logo
episode-header-image
Nov 2020
45m 25s

S1 Ep3: Elma Sands: The Manhattan Well M...

Amber Hunt and Audioboom
About this episode
When a 22-year-old woman living with relatives in a boarding house disappeared on Dec. 22, 1799, her loved ones didn't immediately worry. But when she still hadn't returned days later, all eyes turned to her lover -- whom she'd supposedly been set to marry the last time she was seen alive. Levi Weeks came from a family with money, so his rich brother did something that was unheard of at this point in American history: He hired fancy lawyers. And that's how Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr ended up on the same side defending a man against murder charges in 1800. 

The case, referenced in Lin Manuel Miranda's award-winning musical "Hamilton," marks two firsts: The defense panel was America's first legal Dream Team, and the Weeks' case was the first recorded murder trial in the country's history.

"Crimes of the Centuries" is a new podcast from the Obsessed Network exploring forgotten crimes from times past that made a mark and helped change history.

Follow us on Instagram and Twitter: @centuriespod
Up next
Jul 7
S5 Ep17: Faith Vs. Flag: How the Gobitis Case Tested the Limits of Religious Freedom
In 1935, 12-year-old Lillian Gobitas and her little brother William were kicked out of their Pennsylvania public school — not for misbehaving, but for quietly refusing to salute the flag, which they believed went against their Jehovah’s Witness faith. Their dad sued, arguing the ... Show More
49m 35s
Jun 30
The Murder of Phil Hartman
Crimes Of The Centuries is dark again this week, so here is an episode that you might not have heard previously... or might just want to listen to again. When news spread that a high-profile comedian was killed in a murder-suicide in 1998, the response was disbelief: Phil Hartman ... Show More
38m 5s
Jun 23
Guest Episode: The Wild Tale of Black Jack Ketchum
While Crimes of the Centuries takes a brief summer break, enjoy a guest episode from Josh at The Wild West Extravaganza. This one’s a doozy: It’s the story of "Black Jack" Ketchum — a train robber whose criminal exploits made headlines across the American frontier. But it was his ... Show More
30m 6s
Recommended Episodes
Dec 2016
E25: Gulielma Sands - The Manhattan Well Mystery
Three days before Christmas in 1799, a young woman named Gulielma Sands disappears the night she reveals she is to marry Levi Weeks. Her lifeless body is found in a Manhattan well on January 2nd not far from her boardinghouse on Greenwich Street, New York City. When Levi was arre ... Show More
51m 56s
Jun 2021
Murder: a legal history
Kate Morgan chronicles the legal history of murder, discussing the cases that shaped UK murder laws Lawyer and writer Kate Morgan chronicles the legal history of murder, and explores the roles killers, victims, lawyers and judges have played in making UK murder law what it is tod ... Show More
43m 44s
Nov 2022
L'Affaire Menendez : des crimes à Beverly Hills • Episode 1 sur 2
Dans la soirée du 21 août 1989, le 911 de Los Angeles reçoit l’appel d’un jeune homme paniqué et en pleurs. Il s’appelle Lyle Menendez, il a 21 ans et il vient de découvrir les corps inertes de ses deux parents. Avec lui se trouve son frère, Erik, âgé seulement de 19 ans. C’est l ... Show More
12m 58s
Nov 2022
L'Affaire Menendez : des crimes à Beverly Hills • Episode 2 sur 2
Dans la soirée du 21 août 1989, le 911 de Los Angeles reçoit l’appel d’un jeune homme paniqué et en pleurs. Il s’appelle Lyle Menendez, il a 21 ans et il vient de découvrir les corps inertes de ses deux parents. Avec lui se trouve son frère, Erik, âgé seulement de 19 ans. C’est l ... Show More
14m 29s
Oct 2022
Unsolved Murders: Theodosia Burr
Aaron Burr is most infamous for killing Alexander Hamilton in a duel. But Burr was also a father — one whose daughter, Theodosia, vanished one night at sea. No one can say for sure what happened to her ship, The Patriot, or its passengers... though a centuries-old portrait may ho ... Show More
44m 31s
Dec 2022
EP. 91 ILLINOIS - Drew Peterson (PT 2): The Killer Cop
Throughout his life, Drew Peterson was known as a womanizer, a fact that would eventually lead to the divorce from his third wife, Kathleen Savio, after his affair with 17-year-old Stacy Cales came to light. During Drew and Kathleen’s tumultuous divorce, and coincidentally right ... Show More
1h 13m
Apr 2024
The 1921 Murder Farm Massacre: Slavery After the Civil War
During the spring of 1921, eleven bodies were found in in rural Georgia. These men were victims of horrific murders, and also of a more widespread crime - peonage. Whilst enslavement had legally ended with the surrender at Appomattox and the 13th Amendment, black people across th ... Show More
25m 42s
Feb 2024
The People v. Levi Weeks
In early 1800, Levi Weeks went on trial for the murder of Elma Sands. Rumor had it that Weeks and Sands had been lovers, until something went tragically wrong. But at the trial, where Weeks was defended by Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr, a much more complicated story emerged…S ... Show More
1h 3m
Jun 2023
170. Mabel Greineder - The Park Murder
On this episode of MWMH, Payton and Garrett discuss the murder of Mabel Greineder while she was walking her dog with her husband. https://linktr.ee/murderwithmyhusband Case Sources:A Murder in Wellesley: The Inside Story of an Ivy-League Doctor's Double Life, His Slain Wife, and ... Show More
37m 26s