logo
episode-header-image
May 2020
1h 12m

Shawna Nelson

Emash Digital / Wondery
About this episode

Ignacio and Heather Garraus had made a great life for themselves in Greeley, Colorado. But, in 2004, Ignacio, a Greeley police officer, began an affair with a police dispatcher named Shawna Nelson. When Ignacio ended the affair, years later, Shawna didn't take it well. She set out to take out the one person whom she felt stood in her way of having a life with Ignancio and their son.

Join Mike and Gibby as they talk about this love triangle that turned deadly. Shawna Nelson was willing to commit the ultimate sin to get what she wanted. She murdered Heather Garraus because she felt like she was standing in her way of having that life. But, the lengths that Shawna went to were shocking. The planning, the alibi, some of which Shawna pointed at her own husband as the killer.

You can help support the show at patreon.com/truecrimeallthetime

Visit the show's website at truecrimeallthetime.com for contact, merchandise and donation information


An Emash Digital Production

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Up next
Jul 7
Edward Cairney and Avril Jones
In the late ‘90s, Margaret Fleming was living under the care of Edward Cairney and Avril Jones, friends of her deceased father. In October 2016, the police launched an investigation when concerns were raised about a benefits claim made by Avril on Margaret’s behalf. Join Mike and ... Show More
1h 2m
Jun 30
Nancy Brophy
Nancy Brophy is a former author who wrote romantic suspense novels. She once wrote an essay on how to get away with murder. When her husband was found murdered, Nancy quickly became the prime suspect.Join Mike and Gibby as they discuss Nancy Brophy. Prosecutors believed she spent ... Show More
1h 9m
Jun 23
Stephen Marshall
In March and April 2009, a man’s dismembered remains were scattered across two counties in England. The “jigsaw man,” as the media called the victim, was identified as 49-year-old Jeffrey Howe. The main suspect was his roommate and “best friend,” Stephen Marshall. Join Mike and G ... Show More
58m 56s
Recommended Episodes
Jun 2023
MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Shawn O’Brien
When Shawn O’Brien is found unconscious in his Cranston, RI, apartment and dies days later in the hospital, the unusual circumstances spark suspicions of foul play. But the investigation quickly stalls out, leaving a grieving family searching for answers on their own.If you have ... Show More
1h 12m
Dec 2020
S1 Ep4: The Guy Family Murders (Part I)
It was the morning of November 28th 2012 when Deputy Steven Ballard of the Knox County Sheriffs Office paid a visit to 11434 Goldenview Lane in Knoxville Tennessee. He was there to perform a welfare check on its inhabitants and his body cam was on and recording as he pulled up to ... Show More
49m 37s
Oct 2020
Farmer joins search for woman after allegedly burying body; ex-candidate arrested in cold case
An Arkansas farmer accused of striking a female jogger with his pickup truck, sexually assaulting her, then burying her body in a field reportedly joined a community search for the victim days afterward. Investigators say Quake Lewellyn, who is married, and Sydney Sutherland knew ... Show More
53 m
Sep 2023
Johnny Clarke & Lisa Straub - 538
On January 31st, 2011 Johnny Clarke and Lisa Straub were found dead inside Lisa’s home. Their hands were bound, and plastic bags were taped over their heads. The murder was carefully planned, and the house was ransacked in such a way that it seemed like the intruders were looking ... Show More
52m 35s
Apr 2018
Cold Case
In 1984, Sheila Wysocki found herself helping the police investigate the murder of her college roommate, Angela Samota. Detectives asked her to help gather information, and even sent her out to dinner with the main suspect, a man named Russell Buchanan. But the case remained unso ... Show More
37m 59s
Nov 2023
Did She Marry an Ax Murderer? Part 1
Sometimes the person you love isn't who you think they are. Sharon Krauseneck says she and her husband Jim were happily married. But in 2016, to Sharon's surprise, her husband's alleged dark past caught up to him. In 1982, Jim's first wife, Cathy, was murdered with an ax lodged i ... Show More
33m 14s
Jan 2024
#485: Amanda Knox Slander Trial in Italy | Part 2
We continue our discussion of Amanda Knox’ upcoming retrial in Italy for slander against her former boss, Le Chic Bar owner Patrick Lumumba. When the police interrogated Amanda they told her to sign two police written statements, just hours apart. Amanda has always maintained she ... Show More
37m 21s
Mar 2024
Post Mortem | The Monica Sementilli Affair
Since 2018, Correspondent Michelle Miller and Producer Greg Fisher have reported on the murder of celebrity hair stylist and beauty executive, Fabio Sementilli. They go behind the scenes of their jailhouse interview with Rob Baker, who is serving a life sentence for murder, the l ... Show More
30m 16s