<a href="https://amzn.to/41oA2ue">Five Proofs of the Existence of God</a>", and in this episode speaks about one of these ... Show More
1h 33m