logo
episode-header-image
Aug 2016
1h 3m

Episode 72

Sword and Scale
About this episode
A recurring question in the criminal justice system is whether the death penalty is moral, right or just. Everyone seems to have a fairly strong opinion regarding it, but almost no one has any any first-hand experience with the process. The idea that such a severe punishment to be conducted in secrecy, behind closed doors, may seem archaic and somewhat medieval. In this episode we talk to a man named Dr. Bill Kimberlin, who did something few others would. He actively attempted to attend an execution, and in fact has seen three of them conducted. He also has extensive knowledge of the death row system in the state of Ohio and describes the cushy life that the worst criminals in our society enjoy. We also revisit the Rodney Reed case and get an update on its state of limbo a full year after we first reported the story to you.

Get instant access to all episodes, including premium unreleased episodes, commercial-free at swordandscale.com
Up next
Nov 17
Episode 328
In a quiet Ohio town shaped by coal and tradition, Brad McGarry is found dead in his basement. At first, it looks like a break-in. But as detectives dig deeper, they uncover a complex friendship, a hidden relationship, and a web of lies that unravels in the interrogation room. Th ... Show More
1h 8m
Nov 6
Episode 327
When Kajavia Globe disappeared, her family’s worst fears came true in a city hardened by loss. As frustration with police mounted, the community - neighbors, a sanitation worker, a mother who refused to give up - kept pushing forward. In the end, justice came not from the system, ... Show More
58m 1s
Nov 2
Episode 326
A night of celebration at a remote cabin takes a horrifying turn when a fight breaks out and a young father steps in to calm things down. Within moments, the party descends into chaos, and a single act of violence changes lives forever.Get instant access to all episodes, includin ... Show More
1h 16m
Recommended Episodes
Oct 2023
#469: Convicting a Murderer | Part 2
<p>We continue analyzing Teresa Halbach's murder and the behavior of Steven Avery who was convicted in 2007 for her killing along with his nephew Brendan Dassey. They are both currently serving life sentences in Wisconsin. Filmmaker Shawn Rech’s new series “Convicting A Murderer” ... Show More
32m 47s
Feb 2023
The Murdaugh Murders: A Defense Perspective on the Trial
<p>We are sharing our conversation with a veteran criminal defense attorney from the western half of the country about a high-profile case. Our guest has 25 years of experience, and has worked on a number of high profile cases. He will share his thoughts on the ongoing trial agai ... Show More
53m 38s
Aug 2023
A Conversation with "Mr. Murder": David Hennessy on Homicide, Justice, and the Convictions that Haunt Him
<p>David Hennesy is a legendary figure&nbsp;in Indiana legal circles. A long time attorney, he&nbsp;has done criminal defense work for 40 years — and in that time, as you will hear, he estimates that he has won 100 murder cases. Perhaps that is part of the reason people have give ... Show More
1h 12m
Aug 2023
Offbeat: True Crime Story Time
<p><em>Offbeat</em> is <em>The Murder Sheet's </em>audio opinion column. It's where we give you our takes on topics in crime. In this episode, we'll talk about our collective bias toward interesting stories, the shortcomings of storytelling in the true crime genre, and how it inf ... Show More
54m 26s
Sep 2018
Episode #2 - A Suspect is Charged
After a 14-month hunt for Jessica Chambers’ killer, an arrest is made. Many are surprised to learn who investigators believe to be behind her murder. Hosted by Beth Karas, in this episode investigators explain why they believe they have the right person. It also includes interrog ... Show More
36m 19s
Sep 2018
Episode #4 - Crime Scene Chaos
Testimony continues in the trial for the murder of Jessica Chambers. In this episode, jurors take a field trip to the scene of the crime. Plus, host Beth Karas speaks with a fire expert who explains the process of recovering evidence after a fire and a DNA expert who has reviewed ... Show More
37m 45s
Dec 2023
Breaking Badness: Conviction | 1
Former homicide detective Gary Jubelin walks into the maximum security Macquarie prison, facing up to the kind of criminals he used to put inside there. An old friend once told him they breed animals in prison - but this is something different. Subscribe to Crime X+ to hear episo ... Show More
28m 3s
Dec 2023
Ep. 11 | What’s Wrong with Vince?
In the spring of 2009, Dr. Benjamin Gilmer takes over a country medical practice in Fletcher, North Carolina. His predecessor is no longer running the clinic because he’s serving a life sentence for murdering his father. But, as Benjamin learns more about the case, he begins to w ... Show More
32m 32s
Mar 2023
The Real Killer Season 2, Ep. 6: This Is My Life
The 1989 murder case which sent Keith LaMar to prison in the first place comes into question when discrepancies in his story are discovered. But does what happened back then have any bearing on his death row case?See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information. 
25m 57s
Sep 2018
Episode #3 - Trial Underway
Testimony begins in the murder trial of Quinton Tellis, accused of killing Jessica. Host Beth Karas recaps those first days of the trial including first responder’s emotional testimony as they recount the chaotic scene for jurors and testify that Jessica named her killer. Plus, a ... Show More
34m 50s